Ever since “Bodies…The Exhibition” opened at the Museum of Science and Industry in Tampa, Florida in August, and most recently in New York City in November, it has sparked a lot of controversy.
Ethical arguments range from the educational value of the exhibit to how Premier Exhibitions, the private company that runs the exhibit, obtained the bodies. China’s human rights history is tainted and some people fear the exhibit might be using the remains of people who’ve been tortured.
The bodies were obtained through the Dalian Medical University of Plastination Laboratories in China, according to Arnie Geller, president and CEO of Premier Exhibitions. He emailed me that the university legally obtained the bodies from authorized Chinese government agencies.
But a recent New York Times article noted that some human rights activists have condemned the exhibit. China executes thousands of prisoners a year and has a long history of using death row prisoners for medical purposes, they say.
Executed Prisoners?
Officials from Dalian University have been implicated in the past in the use of executed prisoners for commercial purposes, according to Harry Wu, executive director of the LaoGai Research Foundation, an organization that documents abuses in China’s prison system, who was quoted in the New York Times article. He says there’s reason to be concerned about this exhibit.
When I asked Geller about these concerns, he wrote, “While we are aware of these reports, they absolutely do not apply to our exhibition. We have diligently abided by all relevant international and domestic laws.”
Geller explained that in China, the U.S. and many other countries, unidentified and unclaimed bodies are made available to medical schools and other agencies. That’s after an attempt has been made to identify them by publishing notices in newspapers that invite relatives to come forward to claim them.
I wondered why this information wasn’t displayed at the exhibit, since there’s so much controversy about it. Geller said, “We chose to focus on providing educational materials.” But doesn’t ignoring the controversy just call more attention to it?
Turning Our Backs
Ultimately, I believe that if the bodies were actually obtained under shady circumstances, then people shouldn’t pay to see the exhibit because it implies support of how the bodies were collected. People might even be paying for the death of another person for a future exhibit.
But even if the bodies were human rights victims, I think we’re missing the point in blaming the exhibit. Human rights shouldn’t be an issue only when its victims are hanging on display in our museums. It should be an issue when these people are still alive. We can’t ethically turn our backs on a dying man and then flip out when that dead man lands on our doorstep.
I believe that people who go to the exhibit are making the cadavers as useful a teaching tool as people can be. Even if they died at the hands of a government that should protect them, I think we should let them serve an educational purpose.
Is It Wrong?
But another question I asked myself was: Should human bodies be put on display under any circumstances? Some people argue that even if the bodies were obtained legally and had no next of kin to claim them, they still deserve proper burial rights.
Dr. Vivienne Nathanson, Head of Ethics at the British Medical Association, wrote an opinion piece for the British Channel 4 news website in response to a similar exhibit shown in England in 2002. She said, “The question is whether we believe that people have the right to expect that their bodies will be treated with respect after they die.”
In England, she said, “If you’re found dead in suspicious circumstances there will be a post-mortem, but you don’t expect that your body will then go on public display.” She seemed to think wrong to use bodies this way, regardless of the legal issues.
I disagree. I think the family of the deceased must be the ultimate decision makers when it comes to the remains. And I accept Geller’s idea that if there’s no next of kin, then there’s no problem with using a body for educational purposes, even if they never gave their consent while they were alive.
That is, if the exhibit really was educational. The company claimed it was, but before I went to it, I suspected it might just be a freak show. I also worried whether or not it was suitable for young children, since children can be more sensitive than adults.
While the exhibit doesn’t allow people under the age of 13 unless accompanied by an adult guardian, it does seem to encourage visits by young children-they even offer elementary school group tours. I wanted to see for myself what the kids were being shown.
Upon arriving, I was given what looked like a cordless phone that I could carry around to listen to an audio tour. There was one tour for adults and one for kids, and I listened to them both to hear the difference.
Sugar Coating the Images
While the adults’ version had a monotonous male voice, the kids’ version had a bubbly, high-pitched voice that seemed to sugarcoat the images. But the images the kids saw were the same ones the adults saw, only with watered down, more upbeat explanations. It shocked me to learn that kids and adults could view the same dead bodies, since some of the displays were very graphic.
Some displays were more kid-oriented than others. For instance, one cadaver was smiling and giving a thumbs-up, another had a football grasped in his arm. Those connections to real life seemed like a good tool to get kids’ interest without creeping them out.
Freak Show or Factual?
And the bodies and organs weren’t as gruesome as I’d imagined they might be. For the most part, they looked less real than some models of organs I’ve seen. The process used to preserve the bodies did more than just conceal the stench of death, it also gave the specimens a glossy look.
The exhibit was less circus-like and more factual than I’d expected. In the end, I thought it was educational and appropriate for kids, though I would’ve designed it so they didn’t see displays of fetuses.
While I’m still concerned about how the bodies might have ended up at the exhibit, my other concerns about the exhibit have been put to rest. Speaking as a Health Channel fan, I found the displays to be less boardwalk freak show and more National Geographic Channel. I thought the exhibit provided a legitimate educational experience.
Bodies on Display
Educational Exhibit or Human Rights Abuse?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.