Just Visiting

I Love My Grandma, But I Can't Live With Her

When I was 6 years old, I was placed in kinship care with my grandmother. Since the age of one I had bounced from one horrible home to another-21 in all. But at my grandma’s, I felt I was finally with someone who loved me.
Happy Memories
My grandmother bought me anything I wanted, no matter how bad I was and even if I didn’t need, use or deserve it. (Yes, I was spoiled). She put me in dance school, private piano lessons and summer programs. When she received money for me she put it in my own personal bank account so I could have a little something when I got older. I still have this account.
It wasn’t just my grandmother’s generosity that made me love her. When we cooked and cleaned together, she’d joke and laugh, and tell me stories about myself when I was little. She said that even when I was a baby I had a fresh mouth.
We’d go to the movies-just the two of us-and have long talks. She’d tell me stories about her life, like how her mother made her choose a switch off a tree to be beaten with when she got a bad report card. She asked me questions about school and treated me as if I was her own child. Most of all, she gave me a sense of belonging.
A Heavy Burden
Although my grandmother gave me the only real love I ever had, things were far from perfect. She used to get really mad sometimes and beat me with belts. I was often scared of her. Things got worse when I was around 14 and my grandmother had to keep running back and forth to the hospital taking care of my grandfather, who had Alzheimer’s.
My grandfather couldn’t be left alone for a moment. One night he even peed in my closet! My grandma was dealing with a heavy burden of stress. One day she said the most dreadful words that devastated me completely: “I hate you!” I told her I hated her, too. Then I broke down in tears.
A week later I was moved to another home. I felt OK about moving because I understood what my grandmother was going through. Part of me also felt glad to be getting away from her and her anger.
But in my new home, things were awful. My foster mother never got me anything I needed and wouldn’t let me go outside. She was always broke. Whenever she got money from the agency for me, she splurged on herself. And I could have died of starvation on the little she fed me.
I started comforting myself with good memories of my grandmother and dreamed of going back to live with her. I longed to be in a place where somebody cared about me.
I Felt Like a Lab Mouse
Then one day my foster mother told me I had to go to court. She wouldn’t tell me why.
As I entered the huge, air-conditioned courtroom, I was nervous. The judge, an elderly woman in a black robe, was seated in the middle of a big table. It seemed like the beginning of a horror movie.
“How would you feel if your foster mother were to adopt you?” she asked.
“I wouldn’t want her to!” I gasped. I couldn’t believe this was an adoption hearing. How could I be up for adoption without even being told? There was no way I would let my foster mother adopt me. She was careless and immature, and I couldn’t trust her. I told the judge I would like to be able to be adopted by a family member or friend.
The judge told me I could leave, but I didn’t. A thought had popped into my head.
“Oh, um, is there any chance I could move back into my grandmothers house?” I said nervously. It took a lot of courage to say that!
“I’m afraid that is not possible,” the judge said, “but I’ll see what I can do for you.”
A month later, my caseworker told me the judge had set up weekend visits for me at my grandmother’s house.
‘Get Out!’
I started visiting my grandmother. But she wasn’t the loving, generous woman I’d been dreaming about. My grandfather had gotten sicker, and my grandmother seemed really stressed out and tired. When I asked for new clothes, she told me that my foster mother should buy me the things I needed. Three visits out of four, we got into arguments. She got angry about the tiniest things, like me not putting cups back exactly where I found them.
Then my foster mother went on vacation and left me with my grandmother. I went to bed late on Friday night and woke up Saturday with a terrible migraine, so I stayed in bed. Around noon, my grandmother came pounding in the room like a Big Foot cartoon, yelling, “Why are you still in the bed? Does your foster mother let you stay in the bed all day?”
“Yes!” I said.
“don’t do it here! I’m not your foster mother.”
I tried to explain that I didn’t feel well and had a very bad headache.
“If you’re so sick, then get out of my house!” she screamed.
A Reality Check
I couldn’t believe she was kicking me out. What happened to the loving grandma I remembered? I knew that we’d had problems before, but we always solved them. Now she was acting like a totally different person.
I put on my clothes and packed my bags, feeling like I wanted to cry. In the train on my way home I thought, “Why did I even ask the judge to come back? If my grandma wanted me, she would be working with me and not against me.” I was crushed.
When I got home my foster mother asked why I was home so early. When I told her that my grandmother had kicked me out, she accused me of lying. I was mad and left to walk around my neighborhood. I felt I had no one reliable to love and understand me.
I refused to see my grandmother for two weeks. When I finally got in touch with her she said she was very worried and asked where I’d been. I just told her I’d been sick. I felt uncomfortable mentioning that she had kicked me out and worried that we’d start arguing all over again.
We Argue Too Much
In September I decided to give my grandmother another chance, and I moved back in with her. She’s still taking care of my grandfather but she told me she would try her best not to get tense. I believed that she would stick to her word. I was really hoping for a better bond and relationship between us. But the arguments we’ve been getting into have been more complicated, even though they’re about nothing.
I don’t get scared anymore when she gets mad, like I did when I was little. Now I yell back. But that means small things-like me leaving a door open-can turn into shouting matches. When I see her with steam blowing out of her nose and ears, I feel like I don’t even know her.
Around Thanksgiving I finally got tired of it and contacted my caseworker and her supervisor. They are working on putting me into another home. When my grandmother asks me why I want to move I look at her like she’s stupid because she even said herself that we argue too much.
Loving but Leaving
She’s not angry that I’m leaving. She doesn’t want to see me somewhere where I’m not happy, especially while I’m living with her. She says I am always welcome and can come visit. But I think I’ll mostly keep in touch with her over the phone, to keep the arguments from coming back.
I wish ACS had tried to help us get along before they removed me from my grandmother’s house. Maybe if my grandmother and I had gone to counseling together, we would have learned about each other’s feelings and tried not to do things to get on each other’s nerves.
I feel a little guilty. People who know my situation say that I should stay because she’s family, and that I could help take care of my grandfather. But if I stayed, I fear I’d just give her more stress and she has enough to worry about already.
I think things will be better between us once I’m living in my new foster home. I still love my grandmother unconditionally, and I know she must love me the same way to let me leave like that. I’ll miss her. But I’ve realized I just can’t live with her.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.