True Tales of Deadbeat Dads

Names have been changed.
I was just a little kid, asleep in the back seat of my mother’s car when bright lights woke me. As I groggily sat up, a police officer leaned through the open window and said, “Everything is going to be OK.” I looked around in confusion and noticed that we were parked in front of a red church. There were crowds of people and police cars on the street. I saw my sister sleeping in the car seat with her head hanging down, facing me. Then I realized my mother wasn’t in the driver’s seat.
I started to feel scared, thinking that something bad had happened to her. I was nervous until I heard her voice drifting in from somewhere outside. What made me freeze in disbelief was the sound of another voice-my father’s.
Through the bright, flashing lights of the police cars, I saw my mother, my father, and another woman arguing in the street. “Who is that other woman?” I wondered. My dad was screaming and police officers were trying to separate the three of them. My mother looked sad and angry as she moved toward them, as if she wanted to fight, while my father yelled at her. The other woman looked like she was pregnant and I wondered if that’s why they were arguing.
I began to cry and the police officer tried to comfort me, but I ignored him. I just wanted to go home. I wanted it all to stop.
Replaced
Even earlier in childhood, I’d gotten used to my parents’ verbal arguments. Then my father started walking out and not coming back for days.
But by the time of the incident with the police cars, my parents had been separated for a couple of years. My father had left my mom for another woman, and now the “other woman” was pregnant.
Not long after the fight, my half-brother was born. I didn’t really know he existed until one day when my mother told me about him. She was sitting on the bed in her room when she called me over and showed me photographs of this boy she said was my half-brother. There was a picture of him in the bathtub, and one of my father holding him. Then she told me his name-Christophe David.
Frozen Out
In that moment, I felt betrayed and unloved by my father. My half-brother’s name was almost exactly like my own name, Christian David. I felt like I had been replaced. I felt like I wasn’t good enough, as if he’d decided that my mother, my sister, and I weren’t worth staying with. I assumed he didn’t care about me.
My mother also felt betrayed. After he’d left for good, she had looked sad. I remember her staring out of the bathroom window crying, and I’d hear her cry in her bedroom. She would wear loose-fitting clothes and didn’t seem to care about herself. I wondered if she felt she wasn’t good enough for him, either. Seeing my mom cry made me feel like I never wanted to cry for someone who hurt me.
Even though she was hurt, my mother wanted my dad to be in our lives. He would agree to come see my sister and me, and I would get excited because I wanted to spend time with him. But he never showed up, and I was always let down. It was like he was agreeing to visit without thinking or hearing himself. After a while, I saw right through his lies. Coming and going was all he’d ever done before, anyway.
Years went by and I didn’t hear from my father or see him. Sometimes when I saw children with their fathers, I would get a frozen feeling. I would dream that I was that little boy being thrown into the air and coming back down into his father’s arms. I dreamt that I had an ideal father who was loving, caring, and proud of me. Basically, I wanted a father I could actually call a father. I didn’t want to care about having a dad, but I couldn’t help it.
A Flash of Recollection
To my surprise, my mother and the “other woman” began speaking. It turned out that after my half-brother was born, my father left them, too. My mom wanted Christophe to be part of my and my sister’s life. She thought it would be good if we got to know him and to accept him as our brother. I was shocked. I didn’t want to be in his presence. I blamed him for my dad leaving, even though I knew he was just an innocent bystander like I was.
The day I finally met my half-brother I was nervous and angry. My mother took my sister and me to a pizza restaurant to meet him. The “other woman” and Christophe walked in holding hands. My half-brother, who must have been 7 or 8 at the time, had a tan complexion and short, dark hair; he looked only a little bit like my father. When they approached, my mother put on a smile and greeted them. I was confused because I had assumed my mother hated this former rival.
We sat down and ate pizza. It was a little quiet and awkward, but my mother and the “other woman” conversed. Christophe seemed shy at first, but my sister welcomed him with conversation. My mother looked at me as if to say, “Speak to your brother,” so I asked him about his likes and dislikes. Before we left, my mother took a picture of my sister and me with Christophe between us.
After the flash of the camera subsided, I closed my eyes. For a moment, I was right back in that night when I’d been woken up by the flashing lights of police cars. It still hurt. I saw my half-brother two more times after that, but it hurt to be in the same room with him. He was a reminder that my dad had replaced me, and I couldn’t forgive him or my father for that.
One Minute With Dad
I didn’t hear from my dad for years. Then, walking home from my grandmother’s apartment on a recent Saturday night, I heard a deep, accented voice say, “Hey, Christian.” I was surprised, wondering who could be calling me. I turned around and saw a black car and a man wearing a long-sleeved red shirt. His hair was slicked back and he wore glasses. I looked closely and then realized that it was my father. I was shocked.
“What is he doing here?” I wondered. My father is a cab driver and he explained that he was in the neighborhood doing a delivery. He walked toward me and tried to give me a handshake, but I slipped my hand away fast. He offered me a ride while looking at his watch. He didn’t want anything to do with me before, so I wondered why he was bothering now. But mostly, I was angry and dumbfounded. I refused his offer.
“He owes me more than just a ride,” I thought as he drove off without looking back. I walked home with tears in my eyes, hating him more and more. He saw me for about a minute after years of nothing, and that was it? He should regret all the painful damage he did. He missed out on my childhood and my sister’s.
Good Enough Without Him
I felt so down that night. I had never felt very good about myself because I assumed that if my own father could hurt me and leave me, then anyone could. But after I saw him, I decided I’d try not to let anyone make me feel like less of a person ever again. I told myself to toughen up.
In fact, I do think that being unloved, hurt, and betrayed by my father has made me mentally and emotionally stronger. After going through that period of depression, my mother began taking better care of herself and holding her head high again. She has shown me that, no matter what difficult position you’re in, you can still live life without being held down by the past, and that’s what I’m trying to do. I’m so glad and feel blessed that my mother is in my life, and I try to push away the feeling that something is missing.
As much as I yearn for a father, I know he is never coming back. But I also know that healing is possible. Even though my dad made me feel like I wasn’t good enough to do anything or be anyone, I eventually realized that I am very talented and intelligent-my father just isn’t around to see it.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.