Tiptoeing Out of the Closet

I was afraid to tell my mom that I'm gay

I never really woke up and said, “I think I’m a lesbian.” Just like most heterosexuals don’t wake up one day and say, “I think I’m a heterosexual.” I was born this way. I always knew who I was. It was just a matter of deciding when-and with whom-to share it.
My family’s love and approval has always been important to me. They would ask me if I had a boyfriend, which made me assume that I was supposed to be attracted to boys. I didn’t deny my true feelings to myself as I grew older; I just never mentioned that I was attracted to females because I was convinced it was wrong and I was afraid to get in trouble.
By the end of middle school, I knew that my hiding place in the closet was soon to be revealed. The year before, twin sisters had transferred to my school. Everyone thought they were gorgeous, including me. My hungry little middle-school heart wanted to grab their attention. However, they were popular and I was not.
In 8th grade, one of the twins was in my algebra class. I was one of the top students in that class, so the teacher assigned me to be her personal tutor for the year.
Soon, I found myself thinking about her too often, trying to find any and every way to talk to her. I was peeking out of the closet.
“Why don’t you have a boyfriend, Vanessa? You need a boyfriend,” she’d tell me. I would just stay quiet, afraid of saying something that would make me curl into a ball of embarrassment. Something like, “Because I want you!”
I finally confessed my crush to a few close friends of mine because I couldn’t hold it in anymore. One of them was even able to name the girl that I liked without any hints. Still, I didn’t feel ready to step completely into the light about my sexuality.
At middle school graduation, they handed out roses to all the students. You were supposed to give the rose to someone who’d helped you move forward or who inspired you. The girl that I hopelessly loved gave me her rose. That was one of the last days I ever saw her.
High school was a new beginning for me. I was going to a school in a different borough, far from home. I was going to meet completely different people and start fresh. I noticed that many students there were open about their sexuality. I saw males who dressed very feminine and females who dressed very masculine. I started to open up bit by bit, thinking that maybe it was OK for me to come out.
My First Girlfriend
I met a girl with the prettiest eyes I had ever seen. I didn’t think of her romantically, but I was interested in her character. She was bold, direct, and she stood out from the rest. Even better, she was open about her homosexuality. I felt it in my gut that we were destined to be best friends. I talked to her frequently after that.
And then finally, she messaged me asking me if I was interested in females. I was hesitant to reply, but by that point she was my closest friend and I couldn’t keep it from her. I confessed to her and she asked me if I would ever date a girl from school. I laughed out loud, and told her nobody would ever like me and even if they did I wouldn’t date them for fear of being discovered by my mom.
My confession led us to becoming much closer. A trust had been built and she started to develop feelings for me. I’d never been acknowledged by anyone romantically until then. I started feeling butterflies in my stomach and goose bumps spreading over my skin the minute I was around her.
I finally worked up the courage to become her girlfriend, but I was still afraid. I was afraid of my family finding out and being ashamed of something I couldn’t change if I tried. For a long time, I wouldn’t even kiss her because I didn’t want anyone to see us. I didn’t want someone to stop and point and make us feel like we were wrong for liking each other.
Eventually, everyone in my school found out, and it was less intimidating than I thought it would be. Since my school was so diverse, we fit right in. I was much happier because I felt that I was finally me-at least in school. I had one foot outside the closet door.

“I’m scared for my mom to find out. She’d kill me,” I’d say to my girlfriend.

“I know. It’s OK. You can tell her when you are ready,” she’d say to me.

