(All names have been changed.)
It’s 2 a.m. on a cold winter night. After a long day of school, after-school clubs, homework and cramming for tests, I finally get to sleep.
But then the phone rings. It’s Jane. “He broke up with me!” she sobs. “Oh God, Russell, what should I do?” Sigh. Yet another late-night phone call about yet another guy. What caused it now? He’s being insensitive again?
I listen for more than an hour and give advice for 20 minutes. The talk ends with a, “Russell, you are so right! Thank you.”
3:45 am. Sigh.
The Male Pal’s Perspective
While some guys are on the phone with their girlfriends, scheduling booty calls, I’m busy running a Men Are From Mars, Women Are From Venus seminar.
Yes, I am the platonic male friend. Every girl has to have at least one non-gay male pal to whom they aren’t attracted and consider “just a friend.” We’re there for women when they need a sensitive guy’s perspective on the male mind.
I’m your average guy, with some of the stereotypical hobbies the title holds. I’m a huge sports and music fan, and I have my “boys” who I can always depend on for immature conversations about women. (“Damn, yo, she’s hot!”)
But I have more female than male friends. Women seem to be able to open up to me because, in some ways, I’m not like many guys. I genuinely like listening to someone’s problems and don’t see the extreme importance of getting into a girl’s pants as opposed to her head.
A Sensitive Listener
I mean, sex doesn’t necessarily require much thought and emotion. But being able to delve into what a woman really thinks and feels is more challenging. And I like a good challenge.
So with my female friends, I play the role of listener-calm, patient and sensitive to their trials. I sometimes seek their advice, but more often block out my own problems by helping them deal with theirs.
Being friends with females has opened my eyes to aspects of womanhood that I probably wouldn’t have recognized just hanging out with my “boys.” I take pride in knowing that, compared to guys I know, I’m very aware of and sympathetic to women’s emotions. It’s like I’m one of their girlfriends who’s lucky enough not to go through menstruation (but still able to hear about the gory details).
Yet being the caring, considerate platonic friend isn’t always all it’s cracked up to be. Sure I get insight into the inner workings of the female mind, but sometimes I ask myself, “Do I really want to be there?”
In the Bedroom
One spring Saturday, Tatiana called me up. “Russell, come on over,” she said. “We can chill at my house, and you could give me some advice on what I should change about my approach to men.” (It seems that some women believe that there’s only one approach towards all men, like a one-step Idiot’s Guide to Getting With Your Dream Guy.)
OK, so I’m at her house, and in sacred territory at that: her bedroom. Her parents are out for the weekend, so we’re alone. To the average, hormonally imbalanced teenage male, this would be a dream opportunity.
But I’m the platonic male friend. So instead of having a romantic evening, I’m sitting next to her on her bed watching Sex and the City videos. Following a speech by Sarah Jessica Parker, Tatiana suddenly says, “Oh, I just have to show you this. It’s really important to me. Oh, this thing has got me through some really tough times.”
Strange Moving Object
I’m thinking it must be a family relic, or some memento from a past boyfriend. Then she takes out a long, black, narrow box. Hmm, maybe it’s a necklace. I turn around for a second to look at the TV, then turn back as she hands me this strange-looking object.
“What the-?! Is that what I think it is?” I stutter, eyeing the long, metallic object.
“Yeah, it’s great, isn’t it? Damn, I think the batteries are running low.”
Holding it from the tip, I realize what it is-and where it’s been-and drop it on the bed. A low humming sound starts to fill the room. “Ha! Yeah, great,” I say as I slowly make a break for the door. A vibrator. Like I needed to see that.
It didn’t help that I initially became friends with Tatiana because I wanted to date her. But she didn’t think of me “that way,” and I accepted that. I figured having another good friend wouldn’t hurt and I eventually lost my attraction towards her. Eventually.
While some platonic friendships are intended to be so from the start, many men in my “club” view being friends with a woman as accidental. It’s like, “Hey I wanted to date you, made a bad move, and now I’m stuck watching Divine Secrets of the Ya-Ya Sisterhood with you.”
I’ve tried dating and being more than the platonic friend, but after getting cheated on and rejected a couple of times, I thought it was best to try focusing my energy on things like honing my advice-giving skills.
I mean, I haven’t given up on the prospect of finding that “special someone,” but nearly every woman I come across now seems to view me as nothing more than a sweet guy to talk to.
They Sacrifice Personality for Looks
My female friends complain that all men act like sexist pigs only concerned about sex. I’m not disputing this, but it makes me wonder why some women drone on about how they want a sweet, caring man, then in a blink of an eye, sacrifice personality for physicality.
“Oh you know, your personality is perfect,” said Denise, when, after weeks of pent-up emotions, my head completely drowned in thoughts of her, I finally told her I had feelings for her.
“I do love you,” she said. “It’s just that… well… I mean, I just think that we don’t LOOK good together. I mean, people would start talking about how weird we look together, and we wouldn’t want that. Besides, we’re such great friends.”
Her response left me numbingly cold. I thought about cutting contact with her, but then wondered how guilty I’d feel about dropping someone who at times referred to me as “the only one willing to listen.” So I left our friendship as it was, more for her sake than mine.
Can’t Play With the Toys
My membership in the platonic friend club is a blessing and a curse. It’s like being a kid trapped in a toy factory, getting to see how all these cool new toys are put together and work, but never being allowed to play with them.
It’s nice to be appreciated for my sensitivity, but women only see me as the advice guy, the therapist. The type of guy you date? No.
Everyone keeps saying, “Russell, you just have to be patient. The person you’re meant to be with will come.” Maybe they’re right, and all this insight into females will aid me in my quest to find “the one.” Or maybe I’ll forever be doomed to an existence of late-night phone calls, chick flicks, vibrators, sexual horror stories and talks about “hot guys.” Hmm, maybe being considered a sexist pig wouldn’t be too bad.
Could I Be a Dog?
Some of my guy friends tell me I should “quit with all the sensitive guy crap,” and make more of an effort to take on a smooth image that they say “women really want.”
Maybe I could be the one women talk about instead of the one they talk to. Instead of hanging out in Sephora helping girls decide what makeup to wear to impress a guy, I could be out there being that guy. Why can’t I be an insensitive dog who thinks more about what I could do with a woman rather than what I could learn about her?
Why can’t I? Because I’ve spent so long helping women, gradually understanding them, that it wouldn’t feel right. I’d become hypocritical with my advice about how wrong other men are. I’m more likely to try and play baseball with Tatiana’s vibrator than stoop to that level.
Better to Have
Never Understood Women?
Still, I ask myself: Would it have been better to have never seen what it feels like for a girl, to stay oblivious to all their insecurities and self-doubts? Or is it better to cherish my privileged access to women’s thoughts while enduring the torture of never being seen as more than a friend?
Questions, questions. Oh wait, there goes my phone again. “Hello? Hi. Oh, you really like this guy huh? But you don’t know if he could ever like you because of how your hair looks. Oh boy.”
Sigh. Here we go again. Another “I don’t know if I’ll ever be good enough for him” conversation. Oh joy. When does my membership in the platonic friend club expire?
All Talk, No Action
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.