I remember Thanksgiving 2002. That was the last Thanksgiving I ever spent with my older brother David. At the time I didn’t know it was going to be his last Thanksgiving, since he was only 33 years old. I treated it like any other holiday with my family, eating and spending time together.
Then Christmas Eve came. My mother walked into my bedroom and told me that we had to go to the hospital because David was sick. She looked really worried but she didn’t say why. I expected to hear that whatever he had wasn’t too serious.
My mother and I went to see him that night. I thought that he just had a bad cold, but he looked really thin. It wasn’t until later that night, when my mother and I came home, that she told me what she’d learned that day-that my brother had AIDS.
A Deadly Disease
I didn’t know how I felt. I think I was in shock. I was 12 years old and I didn’t know as many things about AIDS as I know now. But I knew that it can be transmitted through sex and that people can die from it (I learned later that AIDS can also be transmitted when people using drugs share needles).
I asked my mother what was going to happen to my brother. I wanted to know how he’d gotten AIDS, how long he’d had it and was he going to die? I wanted to know if the hospital could do anything to stop him from dying. I kept hoping that the doctors had made a mistake or maybe they got his forms mixed up with another person.
But my mother couldn’t answer most of my questions because they were her questions too. So I stopped asking and stayed quiet.
That Christmas felt really slow and unreal and I just couldn’t get the thought out of my head that my brother was about to die.
A’Normal’ Christmas
My mother tried to be cheerful, like she usually is on holidays. The living room was decorated with a Christmas tree, flashing colored lights and candy canes. It looked like Christmas but it didn’t feel like Christmas.
She tried to not break down even though she must have been taking his sickness the hardest. I didn’t know how to console her so I didn’t do anything. Most of the time I stayed in my room to avoid contact with her, but when I was near her I tried to act normal. I talked to my friends on the phone, played with my cat and watched TV.
My mom, one of my other brothers and I took a cab to the hospital on Christmas Day, which didn’t make us feel any better. The whole hospital vibe felt bad. It made me think of death, despite the Christmas decorations everywhere. The hospital was painted an odd mint green, and it smelled like sick people. The place gave me the chills.
My Brother Was Suffering
I wanted to be at home at our apartment in Manhattan, watching Christmas shows, with the Christmas lights reflecting off the wall. Being in a hospital was not my idea of Christmas.
I did want to see David but I didn’t want him to be in the hospital. He was too skinny and he looked like he was in pain even though he was asleep most of the time. None of us talked. We just sat in his room and looked at him sleeping.
I never bothered to talk to my friends, my mother or my other two brothers about David. I thought that if I didn’t talk about it, then it wouldn’t be true. I still saw my friends at school and talked with them on the phone about school or boys.
I felt like I needed to act normal. It was my attempt to fool myself into thinking everything was OK. Other than going to school, I mostly stayed in my room-but that was normal for me too. I tried my hardest not to do anything differently.
But I did write about my feelings in my journal. I’d started a journal a little bit before I found out about my brother’s disease. It was a black book that I wrote in whenever I was mad or angry or disappointed, a book for all my anger and sadness.
I separated my good and happy entries and my gloomy and disappointed entries. I wrote almost every day for more than a month. Although I probably needed someone to talk to, I felt like paper was the only thing that understood me at that time.
Writing About My Brother
I wrote all about David, about how I didn’t understand why he didn’t protect himself, about whether he’d still be able to protect me without actually being here and whether he was still happy.
I never did fully realize that my brother wasn’t going to make it, and I’m not sure my mother did either. When a character in a movie is supposed to die, he or she always seems to get better. Part of me was expecting David to pull through, just like in the movies.
Of my three brothers (all older than me), he was the one I saw the most. Because he only lived a block away he was always at my house. he’d eat with us or have a snack and watch TV. I’d gotten so used to seeing him at my apartment or outside when I came home from school. When he wasn’t around anymore, I couldn’t believe it.
The Worst Day
The day he died, January 5th, 2003, was hard, really hard. My mother and I were home when someone from the hospital called and told her that her son hadn’t made it.
I was sitting in my room when I heard my mother’s loud cries. I walked into her room to see what had happened and she told me. I just stood there and stared at her. None of that night or the next day felt real. I kept hoping I’d wake up from this nightmare.
The wake and the funeral were very classy but that didn’t matter. My brother was still in a casket and that was when the reality hit me hard. Everything my mother had told me was true. My brother really did have AIDS and he really had died from it.
When I saw everyone crying, I just froze. I thought I had no more emotion left to feel. During the few weeks that I’d known about his disease, I’d tried to block all my emotions and that took a lot out of me. When I wanted to let it all go and cry at his funeral, the feelings wouldn’t come out.
But when I was walking up the aisle to the exit at the funeral, I felt everyone looking at me with those sad “I’m sorry” eyes. That’s when I broke down in front of everyone. My emotions took over and I started to cry. Then I got mad because people were looking at me and trying to console me. I didn’t want to be consoled. I wanted to just cry.
I Miss Him
When we went to the gravesite, it was so hard to see my brother being lowered into the ground. That was going to be the last time I ever saw his body. I felt numb, just standing there and watching.
Three years after his death, I still don’t know or understand all the choices he made. Maybe he chose to have unprotected sex, but I’ll probably never find out. He might not even have known how he got AIDS. I wish that I knew more.
My mother told me he eventually refused to take his medication after he found out he was sick. I wish he had taken the medication so maybe he could still be here.
I miss my brother always hanging out at the house and being protective of me. I always felt safe when I was with him. I know that wishing won’t make him come back, but I still do it. I still hope that in some impossible way, he’ll come back.
For more information on AIDS, call Planned Parenthood at (800) 230-7526 or go online to www.plannedparenthood.org/pp2/portal/medicalinfo/sti/.
Suffering in Silence
When My Brother Died of AIDS, I Couldn't Share My Pain
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.