Spying on Our Social Networks

I recently read a New York Times article about how school officials in Glendale, California hired an outside technology company to comb through the social network posts of children in the school after suicides occurred in their area.
I have mixed feelings about it. On one hand, I think it’s an invasion of students’ privacy. But on the other hand, I also believe schools need to do what they can to make sure their students are safe online. In September, a 16-year-old Nevada boy bragged on MySpace about how many guns he had at home and how he was plotting to kill his schoolmates. He ended up spending 31 days in jail and was suspended for over 90 days. He tried to sue, saying he had his right of free speech violated but the court dismissed it. I agree with the school and the actions they took to discipline him because I think they had good reason to suspect he might really be dangerous. He even referenced the Virginia Tech shooting.
I thought social media sites were for playing around and exploring, places where we could have fun and relax. But if we’re bullying each other and doing other regretful things online, schools want to keep an eye on us. This means we’d have to monitor what we put up and hold back on what we’d normally do. Now there aren’t really things I would want to hide but I’d be more on my toes if I knew my teachers were monitoring me.
The way I see it, there is no way to solve cyberbullying without violating privacy rights. I wanted to find out if other teens felt the same way I did. So I interviewed students at various high schools in New York City. I found out that, like me, most kids have mixed feelings.

My questions were: How would you feel if you found out our school was monitoring your Facebook pages? Do you think it’s an invasion of privacy or a good idea that protects us?
Paris H. Smith, 16, Brooklyn Collaborative School: I am in between. These are hard questions. Now everyone has to pay for the people who do all the bullying. It is an invasion of privacy but they should monitor us to prevent suicide.
Neryssa Kervine 15, Erasmus High School: No, they shouldn’t monitor students because it will intrude into our personal lives. It takes away our right to free speech.
Rasida Barry, 16, Brooklyn Collaborative School: I have mixed feelings. Sometimes you need to check people’s pages because they do malicious things. Also it will help prevent cyberbullying. But then schools also have to monitor the good people who aren’t doing anything wrong so that’s not really fair.
Mailly Jean Louis, 16, Brooklyn Prep High School: To prevent situations such as bullying and people talking to creeps and perverts online then it’s fine. I don’t mind because I don’t do anything that would need to be monitored anyway.
Katelyn Smith, 16, High School for Public Service: I am in between because I think they should monitor us to a certain extent. But I wouldn’t want to be monitored on every website I go on.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.