What’s Up With Dating Older Guys?

After reading “Not Too Young” (see page 16), I wanted to learn more about the issues involved with people under 18 (minors) dating adults. I interviewed Dr. Richard Gallagher, a psychologist and director of the Parenting Institute at New York University Child Study Center.
-Aracelis Diaz
NYC: In her story, the 14-year-old author felt her relationship with a 22-year-old man was a positive thing in her life. Why might it be a problem for minors to date adults?
Dr. Richard Gallagher: It’s usually men dating younger women. The minor may be looking up to the adult and trying to act mature. They don’t have a chance to interact with someone their age who’s just as goofy and immature as they are. It can stunt their social skills. And I’d be concerned about how much control the adult man has over the young woman’s life.
For a 21 year old, it’s very easy to impress someone who is 16, but he’s not developing in a way that is appropriate and isn’t learning how to deal with people his own age and maturity level.
Some teens are getting pregnant because of these relationships. Adult men are often the ones impregnating young women, according to some studies.
NYC: As a psychologist and a parent, what worries you about this issue?
Gallagher: I’m worried about kids’ development and what dating an adult does to them psychologically. In general, we have concerns about kids under 14 getting involved in serious dating relationships. Studies suggest that youth who date [one person exclusively] before age 14 are more prone to depression than kids who are involved in group dating. It may seem pleasurable but it’s actually more stressful.
Teens get their focus taken away from schoolwork and other things. As a parent, I want my teens to have a good life and focus on age-appropriate things. When they’re young teenagers, that means getting the chance to meet different people.
NYC: In the story, the author clearly explains why she wanted to date her older boyfriend. But why might an older guy be interested in younger women? What’s in it for him?
Gallagher: Young women mature more quickly than young men, so young women often appear to be much older than they really are. Also, if a man is not so confident, dating a younger woman is sometimes easier. A man is able to have more influence on a younger woman and doesn’t feel so threatened by her.
NYC: In the story, the author tells a counselor about her relationship, thinking her secret will be kept (it isn’t). At what point during therapy do things stop being confidential?
Gallagher: In doing therapy with teens, the counselor needs to make sure it’s clear to the patient what will or won’t be kept confidential. If teens are saying they’re going to hurt themselves or someone else, or if the teens are going to get harmed or are being harmed (according to the law, that’s true for the girl in the story) the teens have to be told that, and need to be counseled to reveal the situation to parents and others.
A counselor can’t keep that confidential. I would talk to the teen and let him or her know what it is I will have to reveal to other people and why.
NYC: What if the minor lies about his or her age?
Gallagher: Older people have to be clear that if they’re going to be involved with somebody under 18, they could be brought up on rape charges, even if the sex is consensual. The adult has to be sure the teen is old enough to be involved. They should ask for ID or ask, “Where do you go to school?” or “What grade are you in?”
NYC: How would you tell a parent if their child was dating an adult?
Gallagher: It’s an important issue to discuss with the teen because if this is revealed to some parents, it could result in the parents throwing the teen out or physically punishing the teen. I would have a plan based on what I knew about the teen and their family.
NYC: Any advice for our readers?
Gallagher: I would suggest that teens think carefully about these kinds of relationships, don’t get swamped by romance, and talk things over with their parents or guardians. They should talk things over with people they trust.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.