My Father’s Dream or Mine?

I Don't Want to Choose Between Money and Happiness

“You want to be a what?”
My dad looked at me like I had four eyes.
“An anthropologist,” I said. “It’s perfect for me. Cultures, languages, traveling andâ”
“Wait, wait, wait. What about a doctor? A lawyer? You want to dig around in the dirt and look for bones?”
His face was a picture of pure perplexity.
“Actually, that’s an archaeologist,” I said. “Anthropologists study humans. They study different societies and what divides and binds us.”
“Listen, I don’t want to tell you what to do but these types of professions don’t make money. Fields like medicine and law will always make money because they will always be needed. You have to be where the money is.”
What was my dad saying? This was the first time he’d ever really disagreed with my choices, and it was confusing me. What was wrong with being an anthropologist?
It’s not like I wanted to run away to join the circus. Being an anthropologist seemed perfect for me. It took all of the things that I loved about life and people and rolled them into one interesting career.
Questioning My Choices
I’d always thought my dad understood me. Our similarities-like our shared love for music and art-had led me to believe that we were almost the same person. Now he was telling me that my goals for the future weren’t good enough and that all I should be concerned about was making money. For reasons that I couldn’t quite grasp, I felt betrayed.
Our conversation also stirred feelings of doubt within me. Before talking with my dad, I’d been so sure of what I wanted to do and who I wanted to be. I’d travel the world, sampling cultures, and then settle down to teach at a university when I wanted to start a family. I’d had it all planned out until that moment.
Now I felt like scratching these ideas out of my mind. Was my dad right? Come to think of it, I’d never heard anyone say, “Ooh, I really want to be an anthropologist.” Many of my friends want to be something prestigious, like a doctor or a lawyer. Besides, if I worked so hard in high school and college, would I be throwing it away by pursuing a career that didn’t pay much?
Desperately, I began to think of what else I could be. When I considered being a psychologist, my dad shot that idea down too.
“It’s very competitive and very few psychologists get paid a lot,” he said.
Ugh. What was his obsession with money? It was driving me insane. I continued my hunt for a new career, but nothing struck me like being an anthropologist. What was I going to do?
Pressure to Decide My Future
I pictured myself being a penniless writer trying to hustle handwritten pieces of my work on a train. OK, maybe that was a little dramatic but I couldn’t help being concerned. As a junior at Cardozo HS in Queens, with college just around the corner, I felt like I needed to think of something. Quick.
I didn’t always want to be an anthropologist. Most 4-year-olds don’t aspire to be things that they can’t spell. Naturally, having both parents as nurses, I wanted to become a nurse. But after discovering at age 6 that I loved to put words together, I wanted to become a writer. I remember writing and illustrating tiny loose-leaf books with my cousin in the first grade and selling them to our friends for a quarter.
While I never quite gave up my bohemian writing dreams, my career goals started to shift to law when I was 10. The lawyers on TV shows like The Practice seemed to be having a great time calling, “Objection!” and besides, everyone “oohed and ahhed” when I said that’s what I wanted to be.
Soon enough, however, I realized law was not for me. Lawyers have the power to directly influence the fate of another person and I didn’t like that idea. If anything happened to my clients, I thought it would be my fault. After toying with the idea of psychology and writing, I declared myself utterly confused.
The Thrill of Exploration
Around the 7th grade, all that changed. I began watching documentaries by anthropologists about people in distant places. I was fascinated by the cultures untainted by Western civilization, hidden in the mountains of Nepal or the grasslands of Africa. I was awe-struck by languages rolling off foreign tongues, forming words unfamiliar to me but telling stories that I already knew.
I needed to be there. I needed to be surrounded by ancient chanting lit by moonlight. I needed to taste foods that had fed entire tribes for thousands of years. I yearned for the authenticity and truth of these peoples that I didn’t know. I had finally figured it out. I was going to become an anthropologist.
I thought I had my future mapped out. Living in a household with two parents and a steady income, money had never been my concern. I wanted to make enough to be comfortable, but I never aspired to be rolling in money. My family didn’t seem to worry about money either. That’s why it was such a surprise when my dad told me to choose a career with a high salary.
My Parents’ Dream
Maybe I shouldn’t have been surprised by his reaction. About nine years ago my family emigrated from Trinidad, an island in the West Indies, to the United States. When we lived in Trinidad, we were not struggling or in the midst of political uprisings, unlike many immigrants from other countries. I had a peaceful, normal childhood until we left when I was 7. The sole reason my family moved to the United States was that golden word: opportunity.
