Fixing the Cracks

How do abusive foster parents get and stay in the system?

We’ve all heard stories about foster parents who are so neglectful, irresponsible, clueless, or even cruel that you can’t believe they’re allowed to continue bringing kids into their homes. How do they slip through the cracks of the system? How exactly are foster parents screened and trained?
In most states, foster parents must take about 30 hours of training before a child can enter their home. The classes teach parenting, how to work with the foster care system, and the special needs of children who go into care. There are usually more classes that foster parents must take after a child comes into their home.
People who want to be foster parents must also get a home study in most states to make sure their home is safe and healthy and that the child has his or her own space. They also get a criminal background check and must provide character references.
Lots of Training
There is a more intensive-and higher-paying-form of foster parenting called TFC, which stands for therapeutic, or treatment, foster care.
Children who go into TFC homes generally have mental, behavioral, or emotional difficulties. TFC parents get extra training on how to recognize side effects of medication, and the other emotional fallout of abuse and neglect. TFC parents work more closely than other foster parents with caseworkers, social workers, etc. TFC parents generally can take in only one or two foster children.
This all sounds ideal. So why do so many kids experience abuse in their foster homes? The federal government says that in 2007 the rate of mistreatment of kids in foster care ranged from 0.08% to 1.32% across states. That doesn’t sound like a very big number, but if a state has 30,000 kids in foster care, a 0.5% rate means 1,500 kids are being abused in care.
We asked Susan Lambiase of the advocacy group Children’s Rights how bad foster parents get into the system.
Weak Spots
One way bad foster parents slip through the cracks is overloaded caseworkers who don’t make enough home visits. Lambiase says, “It’s very important for caseworkers to visit the foster homes. For a child with no special needs who’s been in care a while, once a month is enough, but at the beginning it should be once a week.” She says that foster parents need the caseworker support, too, and that respite foster care homes-which take a foster child for a weekend or a week-can help relieve a caregiver’s stress.
Another potential problem area is the background check. “There should be rigorous mental health background checks, and checks on who else lives in the home or visits regularly,” says Lambiase. But there are half a million children in foster care in the U.S., and it’s especially difficult to find foster parents for teenagers and for kids with special needs. “Foster care recruitment is difficult; and sometimes agencies are so desperate that they’ll cut corners,” says Lambiase.
Richard Wexler of the National Coalition for Child Protection Reform says this desperation also leads to underreporting of abuse in foster care. “Child welfare agencies are begging for beds and beggars can’t be choosers. So when it comes to foster care, there’s a huge incentive to see no evil, hear no evil, speak no evil, and write no evil in the case file.”
Official statistics on abuse in foster care are generally that 1 or 2 percent of kids in the system are abused each year. But Wexler says academic studies find that 25 or 30 percent of children are abused at some point during their time in care. “The academic researchers talk to kids after they’re no longer in the system and no longer have to fear retaliation,” he says. “And the academics have no reason to lie: They’re not investigating themselves.”
Lambiase and Wexler agree that the best way to prevent bad foster care situations is to not take children away from their families in the first place. But in order to do that, says Lambiase, “you have to support the families with things like in-home services for struggling parents, weekly visits, one-on-one parent training, substance abuse treatment.” As states’ budgets get cut more and more, this isn’t likely to improve. There’s federal money for foster care, but not for supporting families with in-home services, says Lambiase.
Report, Report, Report
Things can get better, though, even in a recession. Children’s Rights targets states with high rates of abuse and brings class-action lawsuits against those states on behalf of the kids. The organization estimated, through a case study of several hundred kids, that as many as 20 percent of foster kids in New Jersey had suffered abuse, so they brought a lawsuit in 1999. New Jersey agreed to reform the system and got the official abuse-in-care rate down below 1 percent, says Lambiase, in part by lowering caseloads and providing more respite homes.
So if you’re suffering abuse in your foster care home, keep telling people. Sometimes the flaws in the system do get fixed.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.