Amerie, on her debut All I Have, unfortunately doesn’t have much. She lacks the pizzazz that would set her apart from other young female r&b singers, like Ashanti and Alicia Keys.
The album contains a few decent tracks, but the bulk of it had me desperately hitting the next track button, only to find that the next track was as dull as the one I’d just listened to.
Amerie will likely be a one-hit wonder with the first single, “Why Don’t We Fall in Love.” The song’s strong drumbeats are intensified by her passionate vocal delivery, making it the album’s best track. (It’s also the shortest, playing less than 3 minutes.)
Too Needy on Title Track
Two other tracks that aren’t too painful on the ears are “I Just Died” and “Nothing Like Loving You.” Both rely on soft, sultry, romantic sounds.
But the rest of the CD suffers from standard beats, poor songwriting and thoughtless production. The title track is dismal: As she croons “This is all I have to give,” I wish she would’ve kept it to herself.
The lyrics make her sound too needy, as she sings over heavenly strings, “I know it’s not enough/ Thought love would never end/ One more touch is all I have.” Her desperate serenade ruins the pretty musical ensemble.
Straight Into Screaming Territory
And on “Need You Tonight,” she needs to shut up. I don’t know what octave she was attempting to hit, but from the middle to the end of the song, Amerie veers straight into screaming and hollering territory, taking on a Mary J. Blige tone.
Her words about urgently needing someone but not being certain about their future together don’t befit her blaring pitch. The song’s mid-tempo beat-box rhythm is mismatched as well; she should’ve been singing a ballad.
Still, excluding her screaming on “Need You Tonight,” the girl can vocalize. Though the bulk of songs don’t come together lyrically or melodically, some are salvageable because of her superior singing style.
Reminds Me of Ali
She reminds me of Tatyana Ali, who played Ashley Banks on The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air. Ali also had a nice voice, but an album that was garbage because of the poor songs.
All I Have is tiresome, with songs that are fiercely uninspired. Still, it might fare well since many stores are selling the album for the price of a single. But “Why Don’t We Fall In Love” isn’t worth the seven or eight dollars that stores are charging for the album (which also doesn’t include the much-better remixed version of the single).
All I Have Isn’t Enough
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.