When I was in 6th grade, my mother bought me a Game Boy Advance SP. I took it to school to show my friends. It got stolen from my book bag, and my mom was furious. She eventually forgave me and bought me another, but she made me promise not to take it to school again.
About a year later, my Game Boy was still in my room on the shelf, and my mom had stopped checking to make sure it was there. As I was eating lunch with my friends one day, one of them asked me about it.
“Bring it tomorrow!” she said. “I want to play that Yoshi game.”
I stopped eating my french fries and said, “No way! I promised my mom I wouldn’t.”
She smirked. “I guess you don’t have a Game Boy, then. If you really have a Game Boy, show me tomorrow.”
I frowned. I didn’t want to disobey my mom and break my promise, but at the same time I didn’t want to be embarrassed in front of my friends. When I got home, I put my Game Boy in my book bag before I went to sleep.
The next day I showed it to my friend. Nothing bad happened, so I took it to school again the next day, and the next day. I felt bad for breaking my promise to my mom, but it seemed like there was nothing to worry about.
But one day, I looked in my book bag and the Game Boy wasn’t there. I couldn’t possibly tell my mother about it this time. She would be so hurt that I disobeyed her again, and that I was so careless with something she’d bought for me.
One Friday, I walked into my house and my mother was standing there. Her arms were crossed and she looked angry.
“Hi, Mom,” I said, as calmly as I could.
My mother continued glaring at me. “Your Game Boy is not on the shelf. Is there something you want to tell me?” she snapped.
“Umâ” I felt I couldn’t tell her what really happened, because I knew how hurt she would be that I’d lost it again. But when she asked again, I told her.
I will never forget her sad and angry expression. She shouted with tears in he eyes, “It’s bad enough you disobeyed me, but lying? How could you? You know I hate liars.” All I could do was hang my head in shame.
Eventually she forgave me, but refused to buy a Game Boy again, so I saved money and got another that I still have today.
-Tichina Fields
Do you agree with the saying, “What they don’t know won’t hurt them”?
Ayana: My dad added to that quote. He said, “What you don’t know can’t hurt you, but it will drive you crazy.” You will have a suspicion, even if you don’t want to outright ask.
Lea: If you lie, people will end up finding out the truth anyway. So you should just tell the truth, and if it hurts the person, they’ll get over it.
Are there some truths you don’t want to hear?
Cinorow: I was watching Maury some time ago. This woman was with a dude since 8th grade, they were thirtysomething, they had all these kids-and she told him these kids might not be his. Stuff like that, I wouldn’t want to know.
Would you have told your mom about losing the Game Boy?
Ayana: Beating around the bush only makes it worse. The fact that she left it in her book bag showed she was irresponsible. If you’re going to break the rules, at least be more careful.
Ben: Exactly.
Do you follow rules because it’s wrong to break them, or because you don’t want to get caught?
Ayana: I could say, “I follow the rules because they’re there.” But no, I base my decisions on the consequences.
Would you take something from a store if you could be sure no one would find out?
Ayana: Yes.
Perry: If I wouldn’t get caught.
Let’s say your classmate left an iPod in view. No one is around to see you take it, but you know the person would be upset to lose it. What would you do?
Ayana: I wouldn’t do that to a specific person, because I know if that happened to me, I would be really upset. That’s just rude.
Ben: One day I was walking and I saw somebody’s cell phone fall out of his pocket. He didn’t even know. I took it, but I thought it wouldn’t be right to keep it, so I gave him the phone back. And the guy didn’t even say “thank you.” I kind of regret it. I could have made money out of it!
Torres: If it’s a stranger, it’s OK to me to take what they drop. I don’t know if you’re rich or poor. But I know it’ll be useful to me.
Lupe: It used to kill me when my mom used to say, “It’s about the principle.” I was like: “Give me a concrete definition. Can I hold principle in my hand? No. What costs more, principle or $20?” Now that I’m older, I see more what she’s talking about. Thinking about yourself versus thinking about other people is an everyday battle.
What Would You Do? Teens Debate What it Means to Do the Right Thing
A Loss I Couldn't Admit
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.