I met Joseph in academic support, which is like a study period. We started chatting and I was instantly attracted. He had dark, curly hair and wore slightly baggy jeans, a black Avenged Sevenfold hoodie, and white and purple DC sneakers.
It was his second year of being a freshman and he was a notorious pothead. Still, I couldn’t help liking him. I have to admit the “bad-boy” image was definitely a turn-on, even though I wasn’t one to ever smoke or cut class.
When I told my best friend that I liked him, she warned: “You’re only going to get hurt.” But I didn’t want to hear it. “So what if he smokes weed? Most people I know do. And who really cares about school?” I thought. Other friends, and even some teachers, said he wasn’t “good enough” for me.
But he made me laugh and listened to me. He could always tell if I was upset and was the first one to ask what was wrong. He even let me borrow his hoodie. I would keep it the entire day just because it smelled like him: a combination of Axe body spray and weed. We started talking on the phone almost every night, but as just friends. Finally, after about a month, and against everyone’s advice, we started dating.
It happened one night when we were talking on the phone. The conversation seemed a little awkward, so I knew something was up. He nervously said, “I want you to be my girlfriend.” I was shocked. I’d been waiting to hear that for so long, but I was speechless.
“So, is that a no?” he asked. The only words I could spit out were “Of course!” My face was as red as a tomato and I couldn’t stop smiling. I wanted to yell with joy from the tallest building in Times Square and let the world know what had just happened.
Warnings, but Why?
In the beginning, everything was great. We would see each other every day at school, eat lunch together, and hang out almost every weekend, just going to the park and talking for hours. We would talk on the phone every night and when we hung up I couldn’t stop thinking about him.
However, my best friend still wasn’t crazy about him. She said she was happy for us, but she also made it clear that she’d be there for me when we broke up. I knew it wouldn’t last forever, but I sarcastically thought to myself, “Thanks for the support.”
I even felt pressure from a teacher to stay away from Joseph. She asked me to stay after school, though I had no idea why. When I came into the classroom, she asked me to sit.
“What’s up?” she asked.
“Nothing…” I replied suspiciously.
“I wanted to ask you, what’s going on between you and Joseph?”
“He’s my boyfriend, why?”
“I was just wondering. You know, you can’t change someone who doesn’t want to be changed. Just think about that a little and I’ll see you tomorrow.” She got up and walked away. I was furious. Why was she getting involved in my personal life? Anyway, I didn’t even know what she meant. I didn’t want to change him.
I Came Second
A few weeks after that conversation, Joseph got suspended for cutting class and talking back to teachers, which he did all the time. I didn’t agree with the way he acted in school, but it didn’t directly affect me, so I didn’t care all that much-at first.
A week or two later, he was suspended again. This time, I told him that he needed to care more about school and treat teachers with respect. He didn’t listen. In fact, he got suspended for a third time three weeks later, this time for 90 days! Despite my annoyance, our relationship was actually going really well. I was still head over heels for this boy.
When he finally came back to school, I was excited. As soon as I walked through the doors on the fifth floor, I saw Joseph sitting outside one of the classrooms. He looked as cute as ever. I ran over to him and sat on his lap. He kissed me hello and held me there for a minute. Finally, he looked me right in the eye and said, “I missed you so much” and kissed me again. The butterflies in my stomach fluttered the same way they did every time I saw him.
But gradually, that feeling started to wear off. As the weeks went by and we spent more and more time together, I finally started to see what everyone else did: a pothead who didn’t care about anything. He still offered me his hoodie when I was cold, but he also ditched me every day to go skateboard and get high with his friends. I didn’t do either of those things.
I once told him I wanted him to stop smoking, but that didn’t go well.
“If you can’t accept the fact that I smoke, then you can’t accept me,” he said.
“Smoking is what you do, not who you are. You’re dating me, not your friends, and not your weed!” I responded. But he didn’t listen to me, so it became a constant argument.
A Learning Experience
After nine months together, I finally realized that it wasn’t working anymore. As much as I didn’t want to admit it, I realized my teacher was right: I did want to change him, and I couldn’t.
I decided to break up with him, and he made it very easy to do. We were talking on the phone one night when he asked, “Would you consider it cheating if I was to make out with another girl?” I was completely taken aback. Of all the bad things I’d ever heard about him, being a cheater wasn’t one of them.
“Yesâ” I replied. He paused for what felt like a couple of minutes straight before replying.
“Ohâ” was all he had to say. My heart was racing. I felt the worst combination of sad, hurt, and embarrassed, like a little kid who just found out Santa isn’t real.
Finally, I blurted out: “I can’t do this anymore. I’m done. Bye.” And that was it.
I called my friend hysterically crying. I told her what happened and she asked me, “Do you regret it, any of it, the relationship, the breakup, anything at all?” I stopped to think about it for a second before answering her question. “No,” I replied.
I can honestly say I loved him. For much of the relationship, he not only made me happy, he made me confident. I’m not sure if it was him or just the amazing feeling of being in love that did this for me, but whatever it was, it made the relationship worthwhile.
For that reason, I’m glad we dated. I not only learned to listen myself, but I learned that the general experience of love is breathtaking. Everyone should have the pleasure of experiencing it. I also learned that it’s OK to make mistakes in love, though it’s never OK to stay with someone who hurts or mistreats you. I also no longer tell people my opinion of their love lives because I know what it’s like to get unsolicited advice. People need to make their own mistakes or they’ll never learn.
