Names have been changed.
I always worried that I’d be considered a snitch for telling on my sister. My brother told me that I had messed everything up. But I had finally decided that I’d had enough.
When my sister got custody of my brother and me two years ago, everything was good in the beginning. Fatima, who’d always been a mother figure to me, had been trying to get custody of us for about 10 years, since she turned 18. She always told us that she wanted all of us to be together.
When I was 8, my brother and I went to live with my aunt in New Jersey. My sister would come to visit us during the holidays and summers, and she always brought me gifts on Christmas and my birthday.
Her visits were a much-needed break from my aunt, who was verbally and physically abusive. During the difficult times, Fatima (next to my brother) was my main source of comfort. But before she could get things together to get custody of us, the agency found out about the abuse in my aunt’s household and my brother and I were sent to a foster home in Brooklyn.
What Happened to My Sister?
A year later, Fatima finally got custody of us. But by then I had mixed feelings about it because my mother (who is addicted to crack) and Fatima’s boyfriend, Haze, would be living with us in a one-and-a-half-bedroom apartment, and Fatima was expecting a baby. Fatima kept telling me that she was going to find a bigger space for us, just give her time.
When I first moved in with my sister, I thought that living with my mom would be a big challenge. It only took a few days for me to realize we had a much bigger problem: Haze.
From the day I first met him I didn’t like him. He was an aspiring rapper, very cocky, wore the baggy clothes and smoked. I noticed he was disrespectful to Fatima. he’d cut her off and tell her to shut up. Of course she’d pick a fight with him afterward to show us she could stand up for herself. But I soon realized that was all just talk.
Whatever Haze wanted, she would get it for him. I’d seen her stand up to her previous boyfriends, and I had no idea who this new Fatima was.
One Terrible Night
The first time I saw things get physical was two days before my sister’s baby shower. My brother and Haze came upstairs punching one another. My brother cursed at Haze and said, “You’re not my father.”
“I’m not, but you gonna respect me,” Haze said. He threw my brother on the floor, putting him in a headlock and choking him. I thought Haze was going to kill him.
My sister came out to break it up and Haze pushed her. I didn’t like that at all, so I grabbed a knife from the kitchen.
“Yo, don’t be pushing my sister, she’s pregnant. And let my brother go!”
I didn’t actually think I was going to stab anyone, but I felt like I could if I had to. My sister tried to loosen the grip of Haze’s hands from around my brother’s neck.
“Let him goâlet him goâhe has asthma!”
Haze finally let my brother go. “You lucky, son. She just saved your life.”
My brother and I tried to leave, but my sister locked the front door.
“Y’all not going nowhere, it’s 12 at night,” she said, blocking the way for us to get out.
“Come on now, Fatima, you’re always sticking up for him, always,” my brother said. “You don’t even care’bout us!”
We Only Wanted to Help Her
I guess I blocked out what happened after that. The next thing I remember, my sister was choking me, telling me that she hated me and wished that I were dead. At that point I really didn’t care about what happened to Fatima. I never imagined in a million years that my sister, my protector, would be choking me.
I really thought she was going to kill me. I hated her for putting her hands on me. I mean I really felt betrayed. She was getting mad at me and my brother instead of her boyfriend. I hadn’t done anything but try to help her.
After that my brother and I talked about reporting Fatima to ACS, but I wasn’t ready. Fatima kept telling me that things were going to get better and that we’d be moving to Jersey. By moving to Jersey, I thought she meant getting away from Haze. I convinced myself that Fatima would return to her old self and we’d be OK again once he was out of the picture.
Meanwhile, the fighting continued. My brother and I tried to help, but she always told us to “stay in a child’s place.” So we just listened to her cries for help from the other side of the wall. Sometimes we even laughed at her stupidity, but I knew deep down inside it hurt us both to hear this and not do anything about it.
New Start, or Same Old Tricks?
Last January, Fatima finally moved us to a bigger house in New Jersey. But it was a bittersweet start. Haze was still living with us, and he and Fatima were up to the same tricks, even after their baby boy was born.
After a couple of weeks, though, they broke up. Fatima kicked Haze out and he moved back to New York. But he still came around, and the violence continued.
By mid-June my sister was spending a lot of time in New York. Meanwhile my brother and I were stuck in the house with no cable or phone cause my sister wasn’t paying the bills.
One morning my sister came back home and told us to pack our things because we going to New York for the weekend. That weekend ending up being weeks, and weeks became months.
