To get a better understanding of twin relationships, I read Entwined Lives: Twins and What They Tell Us About Human Behavior, by Dr. Nancy L. Segal, professor of developmental psychology and director of the Twin Studies Center at California State University, Fullerton. Dr. Segal is an expert on twins and is a twin herself. Hoping to shed some light on my own twin relationship, I interviewed her recently by phone.
-Anonymous
NYC: My twin and I were very close when we were younger, but we’re not anymore. What effect do you think our different personalities might have had on our relationship?
Dr. Nancy Segal: First of all, when you say different personalities, I’m willing to bet that you’re not so different after all. Many identical twins focus on small differences and blow them up so they can differentiate from each other.
You’re 17. Adolescence is a time when all teens, twins or not, ask questions about who they are, what are their relationships to their family, to their friends. It’s a time when people, including twins, tend to differentiate a bit. You may find that as you get a little older, you and your twin will come back together again.
NYC: What’s your relationship with your twin like?
Segal: I’m a fraternal twin and we look and act very differently. we’re no more alike genetically than ordinary siblings. We were never really close as children-we just got close in adulthood. A lot of full siblings tend to get closer as they become adults.
The difference with you and your identical twin is that you were close as children, and now as adolescents you’re moving away a little bit. You’ll probably come together again in a few years.
NYC: Why do identical twins tend to have such a close bond?
Segal: Because they have a lot of similar traits, abilities, interests and personalities. People tend to be attracted toward individuals who have things in common with them. Identical twins have virtually everything in common, so that really helps to cement their bond.
NYC: What are the common myths about twins and which ones are false?
Segal: One myth is that there’s always a good twin and an evil twin. That’s not true. I think people need to differentiate between twins, so they look very carefully for small differences. So if one twin is perceived to be a little nicer than the other, they may call that twin the good twin and the other one the evil twin.
NYC: Why are scientists studying identical and fraternal twins to figure out behavior patterns in humans?
Segal: Twins are a very natural and elegant way of studying human behavior. The studies tell us which traits are most genetically influenced and which traits are less genetically influenced. It will help us all understand who we are and how we got that way.
NYC: How do these studies work?
Segal: Identical twins share all of their genes. Fraternal twins share half on average-just like ordinary siblings. Let’s suppose we’re looking at the trait of introversion-somebody who’s reserved and very shy. You might give a personality test to a group of identical twins and to a group of fraternal twins. If the identical twins’ scores are more matched than the fraternal twins’ scores, this would suggest that there’s a genetic influence on introversion.
Another way of using twins is to study identical twins who were separated at birth and never met until adulthood, and compare them to identical twins raised together. Most people would figure if you’re living together, you should be more alike than if you’re not. But what we’re finding is that the identical twins living apart are as similar as the twins living together. This tells us that the factors responsible for the similarities must be in the genes, not in the environment.
What Twins Tell Us
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.