I Took a Scam Job

Names of people and companies have been changed.
It was a hot summer during high school, and I needed a job. The employment sections of the Chinese community newspapers mostly advertised jobs at restaurants and nail salons, which required several years of experience that I didn’t have. When I saw an advertisement that said no experience was necessary, I dialed the number.

“Hello!” said a woman in Mandarin. She had a cold voice.

“Hi, are you hiring?” I asked.

“Yes, we do offer jobs.”

“What would I be doing?”

“That depends on your ability.”

She gave me the company’s address in Chinatown in Manhattan, and told me to come the following week for an interview. I thanked her and put the phone down, feeling relieved. She didn’t sound very encouraging, but I thought this was the way professional people spoke.
When I arrived at the company’s office, I filled out a form and then met Landy, who was supposed to interview me. She looked about 20, but her serious manner made her seem older.
$3,000 a Month
Landy brought me into a small classroom where loud pop music was playing, and told me a presentation about the company would begin soon. Shortly afterward, another woman walked in and introduced herself as Tracy. “The reason that I am working in this company, Heartwealth, is because of the powerful product that this company has,” she said. She told us that she used to suffer from severe acne, and as she said this, a projector displayed an image of her face covered in pimples. “I tried so many cosmetic products, but none of them worked. Some even exacerbated my condition,” she said. “But after three months of using Heartwealth, my face was much better.”
There were people of all ages in the room, about a dozen in total. As the presentation went on, Tracy shared other people’s testimonies about Heartwealth. Their products, which were supposed to give you different health benefits, seemed impressive. But the part that excited me most came next: “We will help anyone who takes a job here to make up to $2,500-$3,000 per month,” Tracy said. She explained, however, that we would work on commission. That means instead of being paid an hourly wage or monthly salary, we earned a percentage of what we were able to sell.
After talking about examples of high-earning employees, she ended the presentation with more noisy music. I still didn’t know what this company expected of me, but I figured I’d probably be persuading people to buy Heartwealth powders and pills. They looked like health products I’d seen in the supermarket, so I doubted whether anyone would be willing to spend a lot of money on them.
But I was also completely entranced by the notion of earning more than my dad. I started imagining things I could buy, like a new computer, and planning how I’d continue working part-time after school started in the fall.
I also got excited about the idea of developing my speaking skills. I don’t think people take me very seriously when I talk. I don’t know how to make people passionate about what I’m telling them. But I imagined that by doing this job, I could learn to be mature and eloquent like Tracy and Landy and get more respect.
Pushing Down My Doubts
On my next day at Heartwealth, there was another long presentation, this time about how employees should recruit new workers to become their “team members.” I did think it was unusual for a job to involve so many presentations, rather than actual work. Afterward, I was introduced to Eric, a guy not much older than me, who tried to persuade me to buy a Heartwealth product for $60. From the way he spoke, it was obvious he was giving a rehearsed speech. “You should try our product, so you will know how good it is and confidently work in this company,” he said. When I told him I didn’t have $60, he said, “That’s just an excuse. If you really want to do well in this company, you should let go of your excuses.”
I was resolute, and finally he gave up. Though I didn’t like Eric’s pitch, I figured it was worth putting up with some annoyance for such great money.
I doubted some of the things I’d heard. For example, I didn’t think Heartwealth was likely to dominate the U.S. market for health products within three years, as they vowed they would. But I convinced myself to ignore my doubts, because I yearned so much to earn a lot of money and to appear as mature as the young managers I’d met working at Heartwealth.
Workaholic
Over the next few weeks, I spent my time on the street handing out leaflets that advertised the company’s products, or doing small jobs at the company and listening to daily presentations given by the managers. Soon I began working seven days a week, from 9 a.m. to 7 p.m. Sometimes I even went out during the night on my bicycle to tape posters up on the streets.
At first I could only leaflet 400 sheets per day, but later it grew to 800. I stood at intersections handing leaflets to everyone passing by in any direction. By my fourth week at Heartwealth, work filled my day from the moment I opened my eyes to the time they closed. I was giving it everything I had so that by the end of the summer, I’d either be earning all the money I’d been promised, or I’d know for sure that those promises were impossible.
Several things raised my suspicions: When I was sent to hand out leaflets at first, I needed to have a supervisor accompanying me, even though leafleting is a job that a kindergartener could do. It seemed like the company was trying to keep an eye on us.
Once, while I was in the office, I said something to another girl, and immediately a manager stopped our conversation. “Quiet down, there are other people working,” she said. They didn’t want us communicating with each other.
Believing the Brainwashing
But the most suspicious part of the company was the “lessons,” or presentations, we had to attend. There was a big one every week, which usually lasted for five hours, and shorter lessons on the other days. They covered strategic leafleting and “captivating” our friends so they would buy the product or join us working in the company; there were also the lessons about the power of our product, and on the hierarchy of the company.
The lessons changed my attitude dramatically. Sometimes when I felt tired of working, I’d become energetic again after I’d had a lesson reminding me of the high commission I was working for. I especially remember the lessons taught by Mr. Bob, one of the chairmen of the company. He talked about the hard times that he had gone through as an immigrant and the steps he’d taken to become a millionaire.
“Through the system we’ve created for you, you will become successful like me, or even better,” he promised. “We never persuade people,” he added, “otherwise we would be like any scam company on the market. We won’t persuade you to stay with us. But if you don’t want to listen to what your manager tells you, please don’t waste our time, since there are plenty of other people who are willing to join us.” His speeches gave me a picture of a bright future that I wanted to enjoy, and the fact that he directly confronted the doubts I was feeling made his speeches more effective, too. Why would he bring up the word “scam” if he was actually trying to trick us?
“Curing Cancer?”
As time went on, the lessons claimed more and more-that our product could cure cancer, or that we could make millions of dollars a year. At first I didn’t believe these claims at all, but eventually a voice in my head began to ask, “What if these things they say are true?” I was being brainwashed. I was spending so much time listening to something unbelievable that I was starting to believe it.
I think I was susceptible to brainwashing because I wanted to believe that this company was for real. I had always been an average student, and I was worried about my future. If I could really make a living at this company, I could stop worrying. This was such a comforting idea that I did my best to trust Landy when she told me, “As you get more teammates and your teammates get teammates, you will earn much more.”
I kept working, even though doubts exploded in my head the moment I left work-and even though I wasn’t earning any money. The managers assured us that we would earn money after we had been with the company a little while, gotten used to the system, and acquired more teammates. I told myself this might be true.
Eventually, I did find two customers by leafleting. One of them bought $3,000 of our product, and I earned a $300 commission. But I had become so obsessed with the question of whether or not Heartwealth was legitimate that instead of putting the $300 toward the computer I wanted, I spent $100 on Heartwealth pills that were supposed to help me gain weight. I began taking the pills and waited to see what would happen.
Meanwhile, I began talking with a couple of other young people at the company who had doubts like mine. We’d ask each other questions like:

