One evening about four years ago, I walked into my apartment and heard the obnoxious noise of my family and their friends playing bingo in the living room. “Great,” I thought. “Bingo night for the millionth time! Thank God I have my quiet room.”
But when I reached my room I discovered a tall, brown-skinned young boy with long, black hair and the nerve to be lying on my bed and chatting on the phone like he was in his own house. Instead of apologizing, he glanced up and gave me a dirty look.
I immediately hated him. I gave him a dirty look back and slammed the door shut as I left the room. I found my cousin Jayleen, who explained that the boy was the son of one of my grandmother’s bingo friends. Jayleen knew him, so she went into my room and got him to leave. I threw myself on my bed, wondering if the boy was mad at me and realizing that he was pretty cute. Oh well.
Flirting Up the Wrong Tree
The next day my family played bingo again and to my surprise, the rude, cute boy was back. He was sitting in the kitchen and Jayleen introduced him.
I was expecting him to be a brat with a huge attitude problem. But we talked politely and before I knew it we were really getting along, making jokes and getting to know each other.
His name was Artie and he was 11 years old (I was 13 at the time). He kept flirting with me-complimenting me and gushing over my boots-and though I thought he was a bit girlish for my taste, I was interested. We ended up exchanging numbers and I couldn’t wait to hear from him again.
We spent the next week talking on the phone and made a real connection. Most of the time we kept the conversation light, but sometimes we’d talk about our issues with our families, or our insecurities. During our talks, his feminine way of speaking became more apparent to me. But I refused to believe that my possible future boyfriend could be gay.
One night a couple of weeks after we’d met, the conversation turned into flirtation. I started hinting that I liked him and was looking forward to hanging out soon, and all of a sudden he became really quiet. He was whispering something and I had to ask him to repeat himself several times. I didn’t realize Artie was trying to confess his deepest secret to me. Finally I heard what he said: “I’m gay.”
My New Best Friend
He explained that he’d known he was homosexual his whole life and he was finally coming to accept it. Although I’d known deep down that this was coming, I hadn’t expected it so soon.
After I was able to speak, I told him that I’d had an idea that he might be gay and that I loved him all the same. He was relieved. His confession brought us closer and I felt it was my personal responsibility to be a good friend and support him at this critical time in his life.
From then on, Artie and I were inseparable. We had so much in common: We were both boy-crazy, loved the same kinds of music, and were aspiring fashionistas. We spent most of our time making jokes and laughing so hard it hurt. When we weren’t weak from laughing, we were looking through fashion magazines while listening to reggaeton, or hitting the streets of Washington Heights. I liked being with Artie on those late bingo nights; it made me feel like I had a cool life outside of school and the friends I had there.
Coming Out and Dressing Up
Artie had other female friends who, like me, weren’t surprised by him coming out and accepted him just the same. But then came the hard part: coming out to his family. Artie’s Hispanic family is somewhat conservative and can be judgmental. I could totally relate; my Hispanic parents weren’t always easy to talk to. He said he was scared and nervous to tell them, but I told him that if they loved him they’d come around.
Fortunately, his family was mostly supportive. His mother even took him to the gay pride parade. But his father remained in denial about Artie’s homosexuality, and because of that Artie isn’t comfortable around his dad even now.
As Artie and I became closer, he told me he was confused about his identity and really wanted to be a girl. One day he brought hair extensions, a tube top, a mini skirt, and some heels to my house and tried them on. It was hilarious-he didn’t look anywhere near a girl, more like a boy playing dress up with his mother’s too-tight clothes. Then he said he wanted to go outside like that, and I warned that I would act like I didn’t know him.
He looked at himself carefully in the mirror. “Yeah, you’re right, Amanda. I look ridiculous. I look like a guy. I don’t know if this is for me.” He seemed disappointed.
“I’m sorry, babe. But you’re a hot guy! I’m sure that there are millions of hot guys out there looking for a guy like you, so don’t worry about it. Besides, you’re only 13, Mister! You have a long way to go,” I said.
“I am pretty hot,” he agreed. “OK, I’ll stick to being Artie. I guess Michelle will never be.”
