My mom is overprotective and doesn’t let me do anything without her being right there. I’m 17 years old and she treats me like a young child. She tells me what to wear and how to do my hair and she doesn’t let me go out with friends or on dates. She even makes me hold her hand when we cross the street.
And when I do ask her for a little freedom, she just shuts me down. It’s very hard for me to talk to her, and I feel like she never listens.
I interviewed Dr. Carrie King, a psychologist, because I wanted to know how to deal with my mother never letting me leave her side. I thought other kids with overprotective parents or guardians might get some good advice from her, too.
Dr. King does therapy with kids and families. I interviewed her last year for a Represent story, but going back to her Brooklyn, NY, office-on a cold, rainy day-was better because this time the topic was more personal.
Why Parents Cling
I told Dr. King that my mother is overprotective and asked her if it’s natural for parents to want to control their kids. “It’s natural for parents to wish they could control their kids,” she answered. “Parents are experiencing fear, loss, pride, sadness as their kids grow up.”
She added, “It’s very common for teenagers and parents to battle over how much freedom the kid gets. Parents have different reasons for keeping their kids on a short leash. One reason might be that the kid misbehaved when they were given freedom. Another reason could be the parent’s own past-if they got in trouble as a teenager, they may assume their kid will, too.” That made sense to me because my mom did get in trouble as a teenager and now she’s worried that I’ll make the same mistakes.
But I’m not her. I deserve more freedom because it’s not like I’m a troubled kid. I don’t sneak out of the house or disobey her. She says things like, “You’re not missing anything. You have all the time in the world to get drunk and get in trouble.” But I’ve never been in any kind of trouble. I think she needs to listen to me more.
Seeing Both Sides
Dr. King said that compromise is a good way to reach agreement with someone. “Let the restrictive parent know that you’re trying to see his or her side,” she said. “Tell them you know it’s complex and that an outsider could see both people’s side.”
I do try to see my mother’s side. Not all parents of girls who worry about pregnancy are being overprotective. There’s a chance that any girl might get blindsided by love and get pregnant. It’s true that when you are a child yourself you are not ready to raise another child. But I don’t need to hear it constantly! It’s like my mom is the reminder, and I’m the bulletin board.
Dr. King even agreed that my mom’s leash is too short. My mother won’t let me go anywhere I want, but she will drag me places I don’t want to go. I’ve never had the opportunity to be a normal teenager. I just want to go out with friends and to shop for my own clothes. I’m tired of hearing other kids say, “Yo, remember that party from last weekend? That hot!” and having to sit in on the weekends when I know kids my age are out having fun. Instead, I stay home, watch TV, and play my music as loud as I want on my iPod to drown out my sadness and frustration.
My mom has kept me so isolated that it can be scary dealing with other people, and I feel like I’m being robbed of something important. Being young is when you find yourself, learn how to express yourself, and even if you do stupid things, down the line you learn and move on. My mom feels she is protecting me and I feel like she’s going overboard. She thinks shutting out a social life is making me more safe, but I disagree.
If I did have a social life, then new situations wouldn’t be such a big shocker when I got out on my own. I would be more open to people and better prepared for adulthood.
On the Same Team
Dr. King said there are ways to persuade a parent to trust you more. “Sometimes what helps in a discussion like this is to approach the parent like an ally, not an opponent. Say,’Mom, I need your help’ or’Dad, I need your advice’ and that will make them feel like a parent. That will make them feel like you’re both on the same team. It’s not as threatening.”
This was helpful because I have to figure out a way to talk to my mother without feeling like it’s going to go nowhere. I’ll be 18 next year, and she has to back off and stop seeing me as a little girl. For example, over the summer I wanted to get a job and start saving for college. I asked her to sign working papers for me, but she said no.
She doesn’t want to hear the fact that I need to start preparing for adulthood and learning to be more responsible. I have to work for what I want or need so that I won’t always have to ask her. But until I turn 18, I have to go by what she says.
After she said no to the working papers, I started to worry that she wouldn’t let me take a GED prep course either, and so I didn’t ask her. She says she wants me to go to college, but I was still afraid she would find some reason to say No.
Dr. King suggests that kids try to find common ground. “If your mom isn’t letting you do something you need to do for your future, you could ask,’Mom, how do you see the next two years?’ Then take the parent’s vision and work backwards to the things you want, like’If you see me going to college, you need to let me go to the GED class.’ don’t fight over visions; find out what your visions have in common.”
Coping With Frustration
Dr. King admits that sometimes a parent or guardian just won’t budge. “Sometimes the best argument in the world won’t work. You can lay out a great case and the parent may say’no way.’ If you are under 18, that parent has control over you. In that case, it’s just about coping.”
Dr. King says there are different ways to cope. “You can process your anger and frustration, by reading, by writing, with therapy. You have to express your feelings; people die when they don’t get those feelings out. Because it’s boiling inside of you.”
One way I express myself and build up my confidence is writing for Represent. I hesitated to join the writing staff here because I was nervous, but I’m becoming myself by writing about myself. I’m also proving that I have courage to move past my fears.
A month or so after I saw Dr. King, I finally asked my mom if I could take a GED prep course. I didn’t exactly do it like Dr. King said; I just made it quick and firm because I did go blank talking to her, like I always do.
My mom agreed to let me get my GED when I turn 18. That’s later than I would like it to be, but I’m glad she said yes. Another weight has been lifted because now I don’t have to go behind her back. It’s a relief to have gotten that conversation over with, but I still have a long way to go. If I keep speaking up to my mother and take that chain off, I will be able to say what’s on my mind to anyone in the future.
More Leash, Please
A psychologist tells teens how to get more freedom
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.