My Sister and Me

When it comes to relationships, we're very different

One day I was at my sister’s house and she, her girlfriend Asja and I were just sitting around. Her girlfriend grabbed her and picked her up and asked her, “Do you love me?”
“No, I do not love anyone,” Natalie said with a smile on her face.
Then her girlfriend dropped her on the couch. Natalie was saying, “No, come backâ”
Her girlfriend said to me, “See, your sister doesn’t love me.” She seemed a little hurt.
“Natalie,” I said, “how could you be so mean?”
For a long time I saw my sister as very cold-hearted because she didn’t fall in love with anyone. Me, on the other hand, I fall in love too quickly and try to keep the person in my life no matter what. After they freak out and push me away because I’m so clingy, I become upset. Then I act like I don’t care, which usually gets the other person even more involved with me. I know, I’m slick.
So it’s hard for my sister and me to understand each other’s styles.
Guarding Against Heartbreak
Natalie cannot understand why I usually am dating more than one guy at a time. It’s not because I don’t want to commit to someone, it’s because I’m afraid to. I always want another guy around just in case.
For a few years I was dating a guy I considered the love of my life. After I fell out of love with him, but while we were still together, I started seeing other guys, too. I was telling Natalie that once, and she said, “What the hell, Cynthia! Come on, stay with Ismael. don’t do that.”
“But he always threatens to break up with me. I don’t think I’m in love with him anymore. I want someone who is more my type, who is not shy or unconfident,” I said.
“All right, then just tell him that you want a break and that you want to be with someone else right now.”
“No, because then that is hurting him and he needs me and I don’t want to hurt him. And what if I’m wrong? What if I don’t find someone else better? So let me just do it like this now and not hurt him by telling him,” I pleaded.
“OK, whatever,” she said. She couldn’t understand how I could be so afraid to be alone for even a little while.
Keeping Her Cool
I don’t understand Natalie either. She just goes out with people and gets close to them, spending more and more time around them, but she still won’t develop intense feelings for them. She says she likes being free and wild, and avoids intimacy.
She wasn’t joking when she told Asja she didn’t love her. Not long ago she broke up with her.
“What the hell? You’re breaking up with Asja? don’t do that to her. Come on, Natalie, you know you love Asja. Would you like it if someone broke your heart?”
“No, but I don’t knowâ” she said.
“Well, you have to find out what you want and stop breaking people’s hearts,” I told her-which is advice I should take myself.
I understand that Natalie does not want to get hurt and I admire that she thinks about herself and her future. But I worry when she says that she just does not fall in love, that she never feels like that. She says, “Relationships are luxuries,” and “You don’t need a partner.”
Reacting to Our Parents
I wonder if she wants to shut herself off to love because she saw the ways that my father was treating our mother and she never wanted anyone to do the same to her. (He was violent and mean when he was drunk.) But it could just be that she likes being alone, spending time by herself or with friends and having nothing to worry about.
For me, I worry that I need a man too much. I think that I need to feel loved because I never felt loved by my father. I was always afraid of him and he never told me he loved me. But I remember a few tender moments when my dad took care of me. Maybe I don’t have the scared feeling that Natalie has because I felt tenderness for a few moments and want it back so badly.
I think the difference in our ages might also affect how my sister and I see love. My sister had more responsibilities because she was older, and was treated like an adult. She probably wanted to feel less responsible for others. I got to be a kid, and in my relationships I still look for guys to take care of me. My sister fears that getting close to someone else will get in the way of her future, but I fear that if I don’t have anyone by my side to help me then it will be harder to reach my goals.
Both of our parents died when we were still young-I was 8 and Natalie was 10 when my dad died, and two years later our mom died. Their deaths gave me a fear of losing someone once I loved them. My strategy is to love and then try to prevent the loss. Natalie’s is not to love at all.
Take It Slow
But my way of getting close too quick is risky. My mind feels like it is in love with someone I don’t even know very well, and who doesn’t know me. Just knowing that I connect with someone excites me. It feels good but it is not real love, it’s just pretending.
Natalie and I would probably both be better off if we could be more like each other. I think she’d be happy if she really trusted someone enough to fall in love. And I am trying her method to not fall in love that easily. I have a new boyfriend now, and I am holding back my feelings a little bit. I say to myself, “Do not even fall in love with him. Wait and see if you still want to be with him in the future.”
It’s hard, though. At the beginning of our relationship things were up and down, and he told me he wanted to wait a month and just be friends, to get to know me before committing to a relationship. I was mad! I wanted to know right away whether he was going to go out with me or not.
“If I’m special, then why wait?” I said.
“If you’re special, then why rush?” he replied.
I was outraged at first. Then his words made me feel a little more secure.
We did start dating, and I’m still working on taking it slow. Instead of always thinking of him, I try to focus a little bit more than usual on myself and things that I have to do, like finishing school and getting a job. My boyfriend can’t be my whole life.
Learning to Trust
I hope I can be more like my sister-strong, and sure that she does not need someone to be there to support her or tie her down.
I also hope she can learn a little from me. When my sister tells me she doesn’t need anyone but herself, I just think that is absurd. I like shopping by myself, but that doesn’t mean it wouldn’t be fun to have someone along to talk to sometimes. There’s no reason for her to be so cold-hearted.
I hope that as we get older, I can have more confidence and just stay with one person. I hope that Natalie can also stay with someone and develop strong feelings. Neither of us has ever trusted anyone enough to get close and stay close yet, but I hope we can find ways to a truly close and trusting deep love.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.