Good Ain’t Good Enough

I learned to stand up to my parents

It was 5:45 p.m. and we were headed to my third grade parent-teacher conference. I had been dreading this since I found out about it two weeks earlier. Accompanying my parents and I were my little sister and my older cousin Marlin, who always acted as my parents’ translator, since they only spoke Spanish.
In English class, my teacher started off by saying how good my work was and how I was one of her best students. I beamed. Then she pulled out the’but.’ “He could have done better and gotten an A in my class instead of a B,” she said, as Marlin translated. “But he got a 70 on one of his essays so that dropped it down.” My smile turned into a frown. I knew I was in serious trouble.
As I stared down to avoid my parents’ menacing glare, I noticed how clean the floor was. I could smell the wax the janitor used and I could even see my reflection. I saw my scared face, the tears rolling down my chubby cheeks, hitting the floor. Then I felt a hard thud on my arm.
“You’re going to study real hard so it won’t happen again,” my mom said firmly. To the teacher that sounded normal but I knew what it really meant: “I’m going to beat you so bad you won’t ever get that bad grade again.”
Alone and Defenseless
Before we dropped Marlin off, I asked her if she could talk to my parents for me. “I really tried my best and I know I could do better but they’re not going to believe me. They’re still going to hit me. Maybe you can tell them.”
“I can’t tell them what to do. The only person with the power to change their behavior is you,” she said.
That was the last thing I wanted to hear. I wanted someone to fight my battles for me. Defending myself against my parents had never occurred to me. When we pulled up to Marlin’s building and she got out of the car, I felt so alone. But what she told me about talking to my parents was lodged in my brain.
The closer we got to home the bigger the knots in my stomach and throat grew. The car ride home was always silent, and so was the walk to our apartment, the ride in the elevator, and the walk to my room. I had been through this so many times, it was like a ritual.
The Beating Ritual
I knew I had at least five minutes before my father came in so I put my thickest thermal shirts and long johns under my clothes to soften the blows. The door to my room opened and my father walked in. He turned on the TV and raised the volume all the way up so the neighbors wouldn’t hear me scream. He unbuckled the brown leather belt that held up his saggy blue jeans and raised it high. After 10 minutes and countless blows it was over. He was sweating from the beating he gave me and decided that was enough to get the message through to me. And it was.
I’m not saying that beating works or is right, but I have to admit that I tried to get good grades in school so that I wouldn’t get beat. So a week later I wrote another essay for my English class. I labored over it for hours and got a 93. I thought to myself, “Is this what I got beat for? Was this worth the nights I spent crying? Are these belt marks that remain on my body like tattoos worth it?” In my mind the answer to those questions was “No.”
Later that day I came home with a smile on my face waving my 93 in the air like a white flag. I showed it to my dad first, as he sat in his usual position on the couch. He looked at the paper and as he reached for the remote I flinched. I was always on alert, always afraid. But he just put the Yankees game on’pause’ and congratulated me on a job well done. “This is what I wanted, son. See what you can do?”
My Mother’s Rage
A week later report cards arrived. Because they were mailed home my mom was usually the first to lay eyes on them. I ran as fast as my legs could move me to try and beat her home. Sure enough, the manila envelope was already opened. I saw a couple of A’s and B’s. But then I saw the dreadful F in math. I knew I hadn’t done well-I had gotten beat for the C’s and D’s I’d gotten on my tests-but I was shocked that I had actually failed.
My mother was waiting for me in my room. Before I could say a word, she threw me down on the bed. I tried to get up and run away but she grabbed a towel and shirt that was drying on the door and tied my arms to the bedpost, something she had never done before. Next were my legs, which she used a shoelace and belt to tie down. As she wrapped the belt around her knuckles and prepared to strike me, my father walked in and saw me tied up. After a loud argument, my pops untied me, held me tight and said, “C’mon let’s sign you up for summer school.”
My father had beat me many times and watched my mom do it also. But she had never tied me up before and he’d never seen her so full of rage. I think my father acted to me in that kind way because he was afraid my mom would beat me so bad I might run away.
Love, Hate, Confusion
As he carried me away like a proud father who carries his newborn child for the first time, it brought back memories. It reminded me of days when we would come home late from baseball games. After spending all my energy trying to catch foul balls, eating Cracker Jacks, and singing the National Anthem, I napped on the ride home. The last thing I’d see before I passed out would be the lights on the highway passing by. While I slept carefree, my dad managed to park the car, take my seat belt off, and carry me upstairs to bed where he changed me into my pjs and wished me goodnight.
Memories like these would make me forget about the nights he beat me. He was the loving father every young boy wanted. I dressed like him and tagged along with him everywhere he went because I wanted to be like him. What I didn’t want was that stranger who beat me. That guy was nobody to me.

