Robbed

She Took the Shirt Off My Back-But Not My Faith in Friendship

She was a new resident at my group home. Me being the people person that I am, we instantly made friends. She moved into my room and we became double trouble for staff. As the two youngest girls in the group home (she was 13, I was 15), we were really tight. We couldn’t work and go to clubs like the older girls, so we hung out in the neighborhood after school, and on weekends we went to parties together. We were inseparable.
She was the one person there who really understood me. She knew my deepest secrets, but would never tell them because friends do not tell their friends’ secrets. I had often wondered if you could ever really trust another person. She was the one and only person I trusted 200%.
But the word around the group home was that my friend was a thief. Every girl and staff member in the house-me included-was well aware of her stealing habits.
I Stood Up for Her
At first this did not affect how I felt about her. After all, I was her friend. She had no reason to steal from me. We were roommates and she knew she could borrow anything she wanted. We shared clothes, hair gel, soap and toilet paper.
So every time a girl accused her of stealing, I stood up for her. I said there was no way she would do such a thing, even though usually I knew she had stolen something. I lied not just because I didn’t think she would steal from me, but because I believe you stand up for people you really care about. If my mother ever asked which one of us kids did something wrong, we all looked at her like, “What?” even if we knew who it was.
When I went home on a trial discharge, my friend called me once or twice a week to see how I was holding up. That meant a lot to me. Soon I went back to the group home and we started hanging out all over again. We may as well have been named Frick and Frack. It is too bad those names are already taken.
Caught Red Handed
Only one thing had changed: her habits. They had gotten worse. She was caught red-handed stealing clothes and hygiene items from some other girls. Still, I stood up for her.
Then, once or twice I found myself looking for something and she said she’d borrowed it. After a while I realized that several of my white T-shirts with my name on the tags were missing. At first I thought it was just my imagination. Then my friend turned up with an unusually ample supply of T-shirts without tags. I decided to overlook this. I didn’t want to mess up our friendship by making a big deal out of it. I told myself I didn’t care that much about the T-shirts because I could always get more shirts. See, my family would always get me what I needed, even when I was in the system, but her family wouldn’t.
Even so, part of me felt upset about it. I hated the thought that my friend might steal from me.
The Vanishing Shirt
One Saturday morning my friend and I were packing to go on weekend passes. She told me to take off my short-sleeved Old Navy shirt and put on a warmer one because it was cold outside, so I changed into a long-sleeved shirt. Once outside, I realized the weather was warm. I went inside to change back into that Old Navy shirt.
But the shirt wasn’t there. I knew I was not crazy!
My friend was in the room while I tore it apart looking for my shirt. I asked her if she saw it. She said no.
Good news? I found my shirt. Bad news? I found two other shirts of mine as well-under her bed.
I had kept hoping that our friendship was stronger than her need to steal. I was so upset and hurt to find out I was wrong. Telling me to take it off just so she could steal it was so grimey! I thought, “Have I just lost my best friend?”
‘You Got it Back, Right?”
This time I could not let it go. I went to staff and told them all about it in my mean attitude. They called my friend downstairs and I asked her about it.
“Why should you care why I took the shirt? You got it back, right?” she asked me.
“That is not the point. I just want to know why you would steal something from me. Of all girls in this house, me? Why?” I shouted back.
“I do not know what the big deal is. You got your sh-t back, so leave it at that. I don’t care.”
Staff half agreed with both of us. They knew it was wrong for her to take it, but then again I got it back. But it was a big deal to me-I felt betrayed by a friend.
Mending a Broken Friendship
We didn’t talk to each other for a week or so . . . a long time in broken-hearted friendship calculations. Afterwards she apologized to me in a letter. She said she had not realized how much our friendship meant, and that she would never do it again. She also explained how belongings of hers had been stolen from girls at other group homes, yet they were “friends.” I guess she learned from those girls that stealing from friends was OK.
For a few days we wrote notes back and forth to each other. These notes made it easier for my friend and me to understand one another. Mostly she just wrote me notes asking to borrow things, but that was the way we chose to talk for a while. And soon we were hanging out all over again.
Some of you may wonder why I would be friendly again with someone who had stolen from me. But what I learned was that I could trust my friend with some things but not others. I would never leave her alone with my bag, but I would still tell her my secrets. Even after we argued over my shirt, she never told my secrets to anyone.
I Miss Her
That’s how it is with most friendships. You can trust different friends with different things. And the only way you can learn what kind of friend you have is through trial-and-error. Sometimes you might get hurt, but you can’t close yourself off completely because then you will never be anyone’s friend.
It’s not OK that my friend stole from me or lied to me, but that’s how she grew up and I can’t change how she grew up. You know that saying: You can’t teach an old dog new tricks.
Eventually my friend was sent upstate, and we don’t see each other anymore. Even though she stole my shirt and made me wonder whether I could ever trust anyone completely, I miss her. I really miss her. I miss having someone to talk to the way I could talk to her. But I still haven’t figured out whether you can ever trust someone completely.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.