Playing Video Games Won’t Make Me a Killer

I ran around the haunted ship, re-killing hoards of the undead and racking up experience points. Little did I know that the video game I was playing was infesting my brain, burrowing into the very synapses that control my behavior and burning an impression into my fragile little psyche that would leave me a cold, dark shadow of a man, and a killer.
Sound silly? Well, according to some “experts” and activist groups, that’s what violent video games do to children and teens. They say these games rip away our morality and make us mindless imitators of the violent characters in the games.
I disagree. Just look at the number of teens who play these games. How many do you see joining the U.S. Navy after playing SOCOM? How many try to steal Elizabeth Taylor’s jewelry collection after playing Thief III? Most of us can control ourselves.
Comics Vs. Defenseless Youth
This issue isn’t new. Various forms of media have been blamed for youth violence for years now-since before TV. In the 1940s and ’50s, for example, comic books were held responsible for an increase in youth crime.
Back then, comic books about true crime or superheroes became the “In thing” among teens and adults alike. Publishers placed gory or arousing pictures on the covers of comic books to sell them. One cover featured a decapitated woman’s head being placed in an oven. And most cover girls happened to be extremely big breasted and missing most of their shirts.
The fact that teens were reading these books was brought to the attention of U.S. Senator Estes Kefauver, who quickly set out to prove the harmful effects of comics on defenseless youth. The Senate established a subcommittee on juvenile delinquency, and in 1955, after three months of hearings, they released a report criticizing comic books.
PTA Held Public Book Burnings
A consultant for the subcommittee was a psychologist named Frederic Wertham. He claimed that comics “create a mental readiness for temptation” and “an atmosphere of cruelty.”
Wertham helped come up with a questionnaire for the study. But fewer than half of the psychiatrists, social workers, juvenile court judges and probation officers who took part in his survey thought there was a connection between comics and juvenile delinquency.
Wertham went further and published a book called Seduction of the Innocent that set flames of comic book hatred across the nation. And I mean that literally. PTA groups held public comic book burnings. Only the likes of Bugs Bunny and Disney characters were safe from the blaze of insanity.
Eventually the fire died down, and in the years that followed, comics, for the most part, became accepted by society. Nowadays, it’s other forms of media that are under attack.
Look at the music world, for example. Many bands have taken flack for the tone and messages of their music. Politicans and others blamed Marilyn Manson, with his goth image and violent lyrics, for the 1999 Columbine HS massacre (despite the fact that neither of the school shooters in that case were Manson fans).
And for years rap artists like Tupac Shakur and Bone Thugs-N-Harmony have been accused of glamorizing violence and gang culture, and even inspiring a 1998 middle school shooting.
Lawsuits Blamed the Game
The hysteria today about media and youth violence isn’t new. Video games are just up next, an easy target for the blame-bullet.
For example, on December 1, 1997, 14-year-old Michael Carneal fired shots on a student prayer group at his school, Heath HS, in Paducah, Kentucky.
It’s sad enough that he was so troubled that he took out his frustrations in such a way, but I find it even sadder that the families of three of the victims sued (and thereby blamed) several media companies for $33 million: Time Warner Inc.-the makers of the movie The Basketball Diaries, and three game producers-Sony Computer Entertainment, Sega of America Inc. and Nintendo of America.
Because there was a scene in The Basketball Diaries where a student shot up a classroom, and because Michael also happened to play DOOM (a shooting game about escaping hell), the families argued that the companies should’ve warned consumers that their products might bring about copycat violence.
That logic escapes me. Just because someone plays a game and shoots up a school doesn’t mean the game is to blame. Plenty of other teenagers watched this movie or played those games without shooting their classmates.
Not only did this lawsuit place the blame everywhere but on the person who committed the crime, it implied that teens are too dumb to think for ourselves. I find that insulting. I’ve played DOOM. And afterwards, I usually make a sandwich or do my homework. I don’t go and shoot people. Luckily the case was dismissed.
Yes, there’s violence in games. Video games are produced by businesses and they have to make a profit. “Sex sells,” and so do explosions, sword fights, fire balls, lasers, and dragons. They appeal to the general public’s interests. Teens happen to be part of the public and many of us find these extreme forms of pretending and challenge interesting.
The Monster Has to Be There Already
But games don’t suddenly make you violent. Michael Carneal, for example, suffered from a schizophrenia-like disease, had a hard time telling real from imaginary, and had been bullied by classmates. If he’d never played a game in his life, his own loose grip on reality combined with his anger easily could’ve lead to something unfortunate sooner or later.
Even studies by Dr. David Satcher, former Surgeon General (the nation’s chief health officer) back me up. They found that violence in the media leads to aggression only in those teens already exposed to violence at a young age.
Meaning, I could play DOOM till the cows come home, but as long as I was of sound mind beforehand, it won’t turn me into a monster. The monster would’ve had to be there already.
Now, I am not saying that it’s impossible for teens to be influenced by video games. Everyone is influenced by everything to some extent. You may walk out of your house right now and see someone with a pair of sneakers you never knew existed and suddenly want a pair yourself.
You could’ve had a teacher who made you put your gum on your nose if you were caught with it and now you can’t stand gum. You may even be reading this now and be influenced to play your favorite video game. But unless you already have violent tendencies, or can’t tell right from wrong, you won’t end up shooting someone after playing that game.
In Games, we’re in Control
Many things can cause an inability to distinguish right from wrong, reality from fiction. A teen may be mentally unstable, too immature (not just in age, but in reasoning) to understand the magnitude of their actions or maybe they’re actually already a heartless, cold-blooded murderer who likes games. But a game didn’t make them that way.
Games imitate life, not the other way around. And real life isn’t all Tetris or Poke’mon. It’s deeper and more complex than that, so the games that mirror it have become deeper and more complex along with it.
And they’vebecome more violent. We live in a world where real violence is everywhere, from neighborhood shootings to the war in Iraq. we’re mostly helpless to stop it, and we just have to live through it. In games though, we’re in control.
No Sword Fighting in My Reality
I play violent games because they allow me to be the uprising underdog within dark, realistic story lines filled with conspiracy and secrets. I get to triumph over evils like Sephiroth or Akuma because in the game I have the power to take a hit without dying, to wield 12-foot swords, or to press pause. It’s a wild and crazy world, and I’m in control.
Then I turn the game off, and I know that’s where it ends. There is no sword fighting, or gun shooting, or military action in my personal reality. Just in my PlayStation.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.