AIDS Videos: Which One Works Best?

Until recently, the Board of Education had been using a videotape on AIDS prevention called “Sex, Drugs, and AIDS” in high school health classes.
But the Board decided that changes were needed, and they had a second videotape made, called “AIDS: Just Say No,” which is now being shown as part of the city’s AIDS curriculum.
But “Sex, Drugs, and AIDS” is better than “AIDS: Just Say No.” It is much more realistic.
For example, in “Sex, Drugs, and AIDS,” there were three White girls sitting on the floor in a school gym talking about boys and what they used for protection.
‘I Use Condoms’
The first girl says, “I use the pill because it’s the most convenient.”
The second girl replies, “I use the condom because it’s safer and you won’t get any diseases”
“Maybe I just won’t have sex at all,” the third girl says. “It seems like a hassle.”
In this tape they weren’t trying to persuade teens not to have sex. They made it known that if you choose to have sex, you must use protection.
But they don’t do that in “AIDS: Just Say No.” They try to persuade teens not to have sex at all. I think this is just going to turn the students off.
“AIDS: Just Say No” is unreal. The Board of Ed makes it seem like life is perfect.
In that tape there are two White girls, a Black girl, a White guy, and a Hispanic guy. The three girls are sitting on a stairway in a high school, and they start talking about sex and AIDS.
The Black girl and one of the White girls have never had sex. The other girl has, but she used condoms for protection and the pill just to be extra safe.
Fake and Unreal
Then the two guys come and start talking to the three girls. ‘Both boys say that they would use condoms if they had sex.
That seems fake and unreal. They should have, had one of the boys saying that he doesn’t use condoms and one of the girls saying that she doesn’t use any kind of protection. That would have been more realistic.
In “AIDS: Just Say No,” it seems like the Board of Ed, is more worried about teens having sex than about them getting AIDS. They try to persuade teens not to have sex at all, but not all teens feel that way.
For example, in the part with the three girls and the two guys, one of the girls keeps saying, “I’m not having sex until I get married.”
One of the girls then asks one of the boys a question about sex and AIDS, and what he says makes it seem like he’s a virgin: “It seems like I’m never going to have sex.”
But the majority of teens have sex before they’re 18. The Board of Ed should make another video-and this time they should be realistic.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.