Capitalism: A Love Story is the latest film by Michael Moore, a filmmaker who is known for entertaining documentaries that are especially critical of Republican policies. He’s made other famous films, such as Bowling for Columbine, which explored the circumstances that led to the Columbine High School massacre in 1999, and Fahrenheit 9-11, which looked at the presidency of George W. Bush and the war on terror. These films have won him awards as well as controversy and critics.
Capitalism focuses on the current recession and on the problems Moore sees in our economy generally. He shows how the economy has changed over the last several decades, how many factory and assembly line workers have lost their jobs, and how wealthy people and corporations use their money and power to create an unfair system.
Early in the film, Moore says that capitalism is supposed to mean that businesses offering the best products and services will succeed and grow bigger, which sounds fair. But then he talks to people being evicted from their homes and laid-off employees to show how this system allows very big, successful businesses to bully individuals who don’t have wealth or power. He even talks to priests who tell him they believe capitalism is evil.
Is Capitalism Evil?
One thing that I learned watching this film is that way back in the 1940s, President Franklin Delano Roosevelt proposed a “second bill of rights.” Roosevelt suggested that everyone deserves a job with a living wage, freedom from unfair competition and monopolies, a home, medical care, education, and recreation. I think that Roosevelt’s idea is fair. However, I feel disappointed knowing that 65 years later, these rights are not guaranteed in America.
Also, I felt upset when I saw scenes of families being evicted from their homes in Detroit and elsewhere. These families were unable to keep up their payments on their mortgages, so the banks and police came to evict them. The bank officials said that they needed to sell the houses to other people. But in fact, many Detroit houses are left empty because the city is so economically depressed that most people who could afford to move elsewhere have done so. The point is that the banks don’t seem to care. They’d rather leave families in the streets with nothing than give them a break.
Before watching this film, I’d never thought about capitalism or what it is-it just sounded like it had to do with money. Now that I’ve seen the film, I agree that capitalism can be evil, if it winds up meaning the rich become richer and the poor get poorer and can’t do anything about it.
On the other hand, people usually compare capitalism with communism, and I think that communism is unfair, too. Under communism, everyone has the same salary-but some people work harder than others, and I think their effort should make a difference.
Power in Numbers
Capitalism is supposed to reward people for working hard, and in that way, it’s a good system. We can make the system better by ensuring everyone makes a fair salary.
Otherwise, it will be better for workers to start their own companies-as Moore shows some people have done. At one worker-owned company he visits, assembly line workers make a very good salary: $65,000 a year. He also shows workers in Chicago joining together to protest and demand money from the company that is laying them off, and neighbors joining together to defend a family being evicted. He’s pointing out that people without money or influence should join together because there is power in numbers. I like how Moore inspires us to do something about the problems he depicts.
I recommend this film to teens whether or not they think they’re interested in the economy, because it’s an unusually fun documentary. It’s especially useful to teens who feel like they have too much or too little money compared to other people and want to know why.
A Dysfunctional Love Story
A Dysfunctional Love Story
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.