ACS Put On Probation

We all know that the New York City foster care system has its share of problems. And so did a group of lawyers for foster children, who sued the city in 1995 for the failure of the system to protect youth and provide them with proper care. The lawyers wanted the courts to take over the Administration for Children’s Services (ACS) because they felt the city couldn’t run the agency properly.
But the lawsuit has been settled, with Mayor Rudolph Giuliani agreeing to let a group of experts closely monitor the performance of the ACS and issue recommendations and timetables for improving and reforming the agency.
The experts will focus their investigations on how the ACS decides whether or not a child is being abused, as well as foster care placements and adoptions. The agreement will also assign 41 workers to make sure the city’s foster care system is obeying state laws.
The deal represents a milestone in the way child welfare is handled in New York, as the city has never officially had an independent commission that would investigate it regularly. The panel is composed of four former child welfare administrators.
They include Doug W. Nelson, who worked for the state of Wisconsin in the 1980’s and is now the president of the Annie E. Casey foundation, the nation’s largest private foundation devoted to poor children; John Mattingly, a senior program associate at the Casey Foundation, who ran the child welfare agency in Toledo, Ohio; Judith Goodhand, who ran the agency in Cleveland until this year when she became a consultant at the University of North Carolina’s Graduate School of Social Work; and Paul Vincent, who was the director of Alabama’s Division of Family and Children’s Services before moving to a nonprofit child welfare group.
Although they can’t specifically force the city to do anything, these experts have complete access to city officials and data, and can issue periodic reports and recommendations on foster care placement, permanency planning for children in foster care, the monitoring of foster care agencies, case practice and other related issues.
“The system has proven so resistant to change that we really had to be very clear-minded about what was likely to result,” said Marcia Robinson Lowry to The New York Times. Lowry is the executive director of Children’s Rights Inc., the advocacy group that filed the lawsuit. “Winning a trial is not that difficult,” she said. “What is difficult is getting things to change. And this agreement is going to bring about reform that is long overdue.”
Reform sounds good. Only problem is, there don’t appear to be plans for having a current and/or former foster youth on the oversight board, even though teens who are in or have been through the system could offer the experts valuable insight. After all, we’re the ones who are living it.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.