Book Review: Brother, I’m Dying

Brother, I’m Dying, by Edwidge Danticat, is an outstanding memoir that will tear your heart to pieces and glue it back together again. Danticat (who wrote for this magazine as a teen!) is well known for her novels, but this is her first book about her own life. In the book, Danticat expresses her love for the two men who raised her and presents a sorrowful image of the tragedies some Haitians go through in the United States and in Haiti.
The story begins on a hot morning in July 2004 when Danticat discovers that she is pregnant on the same day that she learns her father is dying of a lung disease. This news is soon followed by more tragedy, this time relating to Danticat’s Uncle Joseph.
Life in the War Zone
Danticat was only 2 when her father emigrated from Haiti to the U.S. Her mother followed when she was 4, leaving Danticat and her younger brother in the care of her Uncle Joseph and her Aunt Denise. Joseph Dantica (his name is spelled differently from Edwidge’s) was an extraordinary man: a minister, a survivor of throat cancer, and a role model who touched the lives of his family and community profoundly. He raised Danticat, her younger brother, and many other children of relatives and friends. Danticat and her brother lived with Uncle Joseph until she was 12, then joined their parents in the U.S.
Her uncle’s neighborhood in Port-au-Prince (the capital of Haiti) was a beautiful place but was (and still is) a political war zone. For years, Uncle Joseph refused his younger brother’s pleas for him to emigrate to the U.S. He felt too bonded to his church, his school, and his life in Haiti to leave.
But in 2004, while his brother (Edwidge’s father) was battling a life-threatening illness, Uncle Joseph had no choice but to let go of that bond and flee to the U.S. That’s because Haiti’s President, Jean-Bertrand Aristide, had been sent into exile and the country was becoming a true war zone. When some United Nations peacemakers shot at a local gang from the roof of Uncle Joseph’s church, the gang members destroyed his church and threatened to murder him. Uncle Joseph managed to escape and fly to Miami. But as we read in Brother, I’m Dying, that only led him to a more horrible fate-he died in an immigrant detention center there.
Adversity and Hope
As Danticat brought her baby girl, Mira, into the world, the splendor of new life was offset by her family suffering heartbreaking loss. As Danticat describes this experience, her words will leave you out of breath. She turns grave adversity into a story of acceptance, courage, and hope for a better future.
I am a Haitian immigrant myself, and Danticat’s book left me speechless with mixed-up emotions. I came here in 2000, and I knew that a lot of people were leaving Haiti in 2004 after the president left. But never did I think the country was in such a horrific situation that they were burning churches and schools. I was also shocked and angry at how the U.S. immigration officials treated an elderly man like Uncle Joseph, who was 81 when he died.
A Courageous Writer
I’m amazed at Danticat’s ability to write such a powerful memoir about something so personal and emotional. Writing that book took a lot of courage and an honest heart. I remember when I lived in Haiti, many journalists were killed for sharing their opinions and speaking the truth on political issues. Brother, I’m Dying opens a portal to many issues that I’ve rarely seen Haitian writers explore.
I’m also happy that Danticat chose the career that she did. In my experience, most Haitian parents encourage their children to become doctors or nurses. Writers? Well, not so much. The fact that Danticat followed her dream to become a writer-and succeeded-inspires me to take my own writing to the next level.
I would recommend this book to everyone, especially teens who are going through a difficult time. It can give you courage to deal with grief and help you stand firm through times of hardship. To me, the message of Danticat’s book is that when the unfairness of life cuts down the trunk of your family tree, your roots will make the tree rise again, for they are numerous, strong, and full of momentum.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.