As I watched a young Indian girl named Suchitra on screen in the documentary Born into Brothels, I couldn’t stop thinking about one of my former foster sisters.
Suchitra was passive and soft, no match for her aunt and cousins who were women of the night and wanted to bring her into the family prostitution business. My foster sister was also young and scared when her mother began lending her daughters out to male friends to feed her own drug habit.
These similarities shocked me. I was surprised that life in an overcrowded red light district in Calcutta, India, a very poor city in a poor developing country, could resemble the chaos, poverty and exploitation that I and other foster youth have grown up with in New York City’s projects.
Hungry and Unprotected
“Born into Brothels,” which won an Academy Award this year, follows eight children like Suchitra who live in a brothel. At night, the film shows hundreds of women standing on the streets waiting for men to pick them up. The women’s families live in dirty, one-room cubicles with just one bed for the whole family. None of the children attended school.
Although the brothels were incredibly dirty and cramped and the prostitution was right out in the open, I’d felt the children’s desolation before. Poverty, drugs, abuse and neglect-the sights and sounds were familiar.
The apathetic mothers seemed like my neighbors, who ignored the signs that my siblings and I were hungry and unprotected. The drugs and abuse reminded me of Mommy Dearest. I remembered my own nearly empty apartment, with little furniture or food even though nine people lived there.
Their lives seemed like part of an unbreakable cycle. Suchitra’s parents had lived that way as children, so they raised her the same way. No one gives a damn and the odds are against you. Sound familiar?
A Chance to Create
Then into the brothel stepped Zana Briski, a New York photojournalist who came to India to photograph prostitutes. She ended up teaching the children photography and trying to enroll them in schools.
Suchitra and seven others-Gour, Shanti, Puja, Avijit, Manik, Kochi and Tapasi-became Zana’s young students. They were eager to learn how to use a camera and expose their world. They snapped pictures of naked babies, camels on a beach and children hauling pails of water.
Avijit had the makings of a great artist. He had an eye for perspective and detail, and seemed the most creative of the group. But he wandered aimlessly for a while after his mother’s death. Avijit’s resignation and creativity reminded me of my own deep passion for writing, and my grief.
Suchitra’s passivity reminded me of how I dealt with being sexually abused-denial. Puja’s honest compassion made me think about how I’ve tried to remain a caring person despite what’s happened to me.
Which World Feels Right?
Briski, who the kids called “Zana Auntie,” is an idealist who can’t stand by and watch her students become victims of their environment. She becomes determined to change the kids’ lives by getting them into boarding schools, which normally would not have accepted them because of their mothers’ careers, but will provide a path out of the brothels.
I was as shocked as Zana Auntie that some of the kids ended up choosing to return home from their schools. I couldn’t believe they weren’t determined to leave the squalor they grew up in.
Later I thought about how many of us in foster care return home when we age out, or end up living similarly to how we were raised. I could understand why some of the kids in “Born into Brothels” left school.
Not Free to Choose
Maybe they missed their families. Or maybe what they’d grown up with seemed normal, and the schools felt abnormal, or even dangerous. Perhaps they felt that by embracing new goals for their lives, they’d be putting down where they came from and becoming part of a world of people who judge their mothers.
I see that here, too. A lot of people worry that by succeeding or leaving the kind of neighborhood they grew up in, they’ll be abandoning their families. To me, that’s unfortunate. I don’t want to end up where I came from.
Suchitra didn’t have a choice. Her aunt took her out of school to make money by learning the family trade. I felt terrible for her. At least kids here have a shred of hope. We have free schools and laws against exploiting children. And even though foster care comes with its own pain, we have that.
Wandering? Or Succeeding?
As the credits rolled, I wondered what would happen to the kids who didn’t finish school. Would they end up like their parents? Would they find another way to move up in life? It seemed unlikely that in India they’d find a way.
I wondered about my own future, too. Will I be one of those who make it or one of those who don’t? I’m not sure yet. Maybe I’m like Shanti, not ready to break away from what I know because I’m not sure there’s something better out there for me. At least I’m not like Suchitra, without the option to choose. I hope I’m like Avijit, wandering for a time but eventually succeeding.
Been There
Foster Care Looks Good After Seeing `Born into Brothels'
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.