“If this company is trustworthy, why do I feel they keep hiding something from us?”
“Why do we keep getting lessons every day?”

“Is our product really capable of curing cancer?”

None of us could answer these questions, so our belief and doubts kept battling in our minds.
Hold Out for a Salary
Finally, my fellow workers began to leave the company. One girl said her parents had called the place a scam and forbidden her to work there anymore. She told me about other people who were planning to quit, too.
My heart was suddenly filled with a sense of loss. I thought about the effort of working 10 hours a day with no rest, and about how I’d paid several hundred dollars in total on meals, a formal business suit, and a MetroCard. I had not earned the equivalent of what I’d spent. Maybe I’d been wrong to join this company.
Over the following week, my speed of leafleting dropped; I was no longer eager to work. Every day when I was in the office, I looked around to see who else had left. By the end of August, there were only a couple of us left, and finally my teammate decided to leave.
I was no longer working to earn money, but in hopes of finding the truth about this company for my former coworkers and myself. I tried to continue working after school began, but I’d lost all my willpower.
I gave Landy my resignation, telling her that my parents didn’t want me to work there anymore, because that seemed like the easiest explanation. She reacted calmly. I’d hoped that she would give me a truthful answer about this company’s true nature, but she never did. Maybe she was brainwashed herself.
Not long after, I finished using the Heartwealth products I’d bought-pills and a powder that were supposed to make me gain weight. I never gained any weight at all.
Months later, I realized that if Heartwealth was expanding around the world and curing cancer like they said they would, I should have heard about it on the news by now. I hadn’t. Since then, I read online about a similar scam that spoiled the lives of millions of people in China. This type of scam is called a “pyramid scheme.” One person is persuaded to join and buy a certain product, and then that person is used to attract others around him or her to join. This process is repeated, enlisting many people. It’s called a “pyramid” because it requires an ever-greater number of people to keep functioning, but only the people who join early-the people at the “top” of the pyramid-have much hope of making money.
Beware a job that doesn’t give you a basic wage. Scams entice you with the possibility of a tremendous amount of money, but they don’t guarantee you anything. Teens should also beware of any job that is based around convincing your friends to buy something or join an organization. And stay away from any job that pressures you to make some kind of purchase up front. Legitimate jobs pay you money; they don’t take money from you.
This story is part of the financial literacy series, which is generously supported by NYSE Euronext Foundation.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.