“A homosexual with power-that’s scary!” That’s what Harvey Milk, the main character in the movie Milk, says not long before his assassination. Directed by Gus Van Sant, Milk is based on the true story of Harvey Milk, the first openly gay man to be elected to public office in California.
The movie starts off with Milk (played by Sean Penn, who amazed me with his performance) bumping into a much younger guy named Scott (played by James Franco). The two go back to Harvey’s place to celebrate his 40th birthday. They fall in love and move to San Francisco, where they open a camera shop on Castro Street (at the center of the Castro, a neighborhood that was becoming increasingly popular with the gay community). The shop eventually becomes Milk’s campaign headquarters when he enters the world of community activism and politics.
After running and losing twice, Milk finally gets elected to the San Francisco Board of Supervisors in 1977. But his life ends too soon when he’s shot (along with the mayor) after only 11 months in office.
People and Politics
The movie isn’t just about his political life, but about his personal relationships too. Milk gets so committed to and obsessed with his political campaign that Scott eventually leaves him after years of supporting him.
Another character I found interesting was Milk’s colleague at the Board of Supervisors, Dan White (played by Josh Brolin). Even though he was married with a child, it seemed to me like he secretly had feelings for Milk. When Milk goes back on his word with Dan, it drives Dan to depression, alcoholism and worse.
I loved the fact that they used real-life footage from the 1970s in the movie. For instance, rather than using an actress, they showed footage of the real Anita Bryant, a singer and former Miss America runner-up turned anti-gay activist. She campaigned against gay rights and succeeded in getting rid of a local Florida law that protected gay people from discrimination.
That led to California’s Proposition 6, a proposal that would have banned gay men and women from teaching in the state’s public schools. I was shocked that some people thought that the idea of a homosexual teaching their children was wrong. What does a teacher’s sexuality have to do with them teaching a class?
Spoke Out for Change
Luckily, with Harvey Milk leading the fight, Proposition 6 was defeated. The movie showed how, during his short time in politics, Milk continuously spoke out for the rights of gay people and for civil rights in general.
The movie also showed footage of the thousands of mourners who, after Milk’s assassination, marched through San Francisco with candles in hand. The procession stretched for miles in the night. It showed that Harvey Milk touched many people in his lifetime.
Milk was nominated for eight Academy Awards and won two: Sean Penn’s Best Actor award and Best Original Screenplay. But that’s not why you should see it. You should see Milk to get a better understanding of the hardships that homosexuals went through to gain more rights. Watching this movie made me happy because someone who is gay like me rose to a position of power and was able to make changes.
Milk: Story of a Gay Rights Hero
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.