Do I Want to Be Adopted?

“Wow, can they really be taking me to lunch and giving me authentic jewelry? I just met them a few weeks ago and they’re giving me gifts for my birthday, which passed six months ago. What’s going on?”
The couple had given me a 14k gold chain with a real sapphire diamond on it and a pair of earrings to match. They had a nice, big house upstate where they wanted to take my sister and me, and they were planning to take us to Maine for the summer. They wanted to adopt my sister and me from foster care, and we had to decide quickly whether we wanted them to be our parents or not.
My sister and I came into foster care with no parents and no relatives anyone could find. My pops died from cancer and my moms died about two years later from a heart attack. (Both of them were alcoholics and smokers.) My sister was 10 and I was 12 years old when my mother died.
Put in the Adoption Album
When we came into care, my social worker told us that she was going to take pictures of my sister and me. “Why?” I asked. She said she needed to put our pictures in a book, “just for the record.”
I didn’t know that the pictures would go into a book that families wanting a child would look at. I didn’t know those pictures would lead to such a serious issue-adoption.
A lot of people get foster care and adoption mixed up, but they’re really very different. When you’re in foster care, you really belong to the city, and foster parents or group home staff are paid to take care of you.
When you’re adopted, you become part of a family and no one pays that family. If the family buys you new clothes, they take the money out of their own pocket. But the main difference between adoption and foster care is that adoption is permanent and foster care isn’t. If you’re adopted, you’re in that home for good.
The Fish Bite
About a year and a half after I took the pictures, it seemed that everyone wanted me to be adopted.
“We have a nice family for you who lives upstate. Do you want to be adopted?” my social worker asked.
“You want me to adopt you?” my adult friend, Gia asked. Gia is 33 years old and like a godmother to me. When I lived with my mother, she lived in an apartment upstairs from us. My sister and I saw her almost every weekend when we first went into care. Now she buys me things whenever I’m in need and my foster mother doesn’t help out.
Even my best friend Monika said, “When I have more space, maybe I can adopt you, right?” And my foster mother wondered, “Do ya want to be adopted by me?”
Which Family Should I Choose?
Did I have to be adopted? Who would I choose as my family? Could I wait before deciding?
Luckily, I was old enough that they had to get my permission before anyone adopted me. My sister wasn’t old enough, but they don’t like to split up siblings. So I was the one who got to make the decision. But what would I choose?
Back then, I thought adoption meant that I would belong to a family all over again. I thought that I could become close to that family, but not as close as I was to my real parents.
Even if the new parents were great, they couldn’t fully take the place of my real parents. My biological parents raised me and made me who I am today. For some family to think they could just claim that they’re my parents now made me feel uncertain about them.
Still, I thought it would be good to be part of a family again, with parents who would choose to adopt me and really care about me. But who knew if I’d go into a family that really cared about me, or one that would abuse or neglect me? It was kind of like playing the lottery. I couldn’t really tell what a family was like by going out to dinner with them a few times.
Did I Want to Be Adopted?
My sister and I met with the couple from upstate a few times. They asked how I was doing and about school. That made me feel like they were interested and cared about me, unlike my foster mother who never asked those types of questions.
They seemed like perfect parents since there was a mother and a father, and they were married and lived in a house. They also showed their affection by getting me gifts for my birthday, which my foster mother doesn’t do.
I did and didn’t want to be adopted by them. I did because it would be only my sister and me in a big, beautiful house. Also, the couple seemed to really like us.
But I didn’t want to go because of how far it would be from Brooklyn. I didn’t want to leave my best friends because they’d been there for me since before my mother died. One of my friends raised money for my mother’s memorial and burial. And I wouldn’t want to lose Gia and her boyfriend Andrew by moving somewhere far away.
But most of all, the whole thing made me feel strange. I felt like the family was trying to buy us. They spent so much money in the little time they knew us, and we know from the Beatles that money can’t buy love, and from J. Lo that love don’t cost a thing.
Before I went into foster care, my mother, sister, grandmother, roommate, and I were living in the ghetto where there were drug dealers, roaches, and rats. We were in a very small, $600 apartment of three rooms. We lived off my mother’s welfare check, my grandmother’s social security check, and the money that our roommate sometimes gave us. We were poor.
But if I had to choose to live with someone rich or live in the ghetto with my mother, I would definitely choose my mother.
I was so confused about what to do about the couple upstate. I felt flattered that they wanted to adopt me, scared that if I turned them down I might hurt them, and worried that if I let them adopt me and my sister, they might hurt us.
Pressure to Choose
Some people were telling me to be adopted and some were telling me not to. Gia and Andrew were telling me not to because we wouldn’t be able to see them. My social worker really wanted me to be adopted. She thinks it’s best for foster kids to have permanent homes, and people they can turn to when they’re trying to become independent adults.
I thought about it for a month. I knew it was a decision that would change my life forever. Then my sister and I decided to turn the upstate family down.
That was well over a year ago. But I still sometimes wonder about how my life would be if I were with that family upstate.
After I turned the family upstate down, Gia and Andrew wanted to adopt us. I knew they were great people with good advice and care, but still something was holding me back. It took me a while to figure it out, but I felt that I had to be the way they expected me to be or else they wouldn’t like me or accept me.
It wasn’t something I felt about just them. I felt that being in foster care had taught me how to adapt to everyone’s lifestyle, but I hadn’t yet figured out what my own lifestyle was.
What Kind of Family Do I Want?
When I go to my friend Monica’s house, we go to church on Sunday. If we don’t we kind of get in trouble. But with Gia’s, it’s the opposite-she and her boyfriend are not religious people, and they don’t want my sister and me to go to church when we’re with them.
When I go to Gia’s, we usually watch TV, talk, and eat together. But in my foster home, I come home and go straight upstairs to my room. My foster mother and I don’t eat or watch TV together.
When I’m with my friends I like to wear name-brand clothes, but Gia doesn’t care for clothes with logos.
I felt like if I got adopted, I’d have to pick one person’s way of living. I would have one clear family. But would it be the kind I wanted? It was like choosing how I should be: Should I act religious or not? Should I watch TV or read a book? Could I wear this?
Turning Down Adoption
After I turned down Gia and Andrew, I also turned down the whole idea of adoption, period! I told my social worker to change my goal from adoption to independent living. Independent living means I will live in a foster home until I’m 18 or 21, and then I’ll be on my own.
Today, I’m still in a foster home. I’m glad that I decided to stay in foster care because I see all my friends regularly, and if I feel my foster mother is treating me wrong, I’ll be able to move. I’m also glad because when I graduate from high school, my agency will pay for my room and board in college until I’m 21.
I sometimes think about how all those people wanted to adopt me. I do think it would be great to be part of a family again-especially if the family was perfect. (Ha ha, yeah right!)
But I also don’t believe that I can fully be part of a family again. It can come very close, like when I hang with my friends, but deep down inside I think that it can’t be the same. No one can replace the love that was between my mother and me. My mother had been there since I was born. She knew me better than myself at times, and I knew she definitely loved me.
This story originally appeared in the July/August 2002 issue of Foster Care Youth United.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.