The chaos begins on the first page of Francine Prose’s After, as cell phones ring all at once in every classroom at Central HS. There’s been a shooting at the school in a nearby town, and concerned parents are calling their children to make sure they’re OK. A grief and crisis counselor is hired the next day, even though Central’s students don’t feel greatly affected by the shooting.
Soon, new rules restricting student behavior come into effect, like no wearing red, because the shooters at the other high school were wearing red. Metal detectors are installed at the school entrances, students have their lockers and bookbags searched, and random drug testing is enforced.
Then students are forbidden to bring hip-hop music to school, or books like The Catcher in the Rye. Any loner student who doesn’t appear to have friends is seen as a threat to the school and suspended.
The story is told through the eyes of Tom Bishop, a sophomore on the school basketball team. Like the rest of his classmates, Tom thinks the new rules are unfair. “Why should we lose anything because some lunatics went ballistic at a school 50 miles away?” he says.
He and his friends are scared of Mr. Willner, the new grief and crisis counselor who soon takes over the school. They try to obey his rules, even though they think the rules are completely unnecessary, if not downright ridiculous.
Rule-Breakers Disappear
Any rule breaking, and the consequences are serious. On the first day of the new dress code rule against wearing anything red, a student named Stephanie Tyrone, who’s worn a red ribbon every day since her older brother died of AIDS, refuses to take off her ribbon. The next day, she and her family disappear. Teachers who don’t enforce every rule begin disappearing also.
Parents tell their children that the school is just trying to protect them. But when does protection start becoming a threat? It turns out that dozens of students are being sent away to reform camps.
‘Zero Tolerance’ Gone Too Far
After is Francine Prose’s skeptical take on the “zero tolerance” policies that have plagued high schools across the U.S., especially since the Columbine school shootings. Zero tolerance is where a school will suspend or expel any student who breaks any rule, even if it’s unreasonably restrictive.
Some schools go overboard, like one in Portland, Maine, which expelled a student for taking Tylenol for her headache because it went against the school’s drug-control rules. And a school in Virginia suspended a boy because he dyed his hair blue; it was considered a “disruptive” style of dress.
In After, Prose suggests that these “zero tolerance” methods provide only a false sense of security for adults and end up doing the students more harm than good. Such regulations enforce a cookie-cutter student ideal rather than valuing freedom and individuality.
I Started Following the Rules
It’s creepy how realistic the story was. While reading the book, I felt like I was really living life at Central HS. I found myself following the school’s rules, taking out “dangerous” items like nail clippers from my bag before school and then realizing that they actually weren’t forbidden at my own school.
After absorbed me into the story, and it was hard to put the book down. The simple yet descriptive writing made it easy to read. It’s one of those books that made me forget the world around me.
The last book that captivated me like that was Harry Potter, although when reading Harry Potter I could tell that the story and characters were fictitious.
Fact or Fiction?
The only thing that sounded a little too much like science fiction in the book was the idea of camps out in the wilderness where problem children get sent to for rehabilitation. But then, I found out that there are actual rehabilitation camps like that. They’re usually very rigorous programs, similar to boot camps. There’ve even been a few reported deaths at these camps.
Learning that these rehabilitation boot camps do, in fact, exist, gave me an eerie feeling that the horrible events taking place at Central High could become a reality at any time in a school in America. After leaves you wondering how far we really are from losing our freedoms.
At Central High, the Students Are Disappearing
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.