Don’t Put Me in the Middle

Names have been changed.
“He hit me!” my 23-year-old sister shouted when she walked in the house. Tears ran down her face as she tried to explain what happened. Her voice cracked. My older brother ran in.
When I saw her, my body froze. I could only stare at her. Her right eye was bruised and swollen. There was dried blood on her nose and the left side of her lip was split. I thought of Jade as the strongest and most independent woman I knew. One part of me wanted to hug her, but another part of me wanted to run away. My emotions were all over the place.
“Who attacked you?” my brother demanded. She hesitated. Then she said, “It was Nick. We got into a fight and he hit me.” Her eyes that once shined like stars were dull. “But it was my fault! I got him mad when I should have kept my mouth shut.”
Was she seriously trying to defend the man who had physically abused her?
My brother called my mother at work and told her what had happened. While we were waiting for her, I helped clean the dried blood off my sister’s nose and then gave her a clean shirt. My mother arrived home an hour later and immediately called the police. Two policemen came over to take Jade’s statement. They advised her to file a restraining order, which requires one person to stay away from another person.
The next day my mother accompanied Jade to the police station to file the restraining order. It stated Nick wasn’t permitted to be within 100 feet of Jade or he would get arrested.
Secret Meetings
After that, no one in my family mentioned Nick’s name or what had happened. So I thought my sister had ended her relationship with him. But one day when she took me window-shopping on Fifth Avenue, there he was. It was clear they had planned to meet there. At first I wanted to believe she was seeing Nick as a way to say goodbye forever or to talk about the incident. But I knew that wasn’t true as soon as he kissed her hello.
On our way back home I asked her, “Why was Nick hanging out with us today? I thought you two broke up?”
“We did, but he kept texting me how sorry he was and that he didn’t mean to hit me. He was just drunk, I guess, and wasn’t thinking properly. It’s nothing to worry about, little sis.” At 13, I didn’t second-guess my older sister’s words.
As time progressed, she began to use me as an alibi to secretly meet him wherever we went. She would tell my mother she and I were going out.
After this had been going on for four months, one Saturday when my mother and I were cooking lasagna she said, “I know you’re helping Jade sneak around with Nick. Do you think I’m that stupid?”
Her tone revealed how mad she was with me.
“I don’t know what you’re talking about.”
“don’t lie to me. I know all those times you two go to the’gym’ or’shopping,’ she’s really seeing him. I’m asking you to tell me the truth.”
In that moment, I felt like I had to decide whose side I was on. Should I choose my mother and end all the sneaking around? Or should I remain loyal to my sister who’d been there for me more than my mother had? I left the kitchen without saying a word.
In the Middle
Later, I waited for an opportunity when Jade and I could talk alone. “Mom knows you’re seeing Nick. I didn’t tell her, I swear.”
“Mom doesn’t have any evidence. She just wants to scare you.” A devilish smile formed on her face. This was a different person, someone I didn’t know. I was surprised at how calm she was about deceiving our mother. The Jade I knew tried to do the right thing and didn’t enjoy disobeying our mother.
As time went on, the pressure weighed heavily on my shoulders. Every day my sister and mom fought. I would lock myself in the bathroom covering my ears trying to ignore their shouting and name-calling. I blamed myself for what was happening, because I felt that if I’d said something this would have ended. There were times I wanted to open the bathroom door and tell them to stop. But that meant risking having all the secrets and lies come out.
Then one day I saw my father’s razor on the sink. It was the night when my sister and mother were having their longest argument. I was sitting on the bathroom floor crying and hugging my knees. I felt like I had ruined their relationship.
I stared at the razor. I placed it on my wrist. I closed my eyes tightly; I finally felt like I had control over something. My heart was beating so rapidly it felt like it was going to pop out of my chest. This was my own little secret, a secret that wouldn’t risk losing anyone’s love.
Every cut I made on my wrist or thighs gave me a rush, but it mostly felt like a release. The pressure, stress, and secrets were piling up. I was drowning in them. But when I was alone with a razor it was like a breath of fresh air.
The Truth Comes Out
