Invasion of Privacy

When I stopped sharing, my mother started snooping

One afternoon in July I was on my family’s computer, which is inconveniently located in the living room. I was replying to a friend’s email when my mother came down the hall.
When I hear her coming I usually minimize what I’m doing on the computer (such as checking out Harry Potter sites) because I feel it’s my own business. My mom often asks to see it anyway. I reluctantly show her and she always seems satisfied.
But this time, I didn’t bother minimizing the screen. I assumed that once my mom realized I was emailing someone, she’d back off. “Hi, Mommy,” I said as she came over to me.
She said hi without looking at me, and breathed down my neck as she looked over my shoulder at the screen. I opened solitaire so she wouldn’t see the email.
Feeling Violated
“Why are you doing that? You don’t want me to see?” she asked.
“It’s not that,” I said. “It’s just that I didn’t think you’d want to see a personal email.”
“Well, I do,” she said.
That took me by surprise. She’d always respected my sister’s and my privacy, and would never have listened in on a phone conversation. I said, “But Mom, it’s a personal email.”
“So what? I’m the parent and I want to see it. Minimize solitaire.”
I was taken aback, but I did as she’d asked. She read the email and asked some questions about it, but I didn’t answer. Then she walked away with her head high like she’d just won something.
I felt so mad and violated that I wanted to cry. I took a deep breath and continued writing my email message, telling my friend how nosy my mother was. I was so angry I couldn’t even think straight. I just couldn’t believe my mother would do such a thing.
Mom Is My Friend
My mother and I have a good relationship. A lot of my friends and family members envy us because in many ways we’re more like best friends than mother and daughter. We talk a lot and we trust each other. When something’s going on with me, the first thing I do is go into my mom’s room, sit on the edge of her bed and let it all out.
But even though I tell her more than most 15-year-olds tell their mothers, there are times when I hold back.
Once one of my best friends-who happens to be a boy-bought me a bracelet. It was really nice and I wanted to wear it every day. But I knew my mom would overreact about a boy giving me a present and probably make me give it back. So I decided not to tell her about it.
Telling Her in My Own Time
When I finally wore it one day about two weeks later, my mom told me it was cute and asked me where I’d got it. I told her the truth without thinking twice. She ranted and raved about how she didn’t want me taking jewelry from boys because they might want something in return.
But despite her overreaction, I was glad I’d told her. I felt I’d gotten some good advice about how everything that looks nice isn’t always good for you.
And I felt relieved that now I didn’t have to sneak around with the bracelet. A weight had lifted off my shoulders.
But I believe I have the right to decide what I want to keep to myself and what I want to share with my mother, and that she should respect my need to tell her in my own time. I decided I needed to let her know how I felt.
‘I’m the Parent’
I went into her room and sat down on the edge of her bed. I told her I didn’t appreciate her looking over my shoulder and trying to read my personal email.
“I’m the parent,” she said, explaining that she was concerned about what I do on the Internet.
I know there are crazy people trying to trick teens on the Internet. But that was no excuse for wanting to read a personal email. doesn’t she trust me enough to know I’m not emailing some 45-year-old guy I met in a chat room who’s pretending to be 16?
I asked her, “What’s next? My diary? My text messages in my cell phone?” I told her that now I felt I couldn’t trust her to not read my diary if I left it out in the open.
I think that really hurt her feelings. To hide it, she began to get real sarcastic. “If I wanted to, I could read it,” she said. That got me so heated that I stormed out of her room and slammed the door.
Losing My Cell
The next day when I came home from school, my dad was waiting at the kitchen table. “Why did your mother tell me to take your phone away?” he asked. He told me to call her at work and ask her.
When I called, her sarcastic response was, “Since you don’t trust me, I don’t want you to be on the phone-I might hear your conversations. I wouldn’t want to invade your privacy.” She’d never acted like this before. I felt like I was talking to a whole different person, not my sensible, wise mom who was so easy to talk to.
I laughed. “Are you serious, Ma?”
“Yes, I am. Are you going outside to get something to eat?”
“Yeah,” I said and took a deep breath.
“Well, as soon as you get home, I want the phone on my-“
I hung up on her angrily in mid-sentence. “I’m going out.” I told my dad, and left the house.
When I returned, my mom was there. I was scared because I knew I’d be in trouble for hanging up on her and I’d probably never see my phone again. I put my phone on the charger in my room, hoping she’d forget about it. Then I went into her room. She was laying on her bed watching TV. I sat on the edge of her bed like I always do and said hi to her.
“Hey,” she replied, without looking my way.
An Awkward Silence
Then there was an awkward silence that lasted about a minute but felt like hours. I didn’t know whether she was mad or not, so I began some small talk to see what was going on.
“What are you watching?”
“Jeopardy,” she said in a monotone. We chatted a little but not much, and finally I went to bed without saying goodnight to her like I always do.
The next day, my mother didn’t take my phone away, but we didn’t talk. It felt weird and I had to fight the temptation to speak to her. But I felt she was wrong, so I refused to give in. A day later, she came into my room and sat on the edge of my bed.
“Patricia, I understand where you’re coming from but I’m your mother. I’m the parent. I have a right to read whatever is going on with you. Whether it’s an email, letter, whatever,” she said.
“I love you and I care about you and I just want to know what is going on. I hate the fact that you don’t tell me stuff like you used to. I know it’s because you are getting older but I need to know. That’s why I read the email. I just want to know where your head is at. I miss you,” she said.
My heart warmed and I wanted to cry. I’d never thought about it that way. I hadn’t noticed it before, but I had to admit, now that I was 15, I did hold more stuff back. I wasn’t too comfortable talking to her about boys. It wasn’t so easy to tell her things like I used to.
“I’d love to let you know what’s going on, Mom, but let me tell you from my own mouth, instead of having you read it over my shoulder in an email,” I told her. She nodded and I felt she understood. I hugged her and she hugged me back. It felt good to know that we were OK again.
A Better Understanding
When she left the room, I did a lot of thinking about my mom and me. Sometimes I take her for granted. I should be more grateful to have her in my life and appreciate her concern. I realized that when I’d gradually stopped telling her things, it was like she’d lost a friend. So she’d used desperate measures to get her friend back.
I realized that I didn’t want to lose her friendship either. My mom is the person who knows me the best, who’s always going to be there for me no matter what. And my mom was a teenager once too. So she can understand at least a little about what’s going on with me.
Since our talk, I feel like my mom understands my wish for privacy. Now she just glances at my emails sometimes to see if they could be from some crazy 45-year-old.
I feel like my mother and I have a better understanding now. We still have our usual talks when there’s something on my mind that I’m ready to tell her, which is great. And she’s OK with waiting until I’m ready. I know she loves me and wants to protect me. And since our talk, I feel safe about my privacy now. I even trust her to not read my diary.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.