These days, when Child Services comes knocking on the door, parents usually feel like social workers are there to judge, not to help. Many parents are under a lot of stress and could use help, but they don’t want to admit it because they’re too afraid their kids will get taken away. If parents believed that child services would provide help like day care, therapy or even financial assistance, families might grow stronger and kids would stay safer.
That’s why a number of states have started using a system call “dual track” to investigate families that are suspected of abusing or neglecting their children. Dual track makes sure that kids are removed from danger, but it also helps troubled families without making them feel like criminals.
Dual track requires a child protective worker to first decide whether a situation is serious enough to warrant a traditional investigation, where the cupboards are checked and the entire family is interviewed one at a time. If it doesn’t seem too serious, the worker can set the family up with other kinds of support.
Then a social worker will come to the house, not to decide whether the kids should be removed from the home, but just to find out how the family is doing. The social worker talks with the family about how likely it is that a child will be hurt in the future, and they figure out the best ways to prevent that from happening.
It’s a little bit of a strange thing because the workers do still have the power to remove a child if they feel that the child is in danger. But the biggest goal is to help keep a family together.
So far, in states with dual track, experts say that it seems like families feel less threatened and more supported by the system. Once caseworkers got used to it, they were happier with the process as well. Still, it’s unclear so far whether dual track helps kids do better in the long run. New York City is considering using dual track.
Personally, I do think dual track is a good idea if it keeps kids from being harmed without splitting up families unnecessarily, as long as caseworkers don’t overlook kids who really do need to be removed.
-Princess Carr
Dual Track: Child Welfare Lends a Hand
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.