The Overachievers: The Secret Lives of Driven Kids, takes on different issues from the normal “teen stuff,” so I was curious to know what it was like to write it and why it was written. I decided to ask the author, Alexandra Robbins.
NYC: Adults are always discussing how students are pressured into things like sex or drugs. Why did you decide to write about this other kind of pressure?
Alexandra Robbins: In my work, I like to give a voice to groups who usually aren’t heard. People generally assume that if you’re a smart, talented or ambitious student on the outside, then you must be feeling fine on the inside. I knew that wasn’t the case.
NYC: How is your book relevant to teens who don’t go to an overachiever high school like Whitman?
Robbins: What I call “overachiever culture” affects all levels of students, from the standardized tests that public schools require, to the way that school has become a two-tiered system. Many students feel like their school has split into two: there are the “A.P. kids” and everyone else. It’s as if “average” students are seen as failures. This is ridiculous and wrong.
NYC: How has high school changed since you graduated?
Robbins: It has become a lot more intense, much more competitive and more focused on high-stakes testing.
NYC: Did you have any dej vu moments while you were researching your old high school for the book?
Robbins: Oh sure-I saw some of my old teachers in the hallways and I hung out in some of the same places. It was pretty weird to be back at my old high school. Actually, I got in trouble more this time than when I was a student. Apparently you can’t take your cell phone out in the hallway! And you need a lunch pass to go to your car.
NYC: How did you choose the students that you wanted to shadow and how did they respond to you?
Robbins: I chose students who represented different roles in their school: there are students viewed as “the Meathead,” “the Popular Girl,” “the Flirt,” “the Teacher’s Pet,” “the Perfectionist,” “the Slacker,” “the Superstar,” “the Workhorse” and “the Stealth Overachiever.” I wanted to tell the stories of a variety of different people. The students were great. I’m so proud of them. They were open and honest, even when their stories were potentially embarrassing, because they knew that a lot of other students would relate to them.
Questions for the Author
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.