I only had one parent my whole life. My girlfriend had both her mom and her dad. Her mom was just beginning to accept our relationship, but her dad didn’t have a clue. She was the only daughter and basically her dad’s princess. She worried that telling him might cause him to move her to a different school.
She and I comforted each other and never pressured each other to come out to our parents. But the urgency was thick: We both felt that letting our parents find out on their own would be much worse than telling them ourselves. It turned out to be true.
Telling My Family
One night, my mom told me that she knew what I was hiding and that I’d better confess and explain to her if I didn’t want to get into a lot of trouble. Her threatening tone panicked me, and I escaped to my grandma’s house that night.
I concluded that if my mom suspected something, my grandparents and aunts knew about it as well. As the oldest grandchild, I thought my family would be ashamed of me. They expected so much of me.
I knew it was time. I ran to my aunt’s room with my heart thumping wildly and tears streaming down my face. I was tired of cowering in the shadows for the comfort of others. I was ready to come out all the way.
I sobbed as I told my aunt the truth: I was attracted to females and I was currently in a relationship with one. My grandma heard my gasps for air and came into the room to find out what was going on. To my surprise, they were cool about it. They were surprised that my mom was so worked up and told me it wasn’t even a big deal. They said it was just a phase I’d get over. By 18, I’d have it figured out.
I could have argued and told them I was sure of who I was. I could have argued that they didn’t need to have sex to know they were heterosexual, so they couldn’t possibly try to tell me that that was the only way of figuring who I was attracted to. I could have told them a million and one things but I didn’t say anything. I was out of energy. I was just happy that they didn’t love me any less.
‘This Is Me!’
My mom came straight to my grandma’s house the next morning as my grandma was doing my hair and began to interrogate me. My aunt explained to her what I said the night before because I still couldn’t find the energy.
“You see! I knew that was a terrible school for her! What is wrong with you, Vanessa?!” my mom yelled at me.
“Nothing is wrong with me! This is me! I’ve always been this way!” I cried back. I felt my heart burn black. So what if I liked girls? It wasn’t any different than if I were with a boy. In fact, I felt it was better. A girl would understand me more, and possibly even love me better. And when it came to kids, so what if I couldn’t have biological kids if I decided to? Why would I want to bring kids into a world where hate is unlimited but your love is ultimately restricted, not just by family but by government? All these thoughts pulsed through my mind but I couldn’t put them into words then.
My aunt pretended to be distracted by the television to avoid conflict with my stubborn mother. My grandma seemed to tug my hair harder and harder as the tension thickened in the room. All I could hear was my mom’s anger, poisoning the atmosphere that had been so positive the night before. All I could see was the flare of disappointment in her eyes. Her oldest child was a lesbian. In her eyes, it seemed, I might as well have been a drug addict living on the street, maybe even a murderer.
“This is all my fault! I deserve this for not taking you to church,” she sighed angrily.
“This is who I am! If God can’t love me this way, then he isn’t the good guy everyone swears that he is!” I yelled back weakly at her.
My mom and I didn’t talk for what felt like a very long time after that. She treated me as if I was of a different kind. She acted as if my sexuality was all that I was, when in fact, it’s only part of me.
Maybe she felt, like most parents do, that I’d grow up and get married to a Prince Charming and have many children. And so for a long time, I was ashamed. I felt like the biggest disappointment. But, never, not even during my saddest moments, did I ever try to change who I am.
Forced Back Into the Closet
Summertime came around quickly. My girlfriend’s family was throwing her a surprise party, and I was not going to allow anyone to keep me from going. After all, her mom invited me. She wanted to meet me. I don’t know if my mom was just in a good mood, or if the fire within her was beginning to cool, but at the last minute, she let me go.
I was excited to surprise my girlfriend and excited to meet her mom. The only dilemma I faced was having to retreat back into the dusty closet that I’d hid in for so long.
My girlfriend’s family is very religious. Her mom told me over the phone when she first invited me and again when she picked me up from the train station to go to the party that I would be introduced as her best friend and that I couldn’t act any kind of way with my girlfriend that would give us away.
I agreed, sadly, but it wasn’t as if I was going to go around being a “lesbian,” whatever that kind of behavior involved. Imagine telling someone, “Hey, listen. I don’t mind you tagging along but you can’t go around acting straight. That kind of stuff creeps us out. So uh…just be normal and we’ll have a good time, alright? Thanks.”
It ended up being a wonderful day. My girlfriend was so excited to see me. She hugged me for so long that her mom had to come break us up before we gayed up the place. We both behaved “normal” and I even got a picture taken of us in front of the cake.
Unfair Judgments
After that day, my mom gradually began to accept our relationship. She even developed a liking for my girlfriend. The worst of the journey was out of the way. However, the way we were able to be so comfortable indoors didn’t really work outdoors.
We were absolutely terrified when we were alone in public. Creepy men would stare at us holding hands. Women would look at us in disgust. Parents would turn their kids’ faces in the opposite direction so they wouldn’t be “traumatized for life.” I took this personally and became wary and afraid.
One day, we were a couple train stops away from her home. The train was packed, but we didn’t really notice because we were joking around. We didn’t notice a woman with three children in tow take out her phone and make a call.
“These lesbian b-tches on the train are kissing and stuff. That’s not cute. They really need to find somewhere else to do that. You don’t do that in public. I got my kids here. They going to grow up and think that being gay is OK. Like these b-tches have no f-cking respect. Mad f-cking nasty and sh-t.”
This woman’s voice got louder and nastier as we got closer to my girlfriend’s stop. My knees almost buckled in fear. No one on the train said a word. Why did she do it? I have no idea.
I couldn’t believe that there were parents who still raised their children this way. isn’t cussing in front of your children wrong? isn’t teaching them that they have to be a certain way in order for you to love them wrong?
My girlfriend and I have been harassed multiple times since that incident. However, I know to be strong. Acknowledging rude people will only give them power to keep being rude. But why, in a world so diverse, are you judged for the person you love?

View the lessons based on this story

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.