Texas Teen Shelby Knox Fights for Sex Ed

The town of Lubbock, Texas, is famous for two things: It is the hometown of 1950s rock ‘n roll pioneer Buddy Holly and it has one of the highest rates of sexually transmitted disease (STD) and pregnancy among teenagers in the country.
This second fact prompted a group of Lubbock teens to press their high school for better sex education. The Education of Shelby Knox, a documentary film to be shown on PBS (channel 13), follows one of the leaders of that effort, Shelby Knox.
No Sex Until Marriage
Lubbock is primarily conservative Christian and the town leaders don’t believe that schools should teach sex education. Instead they support abstinence-only education, which teaches only one way to prevent STDs and pregnancy-by not having sex.
Advocates of abstinence education believe that there is no such thing as safe sex and that all people should wait until marriage before they have sex. Shelby sees the high rate of STDs and teen pregnancy in Lubbock as a sign that the abstinence-only approach is not working.
Shelby Knox herself is a devout Christian who believes that abstinence is the proper lifestyle for any unmarried person. Early in the movie she takes a virginity pledge, promising, in front of a pastor and her parents, not to have sex until marriage.
But Shelby recognizes that not everyone feels the same way she does. She wants to fight for the rights of kids to know how to protect themselves.
‘Christianity Is Intolerant’
As a sophomore in 2002, she joins the Lubbock Youth Commission, a teen organization funded by the town government. They campaign to raise awareness of the need for sex ed in schools and they film commercials advocating for sex ed. They pressure the school board to have hearings on the issue, but nothing changes.
Shelby is passionate about her beliefs, which she knows go against those of her pastor, Ed Ainsworth, who runs the abstinence-only program True Love Waits. At one point Ainsworth tells her, “Christianity is the most intolerant religion in the worldâ I hear you speak, and I hear tolerance.”
Yes, he’s saying that intolerance is good and tolerance is bad. Ainsworth has such twisted interpretations of the Bible, I wish the movie had centered on him. Shelby disagrees with his view and insists, once she’s out of Ainsworth’s hearing, that Christianity is about being tolerant.
Folding Under Pressure
Eventually, the Lub-bock Youth Commission abandons the campaign for sex ed when the town government becomes displeased with their radical views and threatens to cut the group’s funding. Shelby feels disheartened by the Youth Commission’s willingness to just give up and she resigns from her position.
I found it kind of ironic that the town government cared enough to set up a Youth Commission so the youth of Lubbock could express their thoughts and opinions-until their opinions differed from those of the town government.
Later on, Shelby takes up the cause of a Gay Straight Alliance (GSA) in her high school when the group is prohibited from hanging up flyers. When she hears the stories of gay kids from Lubbock, she’s horrified by the level of intolerance that they’vehad to deal with, like being routinely threatened in the school parking lot and the school doing nothing about it.
She joins the kids in a counter-demonstration when, after the GSA makes the local news, an organization called God Hates Fags pickets in front of the school, carrying vicious signs saying things like “AIDS cures fags dead.”
It was kind of surprising watching Miss Virginity Pledge take up with the gay kids. I’d almost expected her to brand them all sinners and send them on their way, but she shows herself to be open-minded.
In my old school we had a couple of gay teachers who were “out” and had set up a GSA. GSA is a legitimate extracurricular club and in my school most of the members were straight girls.
One activity was a day of silence to support gay kids who were afraid to come out. The students pinned notes on their shirts explaining that they were taking part in the day of silence and the teachers excused them from speaking in class.
It can be hard to believe that Lubbock and New York City are in the same country.
I agree with Shelby that it isn’t right to persecute gay people and I support her cause to get sex ed. I think that would help reduce the number of teen pregnancies and the spread of sexually transmitted disease in Lubbock. It’s nice to see a teenager taking a stand in a redneck town. But unfortunately, the God Hates Fags picket line looked like it held a lot more sway over the townsfolk of Lubbock than all of Shelby’s hard work put together.
The Education of Shelby Knox has its broadcast premiere on PBS the week of June 21, 2005. Check the channel 13 schedule for exact date and time.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.