Everyone in my family except me is a little old fashioned and conservative. Over the past few years, I’ve found myself disagreeing with them about lots of things, like religion, homosexuality and the war in Iraq.
When I say what I think, they get angry at me and sometimes we fight. They seem to think I’m intentionally separating myself from them when I disagree, rather than just wanting to express my opinions.
Once in an argument my brother told me, “You disagree with other people just to cause problems and resist their points of view to show your rebelliousness to the family.” That attitude makes me feel like my opinions don’t matter, that I don’t matter.
Fighting Over a TV Show
Once at my grandmother’s apartment, my aunts, my mother and I were all watching a Spanish soap opera called Los Teens. One of the girls on the show had a baby, and at the end of the episode, she left the baby at an adoption agency.
For the next 10 or 15 minutes, all I heard from my aunts and my mom was, “Oh my God, that’s just sending the wrong message to girls nowadays” and, “They should have showed her conquering all odds and still keeping her baby and being successful.”
After a while I got tired of listening to their points, which sounded more like what they wanted to see, not how the real world is. So I said, “Well, I think it’s a good way to end things. It’s more realistic.”
Then my mother and my aunts started to bombard me with questions and comments like, “You really think it’s better for her to abandon her child than to try to move forward with her?”
Mom Takes It Personally
I defended the character’s choice, saying that she didn’t want the baby and couldn’t support it. We argued about that for a while, and then one of my aunts asked sarcastically, “Then you will allow your daughter to have an abortion?”
I said that I would talk to her seriously about it, but “If she still wanted to have an abortion, I wouldn’t stand in her way.”
Then my mom snapped, “So that’s what you think, huh? OK, it’s good to know that’s how much you appreciate life, family and the efforts your mother has made for you.”
I tried to explain myself. It wasn’t that I didn’t appreciate my mother and all the things she’s done for me, but she was comparing herself to someone in a completely different position. (When she had me, she was married and had a steady income.)
I felt guilty because I’d hurt my mother’s feelings, but I was also angry that she wouldn’t let me disagree with her without making it a personal attack.
Speaking Without Fear
Fortunately, I’ve found a place where I feel free to express myself without fear of being attacked, where I can talk comfortably about topics that cause trouble at home. This place is TREA (Teens for the Racial and Ethnic Awakening), an after-school discussion group at Renaissance Charter School in Jackson Heights, Queens.
About a dozen students and two adult advisors get together once a week, usually in a world history classroom. We cover a different topic at each meeting, ranging from serious issues like homophobia, sex and racism, to more laid back and entertaining topics like music and poetry. I’ve been an active member for the past two years and I started facilitating meetings last school year.
At TREA, we have rules to ensure that people treat each other’s opinions and experiences with respect, and everyone follows them. At one meeting, the topic was abortion, and the atmosphere couldn’t have been more different than watching Los Teens at my grandmother’s.
Calm, Friendly Debate
Someone said that she wouldn’t have an abortion because that would be committing a murder. Someone else politely replied, “It depends on the way you view life-if you think that a few cells can be considered life,” and then said that she supports abortion. Other kids joined in the debate, bringing up religion and their parents’ views.
The meeting went on as a friendly, calm discussion, even though we were talking about something that can be emotional and personal. I could listen to the two sides and think about what everyone was saying.
Although I didn’t offer my own views at that particular meeting, I’ve contributed to other discussions and felt valued and at ease.
Instead of getting caught up in an emotional battle like I do at home, I can concentrate on other people’s points. Sometimes I’ve changed my opinions; other times I’ve learned new ways to explain and defend my views so that other people understand me.
More Love Means More Arguing
I’ve realized why there’s such a big difference between my family and TREA. At TREA I have no fear of contradicting somebody because I don’t have the same bond with them that I have with the people in my family. It doesn’t matter personally to the members of TREA if I disagree with them.
And I have no fear of being contradicted at TREA. I have to admit that at home sometimes I get passionate and angry in discussions with my family because I want them to agree with me and be on my side. My family is important to me, and I love them.
TREA has given me not only a peaceful retreat from my family but also a new perspective on my relationship with them.
During a meeting about relationships, I said something I’d never told anyone before. My ears felt like dynamite, my blood seemed to warm more than 20 degrees, and I knew that my face had turned as red as a tomato.
Still Close to Mom
“My mom and I have a good relationship,” I said. “Sometimes, key word sometimes, I feel like she’s a really close friend of mine. However, I feel like there are some issues that we wouldn’t be able to talk about. I feel that because she’s a little traditional and conservative, I can’t talk to her as freely as I would want to.”
As I talked, I looked around and saw that people’s expressions were kind and welcoming. No one attacked what I said. The next person to speak talked about her relationship with her mother. It was a huge relief to express my conflicting feelings about my mother out loud.
Even though we clash on political and social issues, my mom and I are really close in other ways. Every day I tell her what happened at school, what I got on my exams, the funny stuff that happened in gym class, the projects that I have to do, any problems with my teachers.
She pays more attention to me when I say these things than when we argue about political and social issues. She acts very understanding and talks to me and gives me advice without judging me. We don’t have any tension between us, and it feels great because I know she supports and respects me.
can’t Tell Mom About Depression
But I can’t talk to her about some of my deeper feelings. At one TREA meeting, we had a guest speaker from the National Alliance for the Mentally Ill who talked about depression.
I’ve felt depressed in the past, and I was relieved to hear an adult acknowledge that it happens to teens. Other members of TREA talked about their experiences with depression, and I was comforted to know that I wasn’t alone in having this problem sometimes.
Without saying that I’d been depressed at times, I told my mom about the meeting. She just couldn’t understand. She said, “Teenagers shouldn’t be depressed. It’s not like they have the worries or problems that adults face,” like bills or taking care of children. I kept trying to convince her, but she wouldn’t accept the fact that adolescents do get depressed.
I was disappointed and hurt by my mom’s reaction. I knew that I wouldn’t be able to talk to her about my depression. She’s my mother and I want her to help me when I feel sad, not dismiss me as an ungrateful, spoiled kid.
Even though I can’t tell her everything about my life, I want to hold onto the closeness my mom and I do have. But the more we fight about things like abortion, the more I feel like I’m hurting her and driving us apart.
Keeping the Peace
Because I have TREA as a place to express myself fully, for now I’m trying to avoid having arguments with my mom and the rest of my family. I know that if I changed my beliefs to theirs (or pretended that I agreed with them), we’d have much less tension between us. But I can’t do that. I won’t lie to them, and I won’t lie to myself, either.
Instead, when certain topics come up, I stay quiet or change the subject. For instance, if they’re talking about President Bush, I’ll bring up something that happened in the family or ask a question about a TV show that my family watches.
But it’s hard to stay away from debates with them, especially when someone says something I’m completely against. I hate having to stifle myself.
I hope that as I get older, my family will stop seeing me as a rebellious kid and start to respect me and my ideas. We still might not agree about political and social issues, but maybe we’ll be able to exchange our thoughts peacefully, without hurting one another.
When Politics Gets Personal
I Hate Fighting With My Family Over My Opinions
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.