You’re not supposed to judge a book by its cover, but what about its title? My Story: Blogs by Four Military Teens, sounded like a book written by cyber generation teens. I was curious to hear the stories of real teens whose parents are in the military and to learn about their struggles.
I was immediately disappointed when I realized that the book, deceptively called My Story, is not really the story of anyone at all. It turns out that these are fictional blogs written by two adult authors. Their accounts of what teens with parents in the military go through seemed more like a bunch of assumptions than anything that’s true to life.
Four Fake Teens
The book is broken down into five sections. The first section is the story of Mariah, a teenage girl who struggles to deal with the deployment and then return of her mother, who is in the Army National Guard.
Next there’s Adam, who represents the complex feelings of teens with parents suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder. After returning from a war zone, his father acts differently and is unable to be around groups of people. Carlos, the third story in book, must learn how to cope with having a disabled father after his dad loses his right leg to a bomb.
In the last story, Meredith becomes depressed after her father’s homecoming. The family had gotten used to life without him and his return prompts constant fights in the household. In the fifth and last section, readers who have a parent in the military are invited to write their own stories.
Here’s my question: Why didn’t the authors just seek out teens’ writing to begin with? If the book is supposed to help others relate to real-life military teens, then why not use real stories? Instead, authors Michelle D. Sherman, who is a psychologist, and her mother and co-author, DeAnne M. Sherman, wrote about fictional teens so the characters’ reactions would fit their idea of how a particular situation should be handled.
No Fairy Tales, Please
The teens in the book end up finding help through a military group at school or camp. (The only exception is Meredith, who sees a psychologist and is diagnosed with depression.) The problem is that it just doesn’t seem believable. How many teens really attend a school with an outreach program for kids of military parents? I know I don’t. And not all teens learn how to cope with the changes in their lives so easily, or have such a happy ending. Get real, we live in the 21st century and the target audience of this text no longer believes in fairy tales.
This book wasn’t written by us nor is it our story; I don’t know any teenagers who would blog about their parents as much as the characters in the book. Worse, the stories are so brief that there is no time to develop an attachment to any of the characters, and it’s so rushed that there is no build up of anticipation. The result is an extremely dull and anticlimactic read.
From the struggles of having to adjust to life without a parent, to the depression and drama that a parent coming back from war can bring, the book aimed to tackle it all and, in the end, it missed all of its marks. This book is an easy read; it’s just not a good one.
Adult Authors Need to Get Real
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.