Meeting of the Minds

Four Represent Writers School the System (And Learn Something Too)

On September 27, three Represent writers and I went on a mission down to the office of the Administration for Children’s Services, New York City’s foster care agency. I was accompanied by my twin, Taheerah, and by Hattie Rice, Erica Harrigan and our editor.
ACS knew we were writing about their new policy of closing group homes and moving teens to foster homes. They asked to meet with us so they could hear about our experiences transitioning from one lifestyle to the next.
When we walked into the big conference room, I thought, “Wow, there are so many people here.” ACS had almost 20 people in the room, including the commissioner! I figured they really wanted to understand how we felt.
‘Independent Living Is a Fraud’
Alexandra Lowe, ACs’ special counsel to the division of foster care and preventive services, told us that group homes and independent living apartments don’t do a good job preparing teens for life after care. “Independent living is a fraud,” she said bluntly. “Most kids cannot be independent at the ages of 18 and 21.” She thinks that if more teens lived in foster homes instead of group homes, their foster parents might continue helping them even after they leave the system.
Lowe said the average kid outside the system leaves home at age 26. Then she said, “We’ve asked kids in foster care to make a choice that the average kid doesn’t have to make-between having a family and being independent.”
We understood what she meant.
Talking about it later, Erica, who is 19, said, “It’s nice they’re trying to stop teens in foster care from ending up with nowhere to go. They’re right-it doesn’t make sense to keep kids locked down in group homes ’til they age out. Then we have no family to turn to, so we have to turn to the streets for survival.”
A Foster Mom to Count On
We all agree that teens leaving care need someone to help them, but we also don’t trust that a foster parent would still be there when the money stops flowing. In the meeting, Hattie said, “Foster parents don’t treat you the same as their own kids.” What if the foster parent just stops helping the child at 21?
That’s when a former foster youth, Angela Egers, stepped in. Angela told us about moving in with a great foster mom, Mary Keane. Angela explained: “I got in a really big fight with a girl. Mary came to me and said,’It’s not for the money, it’s for you.’ I knew she cared about me. Now I don’t have to get in fights. If I’m upset, I go home and talk to my mom-Mary.”
Trained to Be Babysitters
Angela turned 21, but she still lives with Mary. As Angela said, “There are some good foster parents and bad ones. That’s the system’s fault. They train parents to act like babysitters.”
A woman who runs support groups for foster parents agreed. “A lot of foster parents don’t know their role. They get 10 hours of training.”
“I went to a training and I was like,’Oh, my god,'” Angela added. “They were talking about 10-day notices, nothing was permanent. I was like,’How are you going to train these people that if kids misbehave, they get sent away-for having an attitude, for breaking curfew.’ These parents need to be training to take care of teens.”
Finally! Someone willing to admit the system has flaws.
‘It Sounds Like You Were Resistant’
When my own group home closed, my twin and I moved in with a lady who kicked us out three weeks later. My sister, Taheerah, felt bad about what happened with that lady. She said in the meeting, “We didn’t give the lady a chance.”
Then an ACS worker said to Taheerah, “It sounds like you were arguing and resistant in that home.” I felt she was quick to blame us, when the foster mom kicked us out.
Later, my case planner, Mr. Taitt, said to me that my agency had worked hard to find that foster mother. He bashed me down, saying, “I hope that this experience hasn’t soured her.”
I felt so angry and hurt by his comment. He doesn’t know anything about our past or why we’d have trouble in a foster home. And he seemed more worried about how the foster mother felt than how I felt.
Nobody Knows Our Story
His words made me remember meeting my other case planner, Ms. Scott. One day Ms. Scott came to my group home to talk to us all about where we’d move to.
She asked my sister and me, “Why did you come into care?” I wanted to scream on her. I wasn’t about to tell a stranger that my mom was mentally ill and my father sexually abused me. It’s hard for me to even think about my past.
I asked her, “didn’t you read our file? don’t you know anything about our case?”
She said, “I got this file but I want to hear it from you.”
Looking at Mr. Taitt and Ms. Scott in the meeting, I thought about how nobody in charge of my case really understands my life story. How can they make decisions about where I should live? I felt they should’ve gotten to know me a long time ago.
Two People Kept Things Flowing
Later, I blurted out, “Look, I was sexually abused.” It felt funny to say but I wanted them to hear it. I wasn’t even sure they knew that.
At times, the meeting got tense. But we all agreed that two people really seemed to be listening and kept things flowing.
One ACS worker, Geoff Burgess, asked me why I went AWOL from my foster home. He said, “Do you think AWOL is a safety net for you?”
I replied, “I go where I feel safe.” I felt he was trying to understand me.
And we all liked Carla McCulty, who’s been helping teens in Hattie’s group home find places to live. Carla had the right body language. She sat forward, made eye contact, smiled and listened closely. She’d met Hattie only months before, but she seemed to know her well.
‘The Search Goes On’
After Hattie complained about the potential foster parents she’d met, Carla said, “Hattie, we’ve talked and this is what I heard you say was important to you: You’re a private person who needs her space, you prefer to be the only kid, school is important to you and you need time to study.”
Hattie agreed with her, saying, “People come on to me too hard. They’re like,’Why aren’t you talking?’ I’m like,’I’m trying to watch my Discovery Channel.'”
Carla tried to reassure Hattie that she will find someone good. “The search goes on,” she said. “You’ve had an opportunity to meet people. It’s a matching process. I know you keep being introduced to people and it feels bad. But you haven’t gone to live with the people you didn’t like.”
After that, an ACS lady got it right when she said, “It sounds like you feel you have absolutely no control over the process.”
Were Our Concerns Heard?
I felt glad that the ACS workers really were trying to help teens out, that they’d asked to hear from us, and that they were stuck on whether their plan to benefit us was really working. But near the end of the meeting, none of us was sure that our concerns had been heard.
Erica said later, “That meeting was a little emotional for me. I wanted to cry out how I felt-that you girls and I were talking to brick walls. I feared that, no matter what we said at the meeting, they had already made up their minds.”
But at the very end of the meeting, one woman said, “I’m so glad I’m part of this forum. I’ll go back out and meet with the young people I see and ask them, “What could we do to make this process easier for you?”
I was glad that our words had affected her, and I hope that in the future, the people who create policies at ACS will continue making more of an effort to hear from the teens affected by their decisions.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.