Does Feeling Unpopular Make Girls Fat?

“Someone can be popular and still have low self-esteem,” my friend Ashley, 19, said confidently. She and my friend Angie, 17, were sitting in my house watching TV when I called them into the living room to ask them a few questions. Angie came in first, loud as usual. Ashley, who’s more quiet and laid back, came in right behind her, curious to see what I wanted to interview them about.
I had chosen to interview these two friends because I know how different they are from each other. I knew they would have different perspectives on a study I had recently read about in The Washington Post, which linked popularity and weight gain in teenage girls. I was surprised because I had never thought those two things could be related.
Filling in the Blanks
In the study, a group of researchers lead by Adina Lemeshow, a graduate student at the Harvard School of Public Health, looked at a survey of 4,446 girls aged 12-18 who were asked to rate their popularity on a scale of 1-10. Then they looked at the change in body mass (weight gain) of the same group of girls two years later.
The results showed that the girls who had rated themselves as less popular two years earlier were more likely to have gained excess weight. This was true regardless of the girls’ self-esteem. In other words, a girl could have high self-esteem but still rate herself as unpopular. According to the study, this girl would still be more likely to gain weight.
Many Kinds of Peer Pressure
Why should popularity influence us so much? My editor and I contacted Ms. Lemeshow to ask her this. She explained that the study provided no answers as to why girls gain weight after rating themselves as unpopular. So to fill in the blanks left by the study, I decided to interview Ashley, Angie and other friends to get their opinions about why this connection between popularity and weight gain exists.
Angie thought that a girl’s behavior changes depending on whether or not she feels noticed. “It would make sense for a person to gain weight if they don’t feel noticed,” she said. If this is true, then girls who receive a lot of attention might have the opposite experience. Just as celebrities stay thin because they know they’re being watched, I wonder if girls who feel they’re popular also want to keep up their appearance because they feel pressured by expectations.
Staying Active
Shameeka, 17, a fellow New Youth Connections writer, believes that people who consider themselves to be popular tend to be more active and surround themselves with active people, rather than just going home and eating.
“Hanging out is exercise!” said Shameeka, who rates her own popularity at 8 out of 10 because she feels that her interest in hanging out and going places makes it easy for her to interact with many people.
I agree with Shameeka that having friends keeps you active, and that could make some girls less likely to gain weight. Having friends who are positive and active helps motivate me to be positive and active, too.
Meanwhile, teens without many friends may feel less motivated and get discouraged. Viveca, 16, also a writer at New Youth Connections, noted that unpopular girls may look up to popular ones and feel they will never measure up. “When I see that a person is trying hard to live up to those high standards, that’s when everything else begins to go downhill and they end up feeling worse about themselves,” she said. That could lead to weight gain.
But some of the girls I interviewed didn’t believe feeling unpopular will always lead to gaining weight. In fact, they felt it might have the opposite effect.
Ashley agreed that being unpopular may cause people who are emotional eaters to eat and gain weight. But others might actually lose their appetites to stress and lose weight as a result of being unpopular. Both Ashley and Angie pointed out that people have different reactions to social pressure. “It depends on the person,” said Angie.
Not My Priority
This study suggests that popularity can have a big influence on the decisions we make, at least when it comes to food and exercise. But I feel popularity shouldn’t determine how you live your life.
Playing sports and exercising have always been my way of socializing, staying healthy and getting to know people, and I rate myself pretty high on the popularity scale. But I never did those things for the sake of being popular. Personally, worrying about my appearance or what I’m wearing isn’t my first priority. There are other things in life I would rather attend to than the pressure of being noticed.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.