Two months later, Jade and I were shopping at Macy’s, and she started playing with my bracelets while we were waiting in line. My heart was beating fast hoping she wouldn’t see any of the cuts on my wrist. Her fingers began to rub against them. I’d never been so afraid in my life. Suddenly she stopped and I saw sadness in her eyes, but she didn’t say anything.
Two days later I was getting ready for school. As I was changing my pants, Jade came into my room. She saw the cuts on my thighs.
“Are you cutting yourself?” Jade asked as she came closer to me to get a better view of the cuts.
“No, I’m not.” I buttoned my pants fast.
“I know you are, and it scares me. You need help. I told my therapist about this. She thinks you need help, too.”
“I’m not doing anything. You’re crazy.”
I thought, I need help? She’s the one who constantly defends Nick and lies about seeing him.
“I love you and I don’t want you to keep hurting yourself. You’re the only sister I have. It’s my job to make sure you’re safe. So please just think about me and the love I have for you the next time you want to cut yourself. Whenever you’re ready to talk I’ll be here.”
Although I wanted to tell my sister, “You’re the reason I’m hurting myself,” I couldn’t. I cared for her safety and I didn’t want her to be worrying about me as well. We were both too stubborn to discuss our own personal issues, but we would do anything to help the other.
But the next day I decided I needed to address it with her. We were walking to the gym. “I do it because I can’t keep your secrets without feeling like someone is going to get hurt.”
“What?” My sister had assumed I was hurting myself for different reasons, such as insecurities about my weight or height. I knew that telling her the truth would hurt her; that’s why I had held back.
“Whenever you want to go see Nick, you take me with you. I can’t tell mom because then I would be betraying your trust, but I’m also betraying her by lying. I’m being put in the middle and it’s too much for me. I love both of you and you’re putting me in a situation that’s so unfair.”
“Why didn’t you say so sooner?”
“I couldn’t! I don’t want anyone else to get hurt. I just want things to be normal again.”
Finally she said, “I’m sorry I did this. I promise I’ll stop seeing Nick.”
My Turn to Heal
Later that night my sister spoke to my mother privately. She realized she needed my mother’s help to resolve both conflicts. They no longer wanted me to be in the middle.
My mom suggested I go to therapy, but I didn’t feel comfortable speaking to a stranger.
Instead, everyone in my family decreased their working hours to keep an eye on me. Before I went to the bathroom my mom removed all the sharp objects like razors or hair scissors. Every day I had to tell her how I was feeling and if I wanted to cut myself.
I always lied to her and told her “no,” but the truth was I wanted to cut myself. I had become addicted to cutting. I couldn’t stop. It drove me nuts whenever I couldn’t find anything sharp in the bathroom. I missed the rush. My leg would start to shake uncontrollably and I would start biting my nails. But instead of cutting, I would take deep breaths until I felt calmer, listen to music, or do my homework. Those distractions worked.
I’ve come up with some other ways to avoid cutting. Sometimes I put a rubber band around my wrist, stretch the rubber band, and then release it. This snapping against my skin satisfies the urge to cut. Sometimes I’ll write in my journal to express how I’m feeling, and that helps too.
Gradually, the urge to cut has gotten less and less. It’s been six months since the last time I cut. Whenever I feel like cutting, I think about why I did it: I felt suffocated and squeezed when my sister and mom put me in a stressful position, and cutting felt like the only way to release the stress. Then I remind myself that I’m no longer in that position. I tell myself that Jade has moved on with her life and is doing well, and that motivates me to do the same. Still, I now recognize the importance of separating myself from my sister’s problems and not taking them on to such an extent that I’m harming myself. I know I must put my own well-being first.

Self-Harm Can Be Addictive. Here’s How To Get Help
Cutting and other forms of self-injury may make you feel better or more in control in the short term. But they are not a long-term solution for the underlying feelings and problems that make you want to hurt yourself. There is no “safe” or “healthy” amount of self-injury. While self-harm can be addictive, people can and do stop injuring, with the right kinds of help and support.
To get help for yourself or someone you know, call 1-800-DONTCUT or visit selfinjury.com .
Adapted from S.A.F.E. ALTERNATIVES® (Self Abuse Finally Ends) and Helpguide.org

If you or someone you know is in an abusive relationship, call loveisrespect, a teen dating violence helpline, at 1-866-331-9474. You can also text LOVEIS to 22522, or visit loveisrespect.org to get help.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.