The Overachievers

Being the Best Takes Its Toll on Teens

I go to Stuyvesant HS, supposedly one of the best public high schools in the city. Not surprisingly, a lot of the students who grace its halls are overachievers. There’s a school-wide pressure to apply to Ivy League universities like Harvard, Princeton or Yale.
It’s the topic of every conversation for the first half of senior year. No one ever says, “You have to apply to an Ivy.” It’s done more subtly. A raised eyebrow when there’s no Ivy in your list. A question of what you plan to major in because (insert Ivy here) has a great (insert major here) program.
That’s why I was drawn to Alexandra Robbins’ The Overachievers: The Secret Lives of Driven Kids. After I read an article about it last year, I immediately placed myself on the library’s waiting list for weeks to read it. I knew I’d be able to relate to the story.
Popular Girls and Workhorses
In The Overachievers, Robbins spends a year shadowing nine current students and one former student from Walt Whitman HS, a competitive public high school in Bethesda, Maryland that the author attended a decade earlier. She lets us in on their struggles with college admissions, test anxiety and everyday school life. She also explores their relationships with their family and friends. All this is told in chapters about each student that read almost like third-person diary entries.
As I read the book, I felt as if I were right there with Taylor, “the Popular Girl,” as she struggled to write her college essays. I celebrated along with A.P. Frank, “the Workhorse” when he finally broke the chains of his controlling mother, who forced him to take 17 A.P. classes in high school.
I pondered with Pete, “the Meathead,” about whether learning should be considered only a means to get to college, and I envied him when he got more than my usual five hours of sleep. In short, I cared what happened to the characters and their families.
The Push to Overachieve
Robbins did her research extremely well and the book is engaging. Its main flaw is that the reader isn’t able to connect to the students for more than a couple of pages at a time. In between the chapters about the nine students, Robbins inserts chapters of social commentary. It made me feel like I was constantly being plucked from a good story.
I would have been less frustrated if the opinion sections had been clearly sectioned off. It’s almost as if Robbins is trying to trick readers into reading them by slipping them in after a chapter about Julie, “the Superstar” or Audrey, “the Perfectionist.”
I didn’t need to be tricked into reading them. The opinion sections are interesting enough on their own. Robbins argues that the push to overachieve has led to a culture that favors test scores over teaching, inflates grades and even fills kids’ sports with the pressure to be the best. She writes about the intense application process for toddlers at Manhattan’s most prestigious pre-schools. She reports statistics showing that many high school and college students don’t think most of the cheating they do is actually dishonest.
No Right Answers
More than anything else, the book shows that overachieving is a real phenomenon, and that it can have real negative effects. The students themselves are proof of this.
In one chapter, Taylor stands in the post office with envelopes in hand, ready to say “yes” to one of two universities that have accepted her. But she can’t seem to make a decision. She finally chooses one school and mails the letter. Then she panics and decides it’s not what she wants. In tears, she frantically begs one of the mail clerks to get it back for her. Twice.
Julie gets accepted into Dartmouth College, after working hard to get her track time down so she’ll be recruited by Dartmouth’s track coach. But when she starts her freshman year, she finds out that she isn’t the best runner on the team. She almost quits track and Dartmouth altogether, deciding that a community college might be a better choice. Like many overachievers, she doesn’t know how to live in a world where she can’t be the best at everything.
And when A.P. Frank discovers that he has feelings for a female friend in college, he can’t seem to do anything about it for almost an entire school year. He’s paralyzed by romance and dating, where he has no experience and there are no right answers.
A School-Sized Mirror
Reading about the students in this book was like looking into a school-sized mirror. I’d like to think that I’m more of a healthy overachiever than the Whitman students, since I at least try to schedule some “me” time into my week.
But my friends and I deal with some of the same problems as the students in The Overachievers, like SAT anxiety and lack of sleep. Robbins helped me realize that being stressed about the balance of sleep, school, extracurriculars and outside life isn’t a Stuyvesant thing or even a high school thing. It’s a problem that follows students beyond high school. It was validating to learn that my friends and I aren’t just being whiny, self-absorbed teens when we complain about the pressure we feel at school.
I’ll be graduating in June myself, but I don’t plan on letting “overachiever culture” take its toll on me. Hopefully, my efforts to have a life outside of grades and academic pressure throughout high school will ensure that I won’t get overwhelmed when I’m thrown into the real world.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.