Rocking-and Shocking-with Nirvana

I was 7 when the band Nirvana released their hit album In Utero. For some odd reason, as a little kid, I was a huge fan of Nirvana’s trademark sound: pained howls, heavy distortion, and angst-ridden lyrics. Perhaps I was hitting my teenage years early.
I got the album only a few days after its release. I was with my mom, holding her hand on line at Sam Goody. (This wasn’t quite as funny as when I went through my rap phase and Mom got me N.W.A.’s Greatest Hits for Christmas.) She assumed that In Utero couldn’t be that bad. So, hand in oblivious hand, we walked up to the cash register.
That evening, my best friend Kevin and I sat on my floor listening to In Utero and pretending to know the meaning of lines like “I wish I could eat your cancer when you turn black.”
Felt the Controversy of ‘Rape Me’
Then a sorrowful wail jumped out of the speakers. We were stunned silent. This was the coolest song we’d ever heard. It was “Rape Me.”
We could feel the controversy of the phrase, even though we had no clue what it meant. We loved it.
Giggling, we went and woke my father from a nap to ask him what “rape me” meant. Puzzled and panicked, he quickly said that it meant “hug me” and went back to sleep.
We weren’t fooled. We could smell a parent’s lie. The alarm in my father’s eyes clued me in that the word rape might have something to do with sex. Any word that had anything to do with male-female relations was like the holy grail to me. The song suddenly seemed even cooler.
Delighted in Shocked Looks
From then on, “Rape Me” was in constant rotation at my house. It was my way of being mischievous. Plus, the song doesn’t have a lot of words, so I could sing along and get it right.
I delighted in the shocked looks that my parents shot over my head. Every time I sung along, I felt like I was getting away with something, so of course I kept playing it. I don’t know why they didn’t just turn it off.
Eventually, though, they got fed up. This was probably because I had a habit of waiting for other adults to visit the house and then blasting the song, pretending to be oblivious to their gaping. After another one of their friends left shaking her head, my parents finally told me what “rape” meant in a very grave and serious tone.
Too Sad to Listen
I still thought that the song was cool, but I also felt guilty and sad about rape victims’ suffering every time I sang along. Plus I’d already gotten some rebellion out of my system, so I quit listening to the song so much.
Shortly thereafter, Kurt Cobain killed himself. It became far too sad for me to listen to much Nirvana.
“Rape Me” faded to a faint memory, as I grew more interested in brilliant artists like P. Diddy. About two years ago, though, I started to listen to Nirvana again.
My favorite Nirvana songs have become even cooler to me, now that I understand them better. For instance, I figured out that “Polly” was the lament of a deranged kidnapper instead of just a guy talking to a parrot.
Understanding Cobain’s Pain
“Rape Me” has also gained new significance in my old age. Cobain spends three minutes begging for someone to rape him, not literally, but psychologically. To be raped is to be degraded, sullied, sexually violated, and Cobain was inviting this upon himself.
But it makes sense that the lyrics are so painful and shocking because that’s where he was at emotionally. The depression, self-loathing, and drug abuse that he experienced couldn’t have been wrapped up and tied in a nice, easily accessible bow for the fans.
He was genuine, giving us an honest slice of his world, and that’s bound to be unsettling and powerful.
Sometimes, especially when I’m listening to the song with other people, “Rape Me” catches me off guard. I become filled with horror as he sings the words over and over again.
The Essence of Rock and Roll
“Rape Me” isn’t Nirvana’s best song, or even its most popular, but it showed a giant middle finger to anybody with squeamish ears. That’s just so rock and roll.
I still love that song. As a child, it marked the first time that I equated music with the power to shake people up. And as a teen, I understand how the song makes us look at the pain we tend to ignore.
That’s rock and roll. That’s hip-hop. That’s reggae. It’s the essence of innovative music, the stuff that gets us so excited as it sneers at those who don’t get it.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.