Stomping Out Cigarettes in the Media

When you flip through a magazine, are you bombarded with pictures of cool-looking people having a good time, cigarettes in their hands? Does it seem like in every movie you see, a cigarette plays a supporting role?
“I had seen Men in Black before and never noticed the smoking,” Martibel Payano, 16, of Washington Irving HS, told me. Then, four years ago, she joined Reality Check, a youth-led organization in New York state that exposes and fights against acts of the tobacco industry. After that she would never watch smoking in movies the same way
In 2000, about 100 youth created Reality Check, with the help of the New York City Department of Health and the New York State Tobacco Control. “Our main focus is to expose the manipulative practices of the tobacco companies toward teens,” said Martibel, now the organization’s New York City area representative. “we’re not against smokers, we’re against the tobacco industry.”
Cigarette Ads for Kids?
The tobacco industry gears its advertising toward youth by doing things like placing ads in corner stores and bodegas where teens are sure to see them, at sports events with youth audiences, and in magazines read by teens.
Once she started paying attention to this kind of marketing, Martibel explained, “I realized how much smoking there really was in movies aimed at teens.” Men in Black, for example has several characters who smoke.
Though the tobacco industry signed an agreement in 1998 to stop paying movie companies to advertise tobacco products, two-thirds of movies still show tobacco use, according to the Centers for Disease Control (CDC).
And some magazines are “like a booklet of tobacco ads,” said Reality Check member Simone Davis, 15, of Washington Irving HS, who once counted 50 tobacco ads in a single magazine, including one ad that resembled a kid’s pop-up book.
Making Smoking’Normal’
Seeing images of tobacco products in all these places normalizes smoking, making it easier for kids and teens to fall victim to cigarettes, Reality Check members say.
Every day, about 3,000 kids under age 18 become daily smokers, according to the CDC. And most of them underestimate just how addictive smoking is. According to CDC statistics, out of those who don’t think they’ll be smoking in five years, 75% are still smoking five to six years later. Seventy percent of teen smokers wish they’d never started.
Ayokari Hoyes, 30, the Manhattan County Coordinator of Reality Check, says the “tobacco industry sees youth as replacement smokers”-to make up for the 440,000 people who die from smoking-related diseases in the U.S. each year, according to the CDC.
Reality Check works to prevent youth from getting interested in smoking in the first place. The teens give out information and gear at health fairs, voice their concern at health conferences and organize events that grab teens’ attention.
Teens Fight Back-and Win
In 2003, they went to a national conference on tobacco health in Boston, Massachusetts and found a unique way to get their voices heard-protesting on a skywalk connecting the hotels where the conference was. Twenty-eight of them wrapped themselves in white blankets and lay on the floor, representing the 28 people who die from tobacco-related illnesses in Massachusetts each day.
Their work to keep tobacco advertising away from the eyes of youth is starting to pay off. In June, Attorney General Eliot Spitzer and the National Association of Attorneys General worked with Reality Check to reach an agreement with Time Inc. and Newsweek Inc. to ban tobacco advertising from school library editions of their publications, including four of the most popular magazines read by teens in schools-Time, People, Sports Illustrated and Newsweek.
That’s no small victory. In a survey of 233 middle and high schools in New York state, Reality Check found that more than 70% of school libraries had copies of these magazines with tobacco advertising.
Stomping out Tobacco
In July, Reality Check held its first Movie Stomp. They invited youth to a screening of Fantastic Four at a Union Square movie theater. They told everyone to stomp their feet every time there was a scene showing tobacco products and to keep stomping until the scene was over.
Surprisingly, it ended up being a quiet evening-Fantastic Four didn’t have any scenes with tobacco use. But Reality Check members felt they’d gotten their message across. “A movie can still be good without cigarettes,” Martibel said.
For more information, go to realitycheckny.org

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.