Insulted and Humiliated
Sometimes I saw him face much bigger problems. One bingo night, the two of us were on our usual outing around the block, rating boys and sipping caramel Frappuccinos. As we walked along Pinehurst Avenue, about five or six men sat in front of a bodega with beers in their hands. They were laughing really hard and talking loudly. When we approached they fell completely silent, making it obvious that they were studying us.
We went on with our conversation, Artie his usual loud and effeminate self. When we passed, they started shouting.
“Hey Mami, I mean Papi! Come here!”
“F-cking f–got!”
“Awww, look at the little girl!”
They started cracking up. Our conversation stopped and I knew Artie was humiliated. He was furious and screamed, “Go to hell, a–h-les!”
Although he seemed all tough, I knew it hurt him. There were many incidents like that. One time a bunch of little kids followed us to my building screaming, “Gay! Gay! Gay!” In these situations I always tried to comfort him, by just listening or by making a joke to take his mind off it.
His Disappearing Act
Artie and I spent the whole summer and school year together, having fun adventures. But the next summer, he suddenly stopped calling me and showing up to bingo nights. I tried getting in contact with him, with no success. His mother told me that he was hanging out with his other friends.
I was mad and a little jealous, because I didn’t get along with his other friends. It felt like Artie was trading me in for friends he maybe thought were cooler. I gave up calling him and resolved that he would come to me eventually. But a month passed, and nothing.
One night my cousin Adanalcy and I went to get some food. On our way back, Adanalcy spotted Artie across the street with his little group of girlfriends. He seemed like he was having so much fun and was oblivious to us. I wanted to leave, but Adanalcy kept insisting we say hi. We went right up to Artie and the look on his face was half surprised and half scared.
“Oh, hi guys! What’s up? I haven’t seen you in the longest!” he said, trying to act like nothing was wrong. I politely greeted him back. Soon we were walking with him and his friends, feeling as awkward as hillbillies on Wall Street. Then his friends decided to go to McDonald’s, and he went another way with us.
Betrayed and Confused
As we were walking, all of us were silent. I felt the tension in the air. Finally Artie exclaimed, “Amanda, just say it! OK? Why don’t you just get it all out and scream at me already?”
I was taken aback. “What are you talking about? I’m fine. It’s whatever.”
“Amanda, I’m not stupid. I know you’re mad. Just get it over with.”
“Well, Artie, if you want me to say how much of a bad friend you’ve been lately, then yeah, you have been. You’ve totally abandoned me for those girls that I don’t like! And then you sneak around hanging out with them. That’s mad messed up,” I said.
“Oh God, calm down. You’re really exaggerating. I don’t have to be with you 24/7,” he said.
I felt betrayed and confused. “You know what, Artie? Go with your little friends and have fun. I really don’t care anymore,” I said. Then I grabbed Adanalcy, and Artie walked away without even looking back.
Too Much Fun to Let Go Of
Artie and I didn’t talk for the next week. Eventually he instant messaged me, apologizing and saying that I was right-he wasn’t being a very good best friend-but since he’d been hanging out with me so much he was trying to fix things between him and his old friends.
I was surprised that he just came right out and said he was wrong, and it was hard to keep up a tough front. But I told him how he’d made me feel, and wrote that our friendship wouldn’t last if he continued to cut me off and then act like everything was fine.
He apologized again and by the end of our IM conversation, I’d accepted his apology. I wanted to forgive and forget. Having such a fun friend wasn’t something I wanted to let go of.
After that we still hung out a lot less often than we had before, which took a while to get used to. But as I found other friends and new things to do, I realized that I didn’t need him there all the time to have fun. And as I realized I had bigger things to think about, like school and my family, fretting over Artie abandoning me seemed immature.
A New Perspective
These days, we still don’t see each other much, but we communicate over the phone and online. He will always be my Artiekins and no matter how mad I may get at his flakiness, I know that that’s just the way he is.
There’s still part of me that wonders why he can’t make more time for me. But at the same time, I value the openness I feel with him. I can tell him anything.
I’m proud of Artie because he has become so confident and open about himself, and I know part of it is because of our friendship. But I’ve realized he’s also taught me to be stronger and more confident in myself, because he makes it seem so easy.
If he can go through so many struggles for being gay and still hold his head up high, then the things that I drive myself crazy over may not be that bad. His struggles have put things in perspective for me.
My Gay Boyfriend
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.