Some names and details have been changed.
I’m 18 years old, and my mother calls me every hour on the hour because she wants to know where I am and what I’m doing. She knows all my friends and has all their numbers. My friends crack jokes about my mom being overprotective. Even her sisters and brothers think she’s too strict with me.
One night when I was 15, my cousin and I wanted to see a movie, but my mom said no because it started at 9, which she thought was too late. She let me go bowling instead. I was spending the night at my aunt’s house, and we got back around 11 p.m.
“Your mom was calling here breaking,” Aunty said when we walked in the house. “I just got off the phone with her.”
I tensed up. Whenever I went to someone else’s house, my mom would call and argue about where I was with whoever picked up the phone.
“Why was she so upset? She knew where I was at,” I said.
“Uh huh, but your mother said you’re a liar because you weren’t in the house before 10 p.m.,” Aunty answered.
“What? How am I a liar? I went bowling. We had to wait a hour for a lane to open up,” I protested.
“Your mother thinks you went to the movies after all, and she said to come home tonight,” Aunty said. “Girl, I don’t know how you do it. If I had a mom like yours, I’d jump out the window. I’d probably strangle her. What’s your secret?”
I laughed, but inside I agreed with Aunty. Sometimes I did want to strangle my mom.
Let Me Breathe
My mother believes that a girl isn’t grown until she’s 21 years old, and the only way to raise a child is to have strict rules and discipline for all 21 of those years. I’m my mom’s only child, and I don’t see my dad much at all. Mom says that she wants to protect me from “the big bad world” and that she sees all the things that happen to people on the news and doesn’t want them to happen to me.
But her rules make me feel suffocated and trapped. At times I feel like telling her off, but when I do, she over-talks me or yells at me. I get the urge to scream back, but I don’t. Sometimes I even want to hit or push her. I want to tell her, “Leave me alone and let me breathe.”
I believe that she loves me because she worries about me so much. But that’s all she does. She doesn’t want to hear about my life, and we don’t say much to each other except, “How are you?” “Fine.” I wish she’d put more energy into supporting me instead of controlling me.
A Rough Neighborhood
I understand some of her concern for my safety, though. We live in a dangerous neighborhood where people often get shot and every other corner is a hot spot where people are dealing drugs.
But my mom taught me to stay away from dealers and the bad corners. Plus, everyone knows me in my neighborhood and they don’t let anything happen to me. I’ve always done well in school, never gotten involved in drugs or drinking, and haven’t gotten pregnant, but even now, Mom doesn’t trust me to go on a date.
One time she told me she doesn’t want me to make the same mistakes she made in life, but she’s never told me what those mistakes were. How am I not going to make the same mistakes she made if I don’t know what they are?
Almost Ran Away
Until I was 15, my curfew was 8 p.m. Mom didn’t let me go out with my friends or take the subway without an adult. I couldn’t pick out my own clothes, and I wasn’t allowed to date or even get calls from boys.
She never told me how she would punish me if I broke a rule, but she said that she’d find out if I was disobeying her. I was afraid that she’d beat me if I did something wrong because a few times when I was younger, she hit me.
When I was 15, I was so desperate to escape Mom’s rules that I decided to run away to my dad’s. I packed a suitcase and hid it under my bed, waiting for the right moment. But Mom saw it and confronted me after school one day. She asked me what was wrong and why I wanted to leave. She said I didn’t love her.
“I love you,” I told her. “You just make me mad and you get on my nerves.”
“How do I get on your nerves? What do I do?”
“You’re always yelling at me. You call me every hour. You barely let me go out with my friends. You are too overprotective.”
‘I Worry About You’
“I call you because I worry about you and I want to make sure you’re OK,” Mom said. “I don’t want anything to happen to you. And I’m not that overprotective. I let you go out.”
“No, you don’t. I go outside around the block or to my cousins’ house. I don’t get to go to the movies and stuff like that unless it’s with an adult.”
I explained that I wanted her to extend my curfew and to stop calling me at other people’s houses. I also told her I wanted us to talk more.
I think it really scared Mom that I was thinking of leaving. Usually, she’s the boss, and whatever she says goes, but this time she listened.
After our fight, she changed a little. She started to let me go out with my friends without an adult present. She changed my curfew to 9 p.m. on my 16th birthday, and she let me shop for myself. I was relieved that she let me have some freedom, and I felt she cared about my feelings.
Mom wasn’t There for Me
But not long after that fight, my mom wouldn’t let me apply to a high school in another borough because “It’s too far. I don’t want you to be going to school out there by yourself.”
Part of me thought she was afraid of me leaving because I’m her only child and she’d be lonely without me. That’s a kind of love, but the kind of love that feels like jail.
I went to my zoned high school, and I joined the basketball team freshman year. I loved it, and I wanted my mom to come to my games, to be a part of something that I enjoyed doing and that I was good at.
She would say she’d come but never did, even though sometimes I had games on days she didn’t have to work. When she didn’t show up, it felt like a knife in my heart. She loved me so much that she wouldn’t let me leave her side, so how could she leave me hanging when I did want her with me?
With my mother acting like my jailer instead of my mom, I ended up doing exactly what she didn’t want me to do: I started dating boys behind her back.
A Secret Boyfriend
“You better not be having sex. You better not have a boyfriend. You can’t date,” Mom would tell me. “You’re not going to be like those young girls out there having babies. You’re going to graduate and be something in life.”
But her words didn’t stop me from going out with Michael, my first real boyfriend. We met when I was a freshman in high school. He showed up at my basketball games and went to church with me even though he didn’t have to go. I could talk to him about anything.
But I constantly worried that my mom would find out about us, and if she did, she would forbid me from seeing him. Finally, after two years, the hiding got to me. I broke up with Michael.
I haven’t had a boyfriend since then, and I don’t want one until I get out of the house.
Fewer Rules, Same Attitude
My mom loosens her rules slightly each year. Now that I’m 18, my curfew is 11 p.m. I can take the train and the bus by myself if I have to.
But her attitude towards me hasn’t changed. She still has to know everywhere I go and who I go with. She calls me on my cell phone all the time to see where I am. She tries to tell me what I can and can’t wear, and I’m still not allowed to date.
Instead of worrying about my physical safety all the time, I wish my mom were more emotionally protective of me. I want to be able to ask her for advice. I also want her to open up to me.
Even though my mother drives me crazy, she’s the only mom I’ve got. That’s why it hurts me that our relationship is so much about rules, and so little about communication and closeness.
Sometimes I think I should sit down with her and, without seeming disrespectful, explain how I feel.
But I’m scared she’ll freak out and start yelling. Every time I want to talk to her, it’s like my mind goes blank and the words won’t come out.
I plan to go away to college in a year, and I look forward to getting away from Mom and her rules. I believe I’ll feel free and more at ease. But I still want to be close to my mother. I don’t want to feel like we could never break down the walls between us.
Mom’s Rules Make Me Feel Trapped
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.