When teens drink or have unprotected sex, adults often say we aren’t thinking about the risks of unsafe behavior. But a recent study shows that teens think things through far more than people realize. I wanted to know more, so I decided to interview Dr. Valerie Reyna, a Cornell University professor of human development, psychology and cognitive science. She’s the study’s co-author.
-David Schmutzer
NYC: What makes teens do risky things?
Dr. Valerie Reyna: The conventional wisdom has been that kids do these activities because they think they’re invulnerable and they’re going to live forever. The research has shown that’s not the case. In fact, teens think that they’re more vulnerable than adults think they are.
Teens actually take longer than adults to think about the risks and benefits of doing something dangerous. They even overestimate their risk. For example, they overestimate their probability of dying of lung cancer from smoking or getting HIV from unprotected sex.
But then they decide the benefits-like peer acceptance-outweigh the risks. That’s why they engage in the risky behavior.
NYC: When do teens start making more adult decisions?
Reyna: We used to think that you got to be an adult and you began to calculate risks more. But now the evidence suggests that you calculate less as you get older, and that’s why you don’t take risks. You say, “I could get AIDS if I have unprotected sex. I’m not even going to think of the cost-benefit ratio. It’s not worth the risk.”
The theory is that adults don’t need to go into the precise details and weigh them to make a decision. Instead, they base their decisions on their bottom-line “gist” of the situation.
NYC: What’s “bottom-line” or “gist-based” decision-making?
Reyna: There are certain situations that adults look at and they say, “Wow, we know how this situation is going to turn out before we hear the rest of the story.” For young people without experience, what happens can be a surprise.
For example, let’s say it’s prom night and some kids are renting a hotel room, there’s a lot of drinking going on, and there’s no adult supervision. Most adults won’t be surprised that there might be some unprotected sex in that situation. I’m not telling you much but an adult immediately gets the gist.
A teen might argue his friends are nice kids. But logical arguments don’t apply. The bottom-line decision is that you don’t get into that situation. If you’re not in that situation, nothing bad will happen to you.
NYC: Why do some teens choose not to take risks?
Reyna: There are teens who are thrill seekers and others who are more risk-averse and that continues into adulthood. Some teens appear to mature faster, which means they’re getting the “gist” sooner.
Why do some teens get the gist sooner than others? We don’t know, but as you get more experience, you learn more about risky behavior and your thinking changes.
Also, parents are often cited as the most important role models in a child’s life. They can do some good by sharing their values, and sharing the connection between their values and specific situations (like drinking or unsafe sex).
NYC: What surprised you in your research?
Reyna: Teens overestimate the risk of risky behaviors. The teens surveyed didn’t think they were immortal. In fact, some had a very fatalistic attitude [meaning they think they are powerless to change the future].
What’s the first thing public health officials do when they’re trying to educate teens? They tell teens what the risks are because they want to inform them. It’s very well intentioned, but it could backfire. If you tell a teen the risk is X and it turns out it’s lower than they thought it was, you could make them more likely to engage in risky behavior.
NYC: What’s your advice to teens?
Reyna: Examine your values carefully and think about how your everyday life connects to those values. Instead of thinking of values as an abstraction, think about how you would apply them to your encounters with people in concrete situations.
To read the study, visit www.psychologicalscience.org/pdf/pspi/pspi7_1.pdf.
Why Do Teens Take Risks?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.