The Possibility Project (TPP) is a youth theater group that creates plays based on the young people’s experiences. The youth perform in the plays, though they never play themselves. TPP started a foster care program in 2009. Seven writer-performers from that program and three Represent writers gathered this past winter to talk about the stigma of being in care, people’s stereotyping of foster youth, and how best to handle those false assumptions. Rain, Lala, Andianna, Rae, Toni, Charlene, and Michael are from TPP; Marlo, Otis, and Yaselin Serenity are from Represent. Here’s an edited version of that conversation.
What are the worst assumptions or stereotypes about foster kids that you’ve heard?
Rae: “You’re too happy to be in care. How can you always be laughing and be in care?”
Andianna: “You’re on the principal’s honor roll? You don’t do drugs? I know most people in care get pregnant and don’t do nothing with their life.”
Yaselin Serenity: “If you’re a foster child, why is your vocabulary up to par?”
Lala: “Is your mama on crack? Is your mom dead? Are you on drugs? Are you in special education? Where do you get your food from? Where do you get your clothes from? Do you live in a home with your girls? Do you live in a home with a bunch of guys? Have you been raped? Is it like Annie? Do you scrub floors when you get home?”
Michael: People would ask if I was beaten with a wet rag like in Antwone Fisher.
Marlo: A Child Called It
Rain: “All those girls in foster care have sex with everyone. You’re going to be pregnant before you’re 16. Do they lock you in the basement and throw food at you? Was your mom on drugs?”
Otis: “Your real parents gave you up because you were too stupid.”
When you meet someone new, do you tell them you’re in care?
Whole group: No, no, no, no, no, no.
Yaselin Serenity: It depends on how long I’ve known you. If I just met you, I’m not telling you.
Charlene: It depends on the situation. If I’m living with a white foster mom, someone might say, “Your mom don’t look like you,” and I’ll say, “That’s my foster mom.”
Andianna: I don’t tell because people tend to feel bad. “Oh my God, what happened?” Or they say stupid things like, “You don’t look like someone in foster care.” Well, what does someone in foster care look like?
Rain: I don’t say it because people treat you differently.
Lala: I’ll tell my close friends.
Toni: I want to protect myself so I don’t tell them right off the bat. I think it has something to do with trust. Even with a friend, if you two have an argument, she may throw it back in your face.
Do you have a cover story?
Andianna: When people ask, I say, “that’s just my aunt, second removed, who married into the family.” [laughter] I say, “I know she’s lighter than me, she married my uncle.” Something like that.
Lala: “I’m staying with someone for the time being, because my mom is sick.”
Toni: I just say “family friend.”
When do you tell people? What makes it feel safe?
Lala: When you’re my close friend, and I trust you with all my heart. When you feel like familyâ. My best friends know I’m in foster care. Not even teachers know.
Yaselin Serenity: I have trust issues, so I can’t pinpoint a time to tell anyone.
Rain: It never makes sense for me to tell people; if my friend is complaining about his mom, it’s never going to be the same for me. Plus, if you tell them, they might tell somebody else.
Rae: I’d rather observe you for a while and see what you’re about first. I want to see if you’re a person who doesn’t run her mouth about everything. When I see what your character is, then maybe I might open up to you.
What is a good reaction, one you’d like to get from people?
Lala: I got the best reaction I could from my best friend. She had sympathy, but she didn’t show me she felt sorry for me. She was like “Really? I knew you and your mom had problems, but I didn’t know it was that bad. Girl, you’re my best friend for years; if you need anything, I got your back.” She wasn’t all “Oh you poor thing, that’s so sad. Do you need any food?” She didn’t feel sorry for me, and that’s what I really respected.
Did you have stereotypes about foster care before you were part of the system?
Rain: I had the idea that all foster kids are bad, they’re going to beat you up, they’re going to take your clothes, they all come to school hungry and steal everybody’s food. I felt like it was my first day at Rikers when I went into care. You go in there with this warrior status.
Have you come up with a good way to explain foster care?
Yaselin Serenity: My definition is: Different people open up their homes for kids who can’t be in their own homes because they’re unsafe or being harmed there.
Charlene: I really don’t care. It’s not my job. I feel like no matter what I say about foster care, people are still going to think what they want to think. The truth be told, it’s different for everyone. It could be that you were being abused at home; it could be that one parent was abusing the other; it could be that your parents died in a car accident. There are a number of reasons why people end up in foster care and it’s not my job to make everyone understand what the foster system is like.
Michael: There’s good foster care and there’s bad foster care; there’s families who don’t love you or take care of you; there are families who love you and take care of you, and there are families in between who take care of you but don’t love you and just take the money.
Lala: It’s when you can no longer live with your parents and someone else welcomes you into their home and you live with them.
Andianna: I can only explain what I’ve been through and it depends on who’s asking.
Do you feel like your work at TPP or Represent dispels stereotypes?
Rain: When you can do something artistic that moves people, it’s easier for them to accept it. It’s better than saying, “Foster care is this.”
Lala: People afterwards ask, “Did that really happen? Whose story is that?” If you’re ignorant about something, and then you sit down and see what people have really been through, you get it more.
Rae: If something is made to entertain people, they’re more open to listening and not to judge as much or just feel pity.
Yaselin Serenity: I prefer to write for the magazine than to talk about things. Having it written down takes the eyes off me. I’m trying to keep myself together and I don’t want your pity.
Otis: There are certain things I don’t feel comfortable talking about, but in writing I can be honest about the ups and downs of my situation. People have a better chance of understanding me and not prejudging me if they read my writing.
Yaselin Serenity: [TPP] plays are a good way to tell the people to shut up and listen to the kids. The plays give caseworkers a point of view to understand the kids.
Rain: The magazines and the plays prove that people in foster care are not disabled. We know how to write and sing and dance and act. This shows it’s not a handicap for us.
Ask Before You Assume About Foster Care Youth
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.