Being in care with siblings is hard, but keeping them together is harder. My brother and I came into care in June of ’97, when he was 6 and I was 13. We moved from place to place.
Our stays were short lived because of my behavior: I was stealing, breaking things, cutting school and staying out late. I didn’t know that would lead to us being separated.
One day when I cut school my foster mom came home early and caught me. We got into an argument and she called my social worker and said she wanted me out.
I asked the social worker to send my brother with me, but they told me the foster mom was keeping my brother because he didn’t cause problems for her like I did. I was furious.
Living apart from my brother was difficult to handle. I worried about whether he would be OK without me. Fortunately, we had sibling visits every other Tuesday at our agency. I saw that my brother was adjusting well to the foster home, and it made me feel better to know that he was doing fine.
In the end, things worked out all right for my brother and me. He lives with our dad now, and since I’ve aged out of care I go up to see him once or twice a week. But other kids in care don’t get to visit too much.
I decided to talk to Cyllvia Springer, who works on sibling issues at New York’s child welfare agency, the Administration for Children’s Services, about what ACS is doing to keep siblings together.
Q: Why is it hard to keep siblings together at a placement?
A: That’s complicated. It’s rough for all kids whenever they’re separated from their parents, no matter how the parents treated them. Sometimes youth respond to the separation with behavior problems, like staying out late or running with the wrong people. Not all foster parents are able to manage those behaviors. If they can’t manage, one of the kids might have to be removed.
It’s unfortunate. What you need to know is that ACS is really striving to keep siblings in foster care as close as possible. we’re aware that we don’t always have enough foster parents who can handle sibling groups.
Q: Are you doing anything to improve training for foster parents, so they can better handle sibling groups?
A: we’re trying. In March, ACS completed a program teaching foster parent trainers a special set of parenting techniques designed to help foster parents understand and better respond to challenging behaviors.
This training is part of a larger effort to try to give foster parents the tools they need to be able to “hang in there” with their kids.
We will soon be providing additional funding to agencies that will allow them to bring on board foster parent advocates, mental health specialists, and other resources that can help a foster parent deal with a crisis in the home.
Q: Why do siblings sometimes get separated when they’re put in care?
A: Sometimes when you get a sibling group, they have different needs, like behavior or health issues. When we get kids in the same family that need extra attention, the struggle (and it’s always a struggle) is to decide whether to keep the siblings together or help each kid do the best they can apart. Usually when they’re separated its because there are special needs.
Kids also get separated because of kinship foster parents. Let’s say an aunt says, “I can take one child” and an uncle takes two and grandma takes the rest. They may not be living in the same area. But because it’s family we say, “All right, we’ll do the split,” because we know family at least will keep those kids connected.
Q: If siblings are separated, do you keep them in the same areas to make it easier for them to keep in contact?
A: We always try to do that-we try to keep them as close as possible. If we can place siblings no more than a few blocks apart, that’s ideal.
If they have to be placed in different neighborhoods, we schedule visits a minimum of twice a month. We’d like it to be much more often, like twice a week, and not just in visiting rooms but meeting up after school to do homework together, going to the mall together, growing up like normal siblings would grow up.
Right now we’re working on a visiting center in that should open in June. It’s going to be a place where a family can come together. They can celebrate birthdays, watch TV together, play games. We’ll have a dining room, living room and smaller visiting rooms. It’s for family or sibling groups that don’t have a place to meet where they can feel comfortable.
Q: Can foster parents allow their foster child’s siblings to spend the weekend over at their place?
A: Yes, as long as there is adequate space and the agency is notified. In fact, we encourage foster parents to plan weekend activities with siblings because they give kids in care an opportunity to relate in a more typical environment.
Q: If a child comes up with lots of excuses for not going on their sibling visit, what do you say to them?
A: When a sibling doesn’t show up for a visit it can be for a number of reasons. For older siblings, sometimes there is a conflict with school, work or parenting responsibilities. Sometimes a sibling may go through a stage where he or she may feel closer to friends and prefers to spend more time with them.
In any event, the caseworker and foster parent should help this sibling understand the impact of his or her decisions and actions on other siblings. The caseworker might also work with the other siblings to help them reach out more to the missing one, when that’s appropriate.
Q: How come when one sibling gets adopted, the other siblings are not allowed to visit them?
A: That’s rough. Technically, once a child is adopted the foster parents become their parents and then they can dictate what goes on in life of the child, because it’s now their child.
We at ACS talk to pre-adoptive parents to make sure they understand the importance of keeping the sibling relationship. In some cases we even get them to agree to that beforehand, because we understand the importance of maintaining a connection.
Sometimes foster parents feel once it’s their child it’s almost like the previous history no longer exists. But you have to accept the whole package and work with it. For some parents that’s difficult, but we are aware of it.
Even after an adoption occurs, kids can contact ACS and say, “My sibling just got adopted. Is there a way I can reach them?” ACS will contact that adoptive parent if we have a number for them, and try to get them to at least understand the importance of maintaining this relationship. we’re not always successful, but we try.
Visiting Hours
What's the system doing to give us more time with our siblings?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.