My parents saw that my brother and I had the potential and the drive to rise much higher than they had. It was almost like a silent compromise. We were leaving our comfortable island on a single hope-that my brother and I would make it.
Knowing that my parents had brought me to America for success and later hearing my dad’s words about money and career choices, I began to feel as if choosing a profession simply because I liked it was selfish.
“What about the dreams and sacrifices of my parents?” I thought. “Maybe I should forget my aspirations and do something that makes them happy. I should have a career that makes a lot of money. This way, I will be successful and make them proud. All their struggles to rewrite their lives in this strange new country will not be in vain.”
Money vs. Happiness
My mind was twisting and turning among the possible paths to take and their probable outcomes.
“Should I choose a decent career that I love and have an average salary?” I wondered. “Or should I strip myself of love and passion and have the six-figure salary? Could I have a career that I love that also pays a lot? And even if I did, would I have enough time to raise and nurture a family?”
All these questions kept swirling and colliding in my mind. Not one of them produced an answer.
Two summers ago, to my dismay, my brother’s departure for the University of Chicago drew the issue of money into our home. My parents were constantly having financial discussions about what they would contribute and how much my brother would take out in loans. I felt that I needed to make a decision about my future soon.
My brother, who is now 19, became a biology major and pre-med student, just what my parents wanted. I was surprised when he told me he was doing this, because he’d told me many times that he wanted to have a career in foreign diplomacy. Had my dad gotten to him too? Though it’s possible that he had convinced my brother to study medicine, I decided that my brother simply had a change of heart. I have never known him to do anything that he wasn’t passionate about.
Looking for Answers
With all the chaos bubbling over in my mind, I decided to pay a visit to my school’s guidance counselor, Adriana Vega-Saponara. She is a light-hearted and spirited woman who all the students love to talk to. She welcomed me and asked me what was on my mind.
“I want to become an anthropologist but my dad wants me to choose a career that would make more money,” I said.
“My dad told me not to be a teacher because it would not pay much money, but becoming a teacher was the best thing I ever did,” she said. “If you choose a job just for money, you may not be happy.”
Ms. Vega-Saponara suggested that I volunteer and get internships to obtain a clearer picture about my future. She gave me useful advice about following my heart but still having an education to fall back on. She also told me that in order to choose the right career, I would have to know what I want in life.
Easier Said Than Done
Even though her advice was reasonable, I had a feeling that it was easier said than done. But our meeting did make me realize that I had endless possibilities and that almost everyone went through this process at this time in their life.
I also knew that I couldn’t run around trying to please everyone forever. No matter how much advice I received, my confusion would remain until I was ready to clarify it myself. Something simply had to make sense within me.
I finally decided to talk to my parents about my feelings. My father’s responses didn’t surprise me. He said he prefers that his children have careers in the medical profession or legal profession. It seemed like his definition of success was earning lots of money.
But my mother’s responses caught me off guard.
“I just want you to go to college, gain higher education and choose a job that you feel comfortable with,” she said.
When I asked her what she would prefer me to do, she said, “I wouldn’t make that decision. Never. That’s your individual choice. That’s a calling you have to make.”
Talking to my mom gave me the support I was looking for. I felt relieved that she didn’t have the same ideas as my father. She viewed success as having a healthy physical, social, mental and spiritual well-being.
A Sense of Clarity
Although my dad’s responses were expected, my conversation with him also gave me a sense of clarity. I understood why he thought the way he did. His family didn’t have much money when he was a child. So he focused on making enough so his family could live comfortably.
During our conversation, he admitted that he became a nurse for the sole purpose of making money. The reasons behind my parents’ goals for me became clearer. I began to understand both my mother and my father, and in understanding them, I began to understand me.
I still feel obligated to have a decent-paying job, but now I also feel like my mother’s support gives me the freedom to do what will make me happy.
A Happy Balance
I still want to be an anthropolist but now I know that decision is far from final. I’m young and I have my whole future ahead of me. Even within anthropology, there are so many roads I can take. I’m no longer concerned with making a fortune off of my career but I also don’t disregard money completely. I’ve found a happy medium between the two extremes.
For me to enjoy my life, I have to do what I want to do. And despite my dad’s preferences, I know that he’ll be proud of me even if I don’t do exactly what he wants.
So even though I don’t have my future mapped out to the minute, I no longer feel plagued by feelings of confusion. I’m secure enough in myself to not have all the answers yet. Wherever life takes me, I will strive to be a success in my own eyes.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.