Hey Hollywood! Let’s See More Asian-Americans

Why is it so hard to find an Asian-American actor starring in a major American film? There’s no Asian-American actor as big as Al Pacino or Julia Roberts, or even Samuel L. Jackson or Halle Berry.
Perhaps the most popular Asian-American actors are Lucy Liu and B.D. Wong. Lucy Liu’s most famous roles have been as a supporting character on TV’s Ally McBeal and as one of the three leads in the Charlie’s Angels movies.
B.D. Wong, who won many awards as a theater actor, is probably best known for his role on the show Law and Order: Special Victims Unit.
But how about other Asian-American stars? Margaret Cho, the comedian, had her own sitcom in 1994, but it only lasted one season. Jackie Chan is big in the U.S. now, but he’s not American, and he stars as-what else-a martial artist. The rapper Jin, who played an important character in the movie 2 Fast 2 Furious, didn’t have his name or face on the movie’s poster, nor was he seen in the commercials or previews. Bruce Lee, who was born in San Francisco, was Asian-American, but his films were martial arts movies.
Charlie Chan Was White
According to the book Eastern Standard Time: A Guide to Asian Influence on American Culture from Astro Boy to Zen Buddhism, Hollywood has a long history of limiting Asian roles. And when the lead characters were supposed to be Asian, the roles often went to Whites instead. From 1931 to 1947, one of the few major Asian characters was Charlie Chan, a detective. But while the secondary roles of Charlie Chan’s sons went to Asian actors, Charlie Chan was played by White actors.
Similarly, a 1937 movie based on Pearl S. Buck’s novel The Good Earth had White people playing the role of Asians. Even the late 1970’s TV show Kung Fu discriminated against Asians in Hollywood.
The show was created by Bruce Lee and was supposed to have Bruce Lee as the main character, but the people working on it believed that America wasn’t ready for an Asian actor in a starring role. The role went to David Carradine, who is White.
For years, it seemed that the most common parts for Asian actors in American films were martial artist, shop owner, gang member, servant, nerd and prostitute. I don’t think we need to get rid of these stereotypical roles, because that would seem like an attempt to wash away realistic representations about the Asian-American community.
But if those figures remain the only representations of Asian-Americans, then the larger world of Asian-Americans is being left out. I’d like to see a more balanced picture of Asian-American life for those who aren’t familiar with Asian-Americans; even a glimpse might be a learning experience.
Playing With Stereotypes
Things are changing. ER features Ming-Na as an Asian-American doctor, and other TV shows like The Practice sometimes cast Asian-Americans as cops or teachers.
Even though it’s not my kind of movie, the 1993 film The Joy Luck Club, based on the book by Amy Tan and directed by Wayne Wang, had realistic portrayals of Chinese-American women and their immigrant mothers.
More recently, the 2002 movie Better Luck Tomorrow, directed by Justin Lin, focused on Asian-American high school students in California. The movie relies on but also plays with both the Asian gangster stereotype and the “model minority” stereotype (see p. 3), which assumes that all Asians are excellent, hardworking students. The main characters in this film are wholesome and good-natured in front of their teachers, while hiding their dangerous side-a life of crime.
Although I don’t want to see a new batch of stereotypical roles, like that of the overachieving math genius, I enjoy seeing a movie where Asian-Americans are the stars and those characters have full, complex lives.
Stars of Rap and Rock
Other fields of entertainment are starting to have more Asian-American representation, too. Asian rappers were pretty much an underground thing until the success of Jin (who won seven weeks in a row on BET’s 106 & Park Freestyle Fridays) and Southstar (one half of the rap duo Smilez and Southstar). In rock music, the Deftones’ bassist Chi Cheng is Chinese-American, and their lead singer Chino Moreno, whose father is Mexican-American, has some Chinese roots, too.
Seeing more Asian-Americans in different entertainment fields might help the rest of America get a fuller picture of what being Asian-American can be. In addition to a broader range of Asian-American roles in American movies and TV shows, I’d also like to hear more Asian-Americans speaking out against stereotypes.
Making Our Own Movies and Magazines
I’ve seen a few examples of Asian-Americans protesting injustice. For instance, in April 2002, Abercrombie & Fitch ran a line of shirts bearing derogatory Asian stereotypes, such as cartoonlike Chinese laundrymen with a jokey slogan. Within days, Asian-Americans began protesting the shirts, and the line was soon ditched.
And just outside the mainstream, young Asian-Americans are making their own magazines and films that take a more complete look at Asian-American communities. The same year that Better Luck Tomorrow came out, another Asian-American director, Eric Byler, released Charlotte Sometimes, an independent movie about four young Asian-Americans.
And this fall, Melissa Hung, an Asian-American, founded Hyphen, a new magazine out of San Francisco that focuses on Asian-American issues and culture.
When I hear about these projects, I realize the power not just of protest, but of people working together to provide alternatives to what they feel is wrong.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.