There were two sides to my mother too. After her beatings she would bring me ice to lessen the swelling on the welts on my arms and legs. At first, I would push her away because I was afraid to trust her and I was angry. But after a couple of minutes I would let her comfort me because I was hurting and I needed it. And I love my mother. She’d put her arm around me, rub my hair and say, “I’m sorry. I do this because I think it’s for your own good so that you don’t end up like me.” Then she would make my favorite dinner of yellow rice, beans, and steak. I would think, “She’s my mother. How could she beat me over and over?” But I knew it wasn’t completely her fault. She was raised to think beating was discipline. In her mind all of this was necessary to prevent me from being uneducated and poor.
The beatings continued through the rest of elementary and middle school. I managed to maintain a B+ average so I was doing good, but good wasn’t good enough for them.
Time to Fight Back
In my sophomore year in high school, I was once again struggling with math. Geometry class made me feel like a lost tourist on the subway. I ultimately failed with a 60.
Of course I knew what to expect when I got home. My report card had arrived at my house already and my dad had the day off. As the school bell rang and we were dismissed I made my way on the train with my friend Franklin.
“Franklin, be honest. How’d you do in geometry?” I asked.
He admitted to me, “I tried bro, but it was hard. I barely passed with a 68.”
That made me feel a little better. “Damn you going to get it tonight!”
Franklin gave me a weird look, “Are you crazy? Nah, I’ll probably get grounded for a week and go to tutoring.”
I was shocked to learn Franklin’s parents didn’t beat him. I just assumed every kid got beat for getting bad grades. And besides not getting beat, Franklin’s parents helped him by getting him a tutor.
Up until then I had tried to convince myself that getting beat was normal because all my other friends (at least the black and Dominican ones) got beat. But it never felt normal when I was getting hit. Now hearing about Franklin’s experience with his parents confirmed it. I thought to myself, “Today it is going to end.”
Confident, Not Scared
My cousin Marlin had told me more than once: “You can’t remain silent. You’re not going to like this but if the beatings continue, threaten to call the cops on them. You have to do something to protect yourself.” I thought of Marlin’s words. It was time to break the silence.
I got home feeling confident instead of scared. My father was already waiting. He was about to strike me with his cold leather belt but this time I caught it before it could touch my skin. Screaming as loud as I could I told him, “Papi, I’ve had enough of this! That’s it, no more!”
I took a deep breath as I prepared to say this next part. “This is the last time you and Mami are going to hit me or I am going to call the cops! I want this to stop and if that means going to the cops, then that’s what I’ll do.”
There was a look of confusion on his face. I think he was surprised that I was actually speaking out. He walked away furious, his face as red as a tomato.
A couple of tears streamed down my face. They weren’t caused by pain or fear but by a sense of relief. I cried because I no longer had to endure painful nights, because I finally got off my chest what I’ve been dying to say all my life. I knew this was the end. I wasn’t beaten that day or ever again.
Things were awkward after my threat to call the police. My parents didn’t speak to me for a couple of weeks. But it got through to them that the way they punished me was old-school and barbaric. The next time I received a bad grade they told me I could do a lot better, gave me disappointed looks, and took away my Play Station 2. I could tell my parents weren’t convinced this method would work, like when you a see a cleaning product on TV and wonder if it could really clean up the huge mess. But I did improve in that class, and my parents never hit me again.
Writing this story wasn’t easy for me. But I want other kids to know you have to fight for yourselves against anybody, even the ones you love, when nobody else will stand up for you. It may not always be as simple as making a threat, like I did. But I believe that even when you think there isn’t a way out, there often is.

To report child abuse, call the New York State Child Abuse Hotline at (800) 342-3720.You can also speak to a teacher, security guard, police officer, or one of your doctors. Be aware they may contact the Administration for Children’s Services which can place children in foster care.
This story is part of the health literacy series, which is generously supported by the Cigna Foundation.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.