Eventually, my brother went back to Jersey to stay with my aunt because he’d found a job there. My sister was staying with Haze in Manhattan. I was staying with my cousins in the Bronx. We later found out we’d been kicked out of the house in Jersey because Fatima hadn’t paid the rent for months.
A Cry for Help
One day, my cousin, also a rapper, was making beats in his studio and called me in to ask for my opinion.
“That’s hot, you gonna let me get on a track?” I asked.
“How about this, you write something up and I’ll do the same,” he told me.
Five minutes later I came back in the room with my verse written up. It was all about what I’d been going through with Fatima. I told my cousin I didn’t want to read it out loud, but he insisted. I cleared my throat and started:
“We been evicted before, so your hard knocks mean nothing to me/I don’t tell my life story because I don’t feed on sympathy/I gotta feed myself, cause ain’t no one feeding me.”
After I’d finished the whole verse, he was speechless. His mouth dropped, and he called his wife over.
“Kali, Kali, read this,” he said, handing her the sheet of paper. Once she read it she looked at me with the same expression as her husband.
“Is this true?” she asked me.
“Yeah.”
“When did this happen?”
“Now.”
“Wait, this is happening right now? That’s why Fatima told you to stay here?”
I shrugged my shoulders. “I guess.”
I Told Them Everything
At the time, I didn’t realize that this was my way of asking for help. The whole night they tried to convince me to tell ACS about my sister abusing me and about our living situation. I didn’t know what to do. I decided to wait until after I returned from a week-long camp, where I had been going for the past two summers.
I was a little quiet at camp and my camp social worker began asking me questions about “how everything was at home.” Pressure had been building up inside of me and I cracked. I’d known her for a couple of years so I trusted her, and the whole story came pouring out.
The next day she sat me down. She wanted me to tell ACS immediately. I still wasn’t sure, but I just wanted to get it off my chest. Afterwards I called my brother and told him that I had told ACS everything.
“What you do that for? Man, you just messed everything up,” he said.
“They gonna find out anyway, dummy,” I said.
“Man, you a snitch,” he said, then hung up.
What About Me?
I found out that after hanging up with me he had called my sister and told her what I’d done. I felt betrayed. To make matters worse, our agency reacted to my report with shock and suspicion, as if I’d made the story up. They called my brother and he denied everything, so they looked at me as a liar.
I was disgusted with them. They were the ones who hadn’t been doing their job. If they’d been keeping better track of where we were and what was going on in the house, I wouldn’t have been put in the position of having to report my own sister.
I understood why my brother didn’t want Fatima to be reported. He wanted to stay in Jersey to finish up school so he could graduate on time and keep his job. Me “snitching” messed up his chances for all that. He was getting his life together and I respected that.
But what about me? I wasn’t working and I had no money. I also wasn’t in Jersey where I would be able to graduate on time like him. So why shouldn’t I make a better life for myself, too?
I didn’t want to worry about where I would be living next or whether my sister would be there when I woke up.
Moving Backwards
As soon as camp was over ACS moved my brother and me back with our old foster family in Brooklyn. A couple of days later, my foster mother told me she had spoken to my brother and he said he wasn’t mad at me anymore. She said he understood where I was coming from. But my brother and I never talked about it again. I think we both just wanted to move on.
The first weeks back with my foster family I went into a depression. I wasn’t eating or talking much. Sometimes I just felt numb, and I would lie in the dark all the time. I was exhausted, trying to make sense of everything. I felt like I was moving backwards, adjusting all over again to the foster family I’d been living with a year ago.
But with time, I did adjust. I had to. I had nowhere else to go. My foster mother really helped me through things by reaching out to me. She’d make me get up when I just wanted to lie in bed. Her encouragement reminded me that life still goes on.
I Did the Right Thing
It’s been nine months now, and my brother and I are doing great. Our guardian actually listens to us, we receive our weekly spending money and there’s no abuse.
The whole situation with my sister has taught me to start looking out for me, and that’s something I’ll remember in future relationships. I can’t stop her from dating Haze, but I won’t spend time with her if he’s involved. That’s one thing I’m not willing to compromise.
All of her verbal and physical abuse is something I’m not going to forget. I don’t know if I’ll ever be able to build a good relationship with my sister. But in the end I know I did the right thing by speaking up.
My whole life I was brought up to believe snitching is wrong, and I worried about the consequences of reporting my sister. But till this day I don’t look at myself as a snitch.
When you’re snitching, you’re telling on someone else. When you speak out, you’re standing up for yourself and others for cause. I stood up for myself and my brother. The outcome of that was losing a friendship with my sister, but gaining respect and control over my life.
Turning Her In
I reported my sister to protect myself
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.