When Great Isn’t Good Enough

It was a tiring day at school, and I was glad to be going home. The last period, I’d gotten my chemistry test back and was happy to see that I got a 91.
As I opened the door, I found my mom where I usually find her, over the sink preparing dinner and washing the dishes.
“Hi, dear. How was your day?” she said, in Spanish.
“It was fine. I got my test back for chemistry. Look, I got a 91.”
“Let me see it,” she said, drying her hands on the dish towel and taking the test paper. “Just a 91.”
She Makes Me Feel I’m Not Good Enough
“Mom, that’s really good compared to what everybody else got.”
“Mm-hmm, and what did your friend get?”
“Oh, I think she got a 95 or something.”
“I guess she studied more than you did, didn’t she?” she said, handing me back the test. I stomped out of the kitchen.
It was typical of her to say that. I was so mad.
She makes me feel like I’m not good enough. I sometimes ask myself, “Why does she have to be like that?” The only answer I can think of is that maybe she pushes me hard to do well in school because she never got the education she wanted.
Parents Couldn’t Go to HS
Both my parents were born in Ecuador. Around their way there were no schools after 3rd grade. So after 3rd grade my dad stopped studying and started to help his parents by selling things like eggs.
My mom was able to get further. She was sent away to school until the 6th grade. Then when she was 16, she studied with the nuns for four years, learning mostly about religion and nursing. She was on her way to becoming a nun until she decided to get married and have children.
Even though neither of them made it through high school, my parents are very smart. Ever since they came here about 18 years ago, they’ve been able to support my younger brother Ronald and me, and I’m proud of them.
Dad works at a racetrack cleaning floors. I think he’d have loved to do something else, but he couldn’t get far with the education he had. He has a positive attitude, though, and says that at least he’s able to have food on the table for us every night.
Mom used to work in a factory, but now she’s dedicated to staying home and taking care of Ronald and me and the house. I think she’s proud of being a housewife. Still, Mom and Dad want a much better life for me.
Mom Taught Me Math
Their focus on education started early. Before I began kindergarten, Mom showed me basic addition and subtraction. I remember her sitting on the couch while I knelt on the floor next to her, paying close attention to what she was telling me. (She couldn’t really teach me reading because she spoke Spanish and didn’t know how to read or write much in English.)
When I hit kindergarten, I was the best student in the class in math. And it was like that from then on. I enjoyed getting good grades, but I also liked making my mom proud of me. She always congratulated me on my grades.
But in junior high, things began to get tougher. My grades went down, not dramatically, but enough to make my mom disappointed. Instead of the usual 100s and 95s, I was getting some 90s and 85s. Even a drop of a point on my report card upset her.
‘Next Time, Try Harder’
Whenever I brought home an imperfect test, she’d go into one of her speeches. “You see, next time try harder, and you will succeed,” or, “You should have studied more, then maybe you would have gotten a 100.” She even started to use reverse psychology on me. She’d say I couldn’t do things so I’d feel bad and try harder to prove to her that I could do it.
By 7th grade, I decided to show her only my best grades. Even now, I seldom tell her when I’m having a test.
When I do bring home an excellent grade, like a 100, she sounds like she doesn’t care. She says stuff like “Good,” and “Great,” but she doesn’t congratulate me like she does with Ronald, who’s a year younger than me.
He doesn’t do as well in school as I do-his grades are usually in the high 70s and 80s-but she doesn’t get on his case as much as she gets on mine.
‘Why Do You Ignore My Good Grades?’
When I was 15, I saw my mom congratulate Ron for a good grade. I asked her, “Why is it that when I get a good grade you just ignore it and say, ‘OK,’ but when Ronald gets a good grade, it’s a party?”
“That’s not true,” she said. “I’m always happy when you give me a good grade.”
“Well, you sure don’t show it. You always say, ‘Mm-hmm,’ or ‘That’s nice.’ “
“That’s because I know you have the potential to do it. That’s why you always have to put your batteries on, so that you can reach the top, and nobody will be able to stop you,” she said, raising her right hand in a fist and slamming it back down against her left palm.
It’s nice to know that she’s behind me, but it’s too much pressure to feel like I have to be perfect.
Silly To Care So Much
When I wasn’t valedictorian for elementary or junior high school, Mom was upset because it meant that I wasn’t the best. I thought it was kind of silly to care about that. I mean, I wasn’t valedictorian, but I certainly had a high ranking.
I think Mom might be afraid that if I’m not the best, I might turn into one of those girls she watches out the window, walking in their slippers and ragged clothes, not really caring about their appearance, the ones who’ve dropped out of school and hang out with boys all the time.
She knows from experience that it’s hard to go through life without an education, but I find it annoying to hear the same thing over and over again.
I Blow Up Sometimes
I’ve never given her any reason to worry that I’d drop out of school to hang out all the time. She knows me better than that, but she sure doesn’t act like it.
I blow up sometimes when I get too much from her, like when she says I’m “malcriada,” which means someone who misbehaves. When she’s so critical, it makes me feel almost as if she wants me to be somebody else, somebody better. That hurts me.
“I do study! The tests are hard. So what if I miss a few questions!”
“That’s not the point,” she says. “You should study every day so that you can get a better score. One day when you’re older and have your own place to live and a job, you’re going to come back and say, ‘Thank you, Mom, for all you’ve done.’ You just watch.”
She’s Got a Point
It’s irritating, but in a way, I think she’s right. As much as my mom’s constant nagging about my schoolwork drives me crazy, I don’t think I’d be as careful with my schoolwork without it. I also might not care as much about my education, though you won’t catch me telling her that.
But I do take my work and my grades seriously-for me, not for Mom. I know perfectly well that it’s going to help me in life, not her. That’s why I chose to go a competitive school, Science Skills Center HS, and why last quarter I received 90s and above in all my classes except for an 85 in global history.
Dad’s More of a Fan
I wish my mom would see how much I try and would be more encouraging. My father supports me more. Sometimes when he’s around, he backs me up when my mom starts bugging me about my grades. It feels good to have a fan.
I know the support is there. Mom drops hints to me about how much doctors make, even though I’ve told her I want to be a journalist. But when people ask her what my goals are, she tells them proudly that I want to be a journalist.
I know my mom loves me and is proud of me. I’d just feel a whole lot better if she’d show me that she’s my fan, too.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.