“A Thin Line Between Love and Hate”: Nothing to Laugh At

WARNING! If you haven’t seen A Thin Line Between Love And Hate yet, please don’t waste $8. And if you have seen it, don’t bother reading this review ’cause it will just bring back memories of that horrible Black version of Fatal Attraction. I’m a die hard Martin Lawrence fan, but this movie made me wonder why.
In Thin Line, Martin is Darnell, a player who women can’t get enough of. In one scene, he kisses a woman and she faints; in another, a woman has him lick her feet (damn Martin, you didn’t have to go there!). So, you know he gots to be conceited. I mean, he’s even got “D MAN” vanity plates on his jeep.
Darnell and his friend Tee (Bobby Brown) manage a phat club called Chocolate City. Everything is going great for them until they meet up with Brandi (Lynn Whitfield), a really, really rich realtor (she sells mansions and stuff).
When they first see her, she’s coming out of a building in slow motion like she’s some kind of image of perfection (Not!). Tee tries to approach her with some played out come-on lines, but Brandi doesn’t have any time for his nonsense. Then Darnell runs up to her as she’s getting into her limo, begs her to come to the club and slips a VIP pass through her window.
The Bet
When Brandi shows up at the club later, Darnell is sure she has come to see him but she lets him know it’s just to see the club. Then she walks away. Darnell can’t take no for an answer so he bets his friends that he can get with her. If he does, his friends got to call him the man whenever they see him (just to boost his ego up more).
Darnell starts trying to win Brandi’s heart (and get into her drawers). He finds out where she works and pops up without warning, only to get escorted out by security (he’s so obnoxious that if they had beaten him up, I would have cheered instead of calling it police brutality). Then he tries playing it off like he’s a potential mansion buyer in an attempt to get some time alone with her.
Meanwhile, Darnell’s childhood friend, Mia (Regina King), comes home from the Air Force fully grown and developed (damn, she looks good!) and has almost as many guys flocking to her as Darnell has women.
The Triangle
Darnell has the nerve to get jealous. He finds himself caught in a love triangle ’cause he has to have sex with Brandi so he can show off to his friends but his true feelings are for Mia (gosh Martin, how do you do it? You’re just too original for your own good.)
After a little hard work, a lot of lying (including use of the L word) and kicking some game to her, Darnell finally gets Brandi in bed. All the while, Brandi is trying to tell him something but Darnell only has sex on his mind.
Brandi finally stops him while they’re in motion and tells him that she killed her husband because he was abusive. So given the position he was in (hee, hee, hee), Darnell just says that if the man was abusive, she had to kill him. Then they pick up where they left off.
Later Darnell goes and hangs out with Mia and decides that he wants only her. He spends the night with Mia, totally forgetting that he was supposed to go to Brandi’s to celebrate her birthday. He’s reminded the next morning when he hears the doorbell ring and finds a birthday cake with a piece missing and a knife stuck in the middle.
Kill the Dog!
The next thing you know Brandi’s putting as much effort into trying to kill Darnell as he put into winning his bet. I don’t blame Brandi; in fact, I give her props. I didn’t like Darnell’s character at all-he’s a total dog who treats women like dirt and doesn’t care if he hurts them in the process. (Shoot, at one point, I wanted to jump in the movie and help her kill him. The man deserves to die for making me waste two hours of my life that I’ll never get back again.)
I went into this movie expecting some of Martin’s trademark comedy. Usually if he just waves his finger, he’ll make me laugh, but not this time. I guess he was trying to be funny in the beginning of the movie when he was primping in front of the camera or when he did his stupid little mac-wanna-be walk in Brandi’s mansion but he just looked real stupid if you ask me.
Where are the Laughs?
Watching a Martin Lawrence movie where he doesn’t make you laugh is like watching a Steven Seagal movie where Steve doesn’t shoot anybody or break any bones. What’s the point?
For me, the funniest scene was when Darnell and Brandi go horseback riding and Darnell falls off (if I was the horse I would have thrown him off me too and then I would have kicked him a few times for making me be in such a bad movie).
I guess Martin must feel all washed up since his TV show is bombing. But he should stop trying so hard to be a big time movie star/writer/director and pay more attention to putting his show back on the map. Doing movies like this will just put him further in the hole.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.