What Would You Do? Teens Debate What it Means to Do the Right Thing

Lying for a Best Friend

It was May of freshman year. My best friend, Betty, and I decided to attempt the most common lie of all best friend lies: to tell each of our parents we were hanging out together when we weren’t.
Betty’s parents were going out for dinner, so she told them she would spend the evening at my house. When she arrived, I told my parents we were going out to a party.
That part wasn’t a total lie. I had a birthday dinner to go to in Brooklyn. But Betty wasn’t coming with me. She had a party to go to in Manhattan and her party had one thing mine didn’t: alcohol.
I was a bit unsure about the whole scheme we’d concocted. It wasn’t the alcohol that bothered me most; it was lying. I don’t like to lie-not to my parents, and especially not to other people’s parents. My parents are less strict than Betty’s and I would’ve been allowed out regardless, but her parents would not have approved of her going to any party, anywhere, whether or not there was alcohol.
Still, I was her best friend, so it was my duty to help her. We were partners in crime.
Everything went smoothly until 10:30 p.m., when I received an urgent text: “My parents are leaving their dinner and they want to pick me up at your house!”
I rushed home. It turned out Betty made it back to my house first, right before her parents arrived. By the time I skidded to a stop in front of my house, she was texting again: “I’m in the car going home. Everything’s OK.”
I sighed, relieved. But Betty had texted too soon. In science class they teach you that some people have an enzyme that causes them to react very noticeably to substance changes in their bodies. Betty has that unfortunate enzyme, so if she drinks alcohol, it shows physically. When she got home that night and stepped into her well-lit house, she was the color of Elmo. Her mother knew instantly that she’d been drinking and that she’d lied.
Now her mother didn’t trust her, and Betty was miserable. I also felt terrible. It was a dumb plan and not only did she get in trouble, I felt responsible for it.
Even after all that, if I had to lie for a friend again, I probably would, except I’d take more care in considering the consequences. I know that in life’s rules, lying isn’t the right thing to do, but in best friend rules, it sometimes is.
-Christina Gee
Are there times when it’s OK to lie?
Jane: It depends on the severity of the lie. There are lies that don’t have much impact, like lying about eating the last Popsicle, but there are also dangerous lies that should be given some thought before you tell them.
Ayana: If the girl had an abusive father and wanted to stay at my house, I would lie to her father and say I hadn’t seen her. If you’re protecting someone, it’s good to lie. But not just to go to a party.
Perry: If someone is trying to oppress you or keep you from growing up and being your own person, lying can be good.
If you think your friend is being treated unfairly by overly strict parents, does that make it more OK?
Perry: If parents are too strict, then teens all lie.
Ayana: I have a friend who is only allowed to go to parties if me and the rest of her nine friends going to the party all promise her parents that we’re gonna walk her back homeâ If they say they want her home at 12, I’ll make sure we all bring her back at 12. There are ways around lying.
Is lying to help another person different than lying to help yourself?
Cinorow: No, because a lie is a lie, no matter who you lie to.
Ayana: If you’re lying to help someone else, it’s less selfish than lying to help yourself